Dobie Gillis Williams

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Dobie Gillis Williams (1961 – January 8, 1999) was a convicted American murderer. He was tried and executed in Louisiana for the murder of Sonja Knippers. In 2005, Williams was the subject of a book by anti-death penalty activist Sister Helen Prejean in which she asserts the position that Williams was wrongfully executed, due to ineffective legal counsel and the fact that poor people are executed more than others.

Contents

[edit] Overview

Williams entered the home of Charles and Sonja Knippers in the early morning hours of July 8, 1984. He attained entry by stacking two milk crates outside the Knippers' bathroom window and then cutting the screen. When Sonja Knippers went to the bathroom some time later, Williams locked the door and began stabbing Sonja with a knife.

Herb Knippers unsuccessfully attempted to break down the bathroom door during the attack. Williams then fled the scene, exiting through the same bathroom window through which he entered. Sonja Knippers opened the door on her own, and was helped to a couch. Herb told investigators that he heard his wife yelling that a black man was killing her. She bled to death shortly afterwards.

At the time of the murder, Williams was on a five day furlough from Camp Beauregard where had been imprisoned for attempted simple burglary. He was allowed the visit because he was considered a model prisoner and not prone to violence. He was staying at his grandfather's home, which was approximately 0.4 miles (0.6km) from the Knippers residence.

Williams had been seen approximately one hour prior to the murder walking away from his grandfather's house. Investigating detectives were aware of Williams' criminal record and picked Williams up for questioning. They told him they would be there until they "...got what they wanted."

A subsequent medical examination revealed scratches and abrasions on his body that were consistent with the type of wounds one would expect an individual to have after quickly exiting through the Knippers' bathroom window.

After further questioning, three police officers testified that Dobie confessed. He told the officers that after the stabbing he jumped out of the bathroom window, dropped the knife in the Knippers' yard, and ran to his grandfather's house where he hid his shirt underneath the porch. After Williams made his statement, the investigators returned to the Knippers' home where they found a kitchen knife in four inches of damp grass. The officers later retrieved the shirt from the place where Williams hid it. Although no confession was obtained, an unsuccessful attempt was made to record the statement mechanically; at the trial, several investigating detectives testified as to the content of the William’s confession.

Further forensic analysis of the crime scene confirmed that the blood found on the Knippers' bathroom window curtain matched Williams' blood type – a blood type very rare among black people. The analysis further confirmed that the blood could not have come from either Sonja or Charles Knippers. Hair was also taken from the window, and was also found to have characteristics consistent with Williams' hair. However, a second team of DNA analysts found major issues with the first set of tests: sloppy technique, poor quality controls, and subjective interpretation. One test had one in four controls fail, but the lab used the faulty results to draw conclusions anyway. Finally, the autopsy revealed that the stab wounds in the victim's body were consistent with the type of wounds that would have been made by the knife found in the Knippers' yard.

[edit] Trial

Williams was indicted by a Sabine Parish Grand Jury of First Degree Murder in violation of Louisiana Revised Statute (R.S.) 14:30. A Motion for a Change of Venue filed by the defendant was granted, which resulted in the transfer of the case to the 35th Judicial District Court in Grant Parish. After a four day trial, the all-white jury returned a verdict of guilty as charged. At the sentencing phase of the trial, the jury unanimously recommended the death penalty, which the judge imposed.

[edit] Execution

On January 8, 1999, Williams was executed by lethal injection at the Louisiana State Penitentiary. Williams ate twelve candy bars and some ice cream for his last meal.[1] In his final statement, Williams said "I just want to say, I don't have any hard feelings against anybody. God bless y'all. God bless."

[edit] Wrongfully executed?

In 2005, Williams was the subject of anti-death penalty activist and Catholic nun Sister Helen Prejean’s book The Death of Innocents: An Eyewitness Account of Wrongful Executions. Prejean's arguments against his execution do not offer any kind of proof that Williams did not commit the crimes, but rather that his defense at trial did not offer mitigating circumstances during the sentencing. The defense did not point out that his I.Q. was 65.[2] Prejean's other point was that poor people are more likely to receive the death penalty than others.[2]

[edit] See also

[edit] References

  1. ^ Jessica Wehrman (2000-03-05). Last meal for condemned criminals an old tradition. Scripps Howard News Service.[dead link]
  2. ^ a b Dave Lindorff. Unjust executions. Salon.com (2003-05-06). Retrieved on 2007-11-11.