- Nial Djuliarso (edit|talk|history|links|watch|logs) (restore|cache|AfD)
The article Nial Djuliarso has been deleted again for the second time. I am tired of having to explain that Nial Djuliarso is a prominent musician in Indonesia. I created the page of Nial Djuliarso. Although he is not notable in the US, he is a notable jazz musician in Indonesia, because he's a child prodigy of jazz and has created a number of recordings which won awards in Indonesia. Deletion of his article is regretted. Again, I am really sad that Wikipedia uses American standard for notability, while ignoring people from developing countries. We can see categories such as Indonesian Journalist, Indonesian Musician, and Nial Djuliarso is one of them. (Sorry for the late comment regarding this matter because I was away to give birth of my son). The AFD has been discussed many times, it has been contested and approved to be reinstated. Please explain why Nial Djuliarso is deleted again on January 23. Chaerani (talk) 14:34, 16 February 2008 (UTC)
- Endorse deletion (as closing administrator) The requester has mischaracterized the deletion processes that have occurred. Here is what really happened:
-
- 02:27, 23 January 2008 Jerry (Talk | contribs | block) deleted "Nial Djuliarso" (AFD: Deleted after discussion at Articles for Deletion) (Restore)
- 06:22, 10 January 2008 Stormie (Talk | contribs | block) restored "Nial Djuliarso" (28 revisions restored: Contested PROD: Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2008 January 10)
- 03:26, 10 September 2007 Coredesat (Talk | contribs | block) deleted "Nial Djuliarso" (Expired PROD, concern was: Non-notable musician.) (Restore)
- --- You will see that what happenned is that an editor placed a prod notice on the article, which means that they felt the article was a very clear candidate for deletion, and that deletion would likely be non-controversial. They placed a warning template on the creator's (requester of this DRV) talk page, as well diff. After 5 days this prod notice was not removed, per the instructions on the template, so it was then assumed that deletion was indeed non-controversial. Therefore Coredesat deleted the article after a likely quick, undetailed review.
- --- Somebody went to deletion review and questioned the undeletion. Our policy in such a case, (where the deletion was the result of an expired prod), is to immediately restore the article without any detailed review of its merit. Therefore Stormie did in fact restore the article.
- --- As is typical in such a case, it was subsequently nominated for deletion at WP:AFD. That was the first and only time that the article received detailed scrutiny from the community. I closed this deletion debate as delete, following the rough consensus guidelines. JERRY talk contribs 16:35, 16 February 2008 (UTC)
- Request for undeletion for the above reason by me (Meutia Chaerani). Plus I was not available to participate in AFD discussion. Nial Djuliarso is notable Jazz Musician in Indonesia, the same as Indra Lesmana and other Indonesian Musician. (Please correct me if this is the correct procedure to request for undeletion) Chaerani (talk) 16:44, 16 February 2008 (UTC)
-
- Would you consider instead the temporary userfication of the article to User:Chaerani/Nial Djuliarso, to give you an opportunity to address the notability and sourcing concerns? Then you could just improve it and ask me to cross-namespace move it to the main space it was previously in. If you accept this, then just request closure of this delrev request as userfication. JERRY talk contribs 16:50, 16 February 2008 (UTC)
- Thank you for your response. The problem is that now I do not know what was the objection that had caused the deletion. Specifically, which references that has been cited there that is considered as inadequate to the admin standard. If you're able to restore the full article under my page, inclusive the full talk page, plus, list down the concerns that had caused deletion in that talk page, I would agree to accept this interim solution. Chaerani (talk) 17:16, 16 February 2008 (UTC)
- You seem to misunderstand the deletion process, in general, and also seem very much not familiar with WP:N, WP:V, and WP:RS. The administrators who close deletion debates at AfD do not determine on their own, whether the article had adequate sourcing, in terms of doing extensive google searches, going to public libraries and looking at periodical guides, et cetera. These administrators, instead rely upon the remarks and recommendations made by those members of the community who choose to participate in the debates. The only subjective part of this process is to determine that the remarks left were made in good faith, are not inherantly flawed or counter-factual by obvious evidenciary review of the article, it's history and talk page, and the remarks left by others in the debate. Remarks left by very new contributors who have little or no edit history outside of the article under discussion and the debate itself are normally given lesser weighting, as are edits made by people identified as sockpuppets and/or single-purpose accounts. As far as not understanding the rationale for deletion, you really should read the afd itself; it is linked at the top of this deletion review, as added by you. Then review the policies and guidelines that I linked at the beginning of this paragraph. That is the information you need, and the only information I can provide to you. JERRY talk contribs 18:29, 16 February 2008 (UTC)
- Thank you for your explanation. Would it be possible for you to restore the article, either to the original namespace or under my userpage. I can't do improvement to the article unless it is restored to somewhere. I will yield to the decision of the admin to scrap the article (even though I don't agree with it, because as an Indonesian and if you ask other Indonesian people, we know that Nial Djuliarso is a renowned pianist in Indonesia - perhaps not in the USA but surely in Indonesia)Chaerani (talk) 01:10, 17 February 2008 (UTC)
- Notability argument:A musician or ensemble (note that this includes a band, singer, rapper, orchestra, DJ, musical theatre group, etc.) is notable if it meets any one of the following criteria:
- 1. It has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent from the musician/ensemble itself and reliable. Yes, Djuliarso has performed in Indonesian national televisions, for example in 2001 ANTV giving music education workshop. Moreover, to my knowledge, the old Wikipedia article has contained independent news article of Djuliarso.
