Wikipedia talk:Deletion review/Log/2007 February 15

[edit] Comment on "The noob" review posted after discussion was closed

Relist/Overturn The main source of DELETEs for this article seem to be one dogged user with an agenda and those incensed by the sockpuppetry. Very little discussion of the merits of the AfD actually occurred once the sockpuppets showed up. This is not a case of a Frindle or similar nonsense; it is a well-recognized comic. IMHO, the page should be de-salted and then relisted, so as to allow any necessary notability references to be added and then critiqued. This change was far too sudden and, seemingly, far too unilateral. Jouster 21:55, 20 February 2007 (UTC) Comment moved from review discussion to here —Doug Bell ^talk 22:07, 20 February 2007 (UTC)