User:DumbBOT/RfArSummary/Attack sites

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Summary of Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Attack_sites/Proposed_decision (experimental)

  • Majority: 6
  • Total: 11
Color legend
Passed
Rejected
Cannot pass with current votes


Number Title Support Oppose Abstain Status
1 Freedom of Expression 9 0 0 Passed
2 No personal attacks 8 0 0 Passed
3 Harassment 8 0 0 Passed
4 Linking to external sites 5 2 0
4.1 Linking to external sites as harassment 5 1 0
4.2 Linking to external sites as harassment 7 0 0 Passed
7 Dealing with harassment 3 3 1
7.1 ... but no purging of sites 3 2 0
7.2 ... but not of oneself 5 1 0
11 External links 6 0 0 Passed
14 Scope of Arbitration 7 1 0 Passed
15 Malicious sites 5 3 0
15.1 Malicious sites 6 1 0 Passed
15.2 Malicious sites 3 0 0
17 Criticism 2 3 1
19 Big shots 1 4 0
20 Don't panic 5 0 0
22 Over-reaction 4 1 0
22.1 Don't over-react 6 0 0 Passed
23 Satire 6 0 0 Passed
24 Anonymity and conflict of interest 7 0 0 Passed
32 Investigation of prohibited links 6 0 0 Passed
36 Editors have no special protection 1 4 0
36.1 All living individuals deserve protection 3 4 0
37 Error 6 0 0 Passed
38 Fighting back 6 0 0 Passed
39 Struggle 6 0 0 Passed
40 NPA 5 1 0
41 NPOV 1 1 0
1 AntiSocialMedia.net 7 0 0 Passed
2 Attack sites 3 4 0
4 Suppression of references to external sites 7 0 0 Passed
5 BADSITES 4 2 0
5.1 BADSITES 3 0 0
6 Inappropriate application of policy 7 0 0 Passed
7 Teresa Nielsen Hayden 2 2 0
7.1 Teresa Nielsen Hayden 1 3 0
8 Sorting out 6 0 0 Passed
12 Michael Moore 3 2 0
13 Cyde 3 1 0
14 Don Murphy 2 2 0
1 Salt the earth 2 5 0
1.1 AntiSocialMedia.net 1 0 0
2 Ban 2 5 0
2.2 Ban 1 0 0
3 Policy matter remanded to the community 1 6 0 Rejected
3.1 Policy matter remanded to the community 4 2 0
3.2 Policy matter remanded to the community 6 2 0 Passed
3.3 The community is encouraged to develop a policy 5 0 0
4 Editors encouraged 8 0 0 Passed
5 Scope of this decision 4 1 0
5.1 Scope of this decision 6 1 0 Passed
6 Other sites 1 5 0
6 A wait 1 5 0
7 Advice to aggrieved parties 7 0 0 Passed
8 When in Rome 1 5 0
9 Cyde 1 6 0 Rejected
9.1 Cyde 2 5 0
1 Enforcement by block 4 1 0
1.1 Enforcement by block 1 0 0
2 Arbitration proceedings exempted 1 5 0