- 2. Has had a charted hit on any national music chart. I am checking on this one
- 3. Has had a record certified gold or higher in at least one country. I am checking on this one
- 4. Has received non-trivial coverage in a reliable source of an international concert tour, or a national concert tour in at least one sovereign country. National concert in Indonesia definitely: he has performed in Java Jazz and Jak Jazz, two most prominent annual jazz festival in Indonesia. Also he has performed in Mosaic Music Festival Singapore and North Sea Jazz Festival Netherlands, two prominent world jazz festival.
- 5. Has released two or more albums on a major label or one of the more important indie labels (i.e. an independent label with a history of more than a few years and a roster of performers, many of which are notable). He has released two jazz albums from a Omega Pacific Production, and Indonesian Jazz label.
- 7. Has become the most prominent representative of a notable style or of the local scene of a city; note that the subject must still meet all ordinary Wikipedia standards, including verifiability.** He is Indonesian Jazz Pianist.
- 8. Has won or been nominated for a major music award, such as a Grammy, Juno, Mercury or Grammis award. He has won awards albeit not major to american standard as above
- 9. Has won or placed in a major music competition. He has won many competitions for young pianist, it is listed in the old article.
- 10. Has performed music for a work of media that is notable, e.g. a theme for a network television show, performance in a television show or notable film, inclusion on a compilation album, etc. (But if this is the only claim, it is probably more appropriate to have a mention in the main article and redirect to that page.) I am checking on this one
- 11. Has been placed in rotation nationally by any major radio network. Yes this is applicable for Indonesian radio network
- 12. Has been the subject of a half hour or longer broadcast across a national radio or TV network. Yes in Indonesian TV network, please see point 1.
—Preceding unsigned comment added by Chaerani (talk • contribs) 01:10, 17 February 2008
-
- Please examine the phrase the subject of, and contrast it with "appeared on", "mentioned in" and "quoted in". JERRY talk contribs 01:22, 17 February 2008 (UTC)
- Thank you. You are disputing criteria no.1. I try to explain: He became the key speaker and resourceperson on music education program in national Indonesian TV (ANTV) in 2001 due to his notability and musical skill relative to other musicians in Indonesia. Not strictly as "the subject of" but i would argue that it is one grey area. Also, for notability does not need to fulfill ALL of the above criteria, fulfilling one criteria can be considered as notable. As you can see, Djuliarso has already fulfilled at least one in Indonesian music scene. Sure, not in US or Western World music scene, but Djuliarso is an important musical personality for Indonesia. Chaerani (talk) 03:33, 17 February 2008 (UTC)
- Would you consider instead the temporary userfication of the article to User:Chaerani/Nial Djuliarso, to give you an opportunity to address the notability and sourcing concerns? Then you could just improve it and ask me to cross-namespace move it to the main space it was previously in. If you accept this, then just request closure of this delrev request as userfication. JERRY talk contribs 04:17, 17 February 2008 (UTC)
- OK provided that you will move the article once the sourcing issue is solved in line to WP:N. thank you Chaerani (talk) 09:46, 17 February 2008 (UTC)
|