User:DumbBOT/RfArSummary/Giano

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Summary of Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Giano/Proposed_decision (experimental)

  • Majority: 4
  • Total: 7
Color legend
Passed
Rejected
Cannot pass with current votes


Number Title Support Oppose Abstain Status
1 Requests for adminship 6 0 0 Passed
2 Bureaucrats 6 0 0 Passed
3 Consensus 5 0 0 Passed
4 Advantages of consensus 6 0 0 Passed
5 Problems with consensus 6 0 0 Passed
6 The effect of failure of consensus 5 0 0 Passed
7 Administrator conduct 6 0 0 Passed
8 Second chances 5 0 0 Passed
9 Decisions are final 5 0 0 Passed
10 Appeal of a decision by Bureaucrats 1 3 0
11 Criticism welcome 4 0 1 Passed
12 Being upset 4 0 0 Passed
13 Wikipedia is not a battleground 4 0 0 Passed
14 Disruption 5 0 0 Passed
15 Disruption by administrators 6 0 0 Passed
16 Return to administrative status of desysopped administrators 1 1 1
17 Courtesy 6 0 0 Passed
18 Assume good faith 2 1 0
19 Discussion of controversial decisions 5 0 0 Passed
20 Productive policy discussion differentiated from trolling 3 2 1
21 Baiting 6 0 0 Passed
22 Taking the bait 2 1 1
23 A mixed system 1 4 0 Rejected
23.5 Contributors are valued 1 0 0
24 Respect 1 4 0 Rejected
25 Blocking of administrators and other wheels for disruption 1 2 1
26 Jurisdiction of the Arbitration Committee 5 0 0 Passed
27 Return of access levels 6 0 0 Passed
1 Carnildo 1 3 1 Cannot pass with current votes
2 Resysopping 5 0 0 Passed
3 Wikipedia:Requests for adminship/Carnildo 3 5 0 0 Passed
4 Failure to achieve consensus 5 0 0 Passed
5 Closing of Carnildo's request for adminship 5 0 0 Passed
6 Opposition to closing of RfA 5 0 0 Passed
7 Giano's role in opposing the decision 5 0 0 Passed
8 John Reid's role in opposing the decision 5 0 0 Passed
9 Kelly Martin 4 0 0 Passed
10 Tony Sidaway 5 0 0 Passed
11 Giano 4 0 0 Passed
12 Giano II 6 0 0 Passed
13 JoshuaZ 5 0 0 Passed
14 Geogre 1 2 2 Cannot pass with current votes
15 Irpen 6 0 0 Passed
16 Jdforrester 6 0 0 Passed
17 Inksplotch is not a sockpuppet 1 3 0
17.1 Checkuser on Inksplotch does not find sockpuppeting 5 0 0 Passed
1 Carnildo restored to Administrative status 1 1 3 Cannot pass with current votes
2 John Reid is banned for one week 3 3 0
2.1 John Reid is strongly censured 2 2 0
3 Kelly Martin thanked 4 0 0 Passed
4 Tony Sidaway suspended 1 4 0 Rejected
4A Tony Sidaway's sysop access 6 0 0 Passed
5 Giano II 6 0 0 Passed
6 Geogre desysopped 1 4 0 Rejected
7 Jdforrester reminded 4 0 0 Passed
8 Kelly Martin's sysop/checkuser/oversight access 6 0 0 Passed