Talk:Cynology
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
This article is within the scope of WikiProject Dogs, an attempt to build a comprehensive and detailed guide to articles on Canines on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, you can edit the article attached to this page, or visit the project page, where you can join the project and/or contribute to the discussion. | ||
| Start | This article has been rated as Start-Class on the Project's quality scale. | ||
| High | This article has been rated as high-importance on the importance scale. | ||
|
Article Grading: The article has been rated for quality and/or importance but has no comments yet. If appropriate, please review the article and then leave comments to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the article and what work it needs. |
|||
[edit] Is there such a thing, really?
Are there actually scientists who call themselves cynologists?
Searching the web, it seems to be a fancy term for dog trainer or dog breeder with no associated scientific training (as in "Cynology College" or ads to "Become a Certified Canine Cynologist Now!" or general hobbyists with websites devoted to their personal "research").
I'm hoping someone can provide information and links showing use of the term "cynology" by reputable scientists with publications on the topic in real scientific peer-reviewed journals.
Hafwyn (talk) 17:02, 31 March 2008 (UTC)
Well, talking to one __:) will provide a few links, time allowing. One will need to travel to Russia or other country that have this science as college accredited to get according education and degree. There are also classes, all breeders need to attend prior to registering their kennel. They even have cynology as a public school as a subject, Cynology Academy, occupation "Cynolog", etc. Real scientific studies about dogs exist for real --Afru (talk) 01:52, 1 April 2008 (UTC)
- Yes I know there are reputable scientific studies now of dog genetics and dog behaviour, but "cynologist" is not a term used in English by scientists to refer to themselves. Or at least I can find no instances in English. However, I DO find many references to "cynology" as a trade or occupation, such as dog handler, dog trainer, dog breeder, kennel worker or pet store manager, in Canada, the United States, and the UK. I just think that the English Wikipedia page should include how the word is actually used, so as not to be misleading about what is and what is not "science". Hafwyn (talk) 18:13, 12 April 2008 (UTC)
- Agreed:) Needs work to clarify, same as most dog related issues, especially purebred dog-related issues. For example, extensive studies on working dogs, on selection of hunting dogs and protection dogs for specific purpose, such as developing specific tests. That clearly belongs to cynology, the science about dogs, because those studies are dog breed-specific and scientific at a time. This is just an example; there are several topics that are not just biology related, but actually are about purebred dogs, such as general behavior, breed development history, health, exploitation under different conditions, etc.
Modern dog shows are not science-related (even through initially they started as a cynology event for breeders to evaluate their dogs). But breed standard development include both, science studies and kennel club related activities. How can we outline one from another?
Most terms are hard to impossible to translate in English, that does not help as well--Afru (talk) 07:20, 13 April 2008 (UTC)
- All righty, there is a language problem here. The use in English of a Greek or Latin based suffix with a Greek or Latinized name of an animal (like cynology) is seen as referring to a branch of the sciences, OR is used to inflate the importance of the thing being described, either humorously or to apply the standing and status of a field of science to some other field of endeavour. Perhaps "cynology" logically should be a term scientists who study dogs should apply to themselves, but they don't, and it's not. Instead, it is people who study dog training, dog breeding, and related fields that refer to "cynology." I'm not describing what should be, I'm describing what is.
- Although dog trainers and breeders do contribute to our understanding of our dogs, what they do is not science. (See Scientific Method to clarify what I am talking about.) Dog shows may have started out as cynology events, but if shows were so described, that only proves that the word does not refer to a science. Dog breeding in the old days involved a lot of guesswork and a lot of culling; there was nothing scientific about it.
- And yes, it would be good if Kennel Clubs and dog professionals were able to assist scientists, but so far there has been a great deal of frustration on both sides; "the plural of anecdote is not data", someone once said. KCs and dog professionals supply a lot of anecdotes, but that doesn't advance science much. But that's wandering off the topic... The word "cynolgy" is not used by any branch of the sciences, whatever the roots of the construction are. Hafwyn (talk) 01:01, 15 April 2008 (UTC)
[edit] More on usage
A search of English language websites shows that those who use the terms "cynologist" and "cynology" to describe themselves and what they do are dog trainers, dog handlers, or dog breeders; useful occupations, but not ones that have anything to do with being scientists.
