Talk:David Helfgott

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article is within the scope of WikiProject Biography. For more information, visit the project page.
Biography Portal
Start This article has been rated as start-Class on the project's quality scale. [FAQ]
Flag
Portal
 David Helfgott is within the scope of WikiProject Australia, which aims to improve Wikipedia's coverage of Australia and Australia-related topics. If you would like to participate, visit the project page.
Start This article has been rated as start-class on the quality scale.
Low This article has been rated as low-importance on the importance scale.
This article is supported by WikiProject Australian music. See also P:AUSMUSIC.
Assessment comments

Contents

[edit] "Rise and Shine" subheading

Har... Har. Sp0ng 10:12, 10 July 2007 (UTC)

Hey, I couldn't think of a better way to describe that he'd had a movie about him and he rose to fame through it. It's short and sweet and just happens to be a common phrase. --lincalinca 12:36, 10 July 2007 (UTC)

Of course :) I found it amusing though! Sp0ng 05:34, 6 August 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Barely competent?

We currently have this:

Many of his recordings, especially that of Rachmaninoff's third piano concerto, have been criticized as lifeless and barely competent.

Shouldn't we at least cite such a scathing remark? --P3d0 20:27, August 28, 2005 (UTC)

Personally I think they were just being snarky. I mean he's not that great, but he's okay to listen to. I think they were somewhat justly annoyed though because truly great classical performers do not get that kind of media attention. Looking back the only thing Helfgott did to earn it was be mentally ill and have a movie made about it in his own lifetime. (Most movies about classical musicians seem to be done long after they die) I kind of figured some of the controversy concerning the movie would be here or at the Shine page though. As I recall some of his siblings indicated the movie was unfair to his father, invented allegations, and makes it seem like he was the main cause of his son's mental illness. (Which if Helfgott has schizo-affective disorder it's likely not mostly his Dad)--T. Anthony 23:36, 24 October 2005 (UTC)
Dude, he has a mental illness doesn't he? Seems a bit rough to say such things about probably the worlds best piano player with his condition. 202.191.107.161 07:24, 10 September 2006 (UTC)
No, they weren't being snarky, just honest. Unfortunately, the criticism that his playing is "lifeless and barely competent" is true. Anyone who compares a performance of his with that of a respected musician will hear the vast difference. As for him being the world's best pianist with a mental illness, even that is dubious; e.g. many people believe Glenn Gould had Asperger syndrome. But Gould is loved and respected for his musical genius, not for his illness. The bit at the end that says he played "The Bee" is likely inaccurate, as this is a violin & piano piece by Schubert. One would assume he played Rimsky-Korsakov's "Flight of the Bumblebee" as his did in the movie SHINE. 74.99.213.103 21:02, 25 December 2006 (UTC)
David Helfgott is not "the worlds best piano player with his condition." He's just the most famous one, and his fame is built on an extremely inaccurate movie. Rosier 08:45, 8 March 2007 (UTC)
Its inaccuracies mostly relate to his pianistic abilities, but the atrocities he endured in his life are, according to sources, if anything, highly accurate, if played down for the purposes of being bearable. Films have been made about people who've been far less notable and who've not become famous save for the film made of them. Riding in Cars with Boys comes to mind. In other words, the films tells a tale that, though not wholeheartedly accurate, is an accurate depiction of the person and life, though perhaps not of the abilities of the person in question. --lincalinca 06:03, 29 June 2007 (UTC)
You're probably referring to the movie Shine, so that discussion should happen there. But no, it's not just his pianistic ability that is grossly misrepresented; e.g. his dad wasn't a Holocaust survivor having arrived in Australia in 1935, his mental illness was not caused by his mistreatment but inherited schizo-affective disorder, etc. 24.235.124.106 01:17, 12 August 2007 (UTC)

[edit] ABC Instrumental and Vocal Competition

The claim that he won the ABC Instrumental and Vocal Competition 6 times is from his own website and the geocities biography (both almost exactly the same and highly questionable). But it's not verifiable on the competition's own site (http://www.symphony.net.au/art_perf_01.html). They list all the winners going back to 1944. 74.99.213.103 00:18, 12 February 2007 (UTC) Have any of you seen him on stage?What makes you such a good critique? —Preceding unsigned comment added by 62.255.104.46 (talk) 15:27, 8 September 2007 (UTC)

[edit] Cyril Smith reference

The page about David Helfgott references Cyril Smith as the teacher. A link is included to Cyril Smith but unfortunately the link is not to a music teacher, but to a politician. The link should have been to Cyril Smith (pianist) instead, I believe. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 212.10.68.249 (talk) 13:32, 15 February 2007 (UTC).

[edit] 'shine' section

it reads like this section of his bio had a bunch of sentences deleted or something. first it's about some other stuff, then a mention of "his onscreen performance", and then the movie is finally brought up "despite this" in the last sentence in reference to bringing him fame. the only actual discussion of the movie is mentioning that people disagree with it. --dan (talk) 03:39, 29 February 2008 (UTC)