Construction of the World Trade Center

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

For the post-9/11 rebuilding and ongoing construction at the World Trade Center site, see World Trade Center site.
View of the World Trade Center's construction from across the Hudson River
View of the World Trade Center's construction from across the Hudson River

The construction of the World Trade Center was conceived as an urban renewal project, spearheaded by David Rockefeller, to help revitalize Lower Manhattan. The project was developed by the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, which hired architect Minoru Yamasaