User talk:Dimdamdocdim
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
[edit] Scientists
- People who have reached the position of full professor at major universities have inevitably published much more than the average scientist, and therefore meet WP:PROF. Such articles are always upheld at Afd. I am therefore removing the PROD on Neil Risch . I cannot prevent you from taking it to AfD, but it will be a speedy keep almost certainly.
- Noah Rosenberg is more dubious. He is just an Assistant professor, but he had published 45 papers in very good journals. It might be taken to AfD, it is worth a discussion. Most but not all assistant professors are deleted there--it would depend on the citations to his work. I placed a notability tag, & I leave it to your judgment.
- Pardis Sabeti is interesting. She's just a postdoc, which is rarely notable, but he has received awards that have been documented in RSs, and thus meets the general notability requirement. I can foresee an interesting discussion if you bring it to AfD,as I think you should. I do not know what the community will decide.
Please try to discriminate when you place prods. Good work on spotting Rosenberg and Sardis, though. I notice your user name, but I point out that Risch & Sabeti both have documentation, DGG (talk) 18:02, 29 January 2008 (UTC)