Scientists (with advanced degrees and published work) and veterinarians who work with or study dogs and other canids are referred to by their actual specialties and training; I find none that list "cynology" among their fields of study, although they may study dogs. Examples in no particular order:
-
-
- Ian Dunbar, veterinarian, animal behaviorist, dog trainer, and writer. He received his veterinary degree and a Special Honours degree in Physiology & Biochemistry from the Royal Veterinary College (London University), and a doctorate in animal behavior from the Psychology Department at the University of California in Berkeley, where he spent ten years researching the development of hierarchical social behavior and aggression in domestic dogs. (No "cynology" listed.)
-
-
-
- Elaine A. Ostrander, who began the canine genome project; Ph.D. from the Oregon Health Sciences University, geneticist and senior investigator and Chief of the Cancer Genetics Branch at the National Human Genome Research Institute of the National Institutes of Health. (Not a "cynologist".)
-
-
-
- Desmond Morris, zoologist and ethologist, degrees from the University of Birmingham (Zoology) and D.Phil. from Oxford University, supervised by Niko Tinbergen. Among many other works wrote a book called "Dogwatching" in 1986. (There is no evidence that he ever called himself a cynologist or studied or took a degree in anything called "cynology".)
-
Typical usage in English of the term "cynology" is seen in this article, http://www.scam.com/showthread.php?p=265227 "Cynology College are Scammers" (sic). Another animal training school changed its name from "Cynology College" to "The Companion Animal Sciences Institute", apparently to be less misleading about what it was offering.
Although this is "English Wikipedia" cites from other countries may be useful in showing that "cynology" should not be referred to as field of scientific study. (Noting that the word itself may have a different meaning - connotation and denotation - in other languages than the meaning in English, and these are translations.)
http://www.pads.ru/mode.980-id.1220-l.en-type.html An article on dog breeding describes requirements for Russian "expert cynologist certification" as including "educational level not less then high school graduation"; "Written document confirming the completion of classes in cynology or extracurricular exams"; and practical experience and references. This demonstrates that cynology is not a scientific discipline but rather a trade, even in Russia. A high school diploma and a certificate are not the same as a PhD in an academic discipline and peer-reviewed research.
http://www.amberdog.lv/cat_august_en.html?lang=en&cat=138 Amberdog "magazine dedicated to the development of cynology in the Baltic countries" covering dog training, dog shows, and veterinary advice (a hobbyist magazine, not a scientific journal.)
http://www.customs.tiraspol.net/eng/ Russian website that defines "cynologist" as a dog handler: "A cynologist group is a part of the Department on smuggling and customs rules violation of SCC. Two years ago the cynologist group was filled up with the English cocker-spaniel assistants."
http://www.shutterstock.com/pic-281279.html "The militiaman the cynologist with the dog." (A photo of a woman police officer with a dog.)
On e-Bay: RUSSIAN PATCH CYNOLOGIST LIFE-SAVER SERVICE DOG GERMAN SHEPHERD; a shirt patch for some sort of police dog handler (aka "cynologist")
I found only one self-described cynologist; an agriculturalist, Nicholay Atanassov (http://cynology.freeservers.com/index.html), lists himself as Director of The Center of Experimental Cynology and his education as in agriculture and animal breeding. He seems to be an expert in livestock breeding and has written hobbyist breed-books on the German Shepherd Dog. What the "The Center of Experimental Cynology" does and who is involved is not clear. No scientific papers are listed or anything resembling scientific activity described. It is clear from the website that his first language is not English, so this may not be relevant to "English Wikipedia". I find no other relevant information about describing him as a scientist or any scientific training he may have or any published research in credible journals.
- There is lots more like this. Nothing indicates that "cynology" is or has ever been an academic discipline in the sciences, but rather is a term referring to dog trainers and dog handlers; in English, it comes across as an attempt at grandiosity, an embarrassingly inflated term, when applied to the useful work of dog handling and dog training.
