Talk:Die Hochzeit/Comments

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Middle of Stub range (18 points). There may be limited scope for developing this article. After all it's a non-existent opera. (Possibly better not to have started it?). However some things can be done:

• Give full details of the recording and any others, including the name of the author of the booklet.
• Check references in the main biographical works to see if there is any background information that can be added.

-- Kleinzach 01:04, 7 September 2007 (UTC)

Since this isn't really an opera, it can't be assessed according to the Project's opera articles points system or Opera Quality Scale. I have therefore used the WP grading scheme, and it seems to me to be low Start-class rather than Stub-class. As noted above, there probably isn't a lot more that can be said (and it's not clear that there are any recordings of what still exists, which, incidentally, is more than just a septet), but the article can certainly be improved by the addition of extra background information, including the source for the libretto. --GuillaumeTell 21:30, 19 September 2007 (UTC)

Start. I tend to agree that the opera marking scheme can't be properly applied here and would distort the assessment. There is enough basic information here the article to have some use to readers. Therefore I'm inclined to give it a low start per GT. I agree that Newman or another biography should be used to look for information. And from what GT says, there obviously is more information available. It therefore ought to be able to develop the article sufficiently to in theory reach GA standard.--Peter cohen 11:59, 20 September 2007 (UTC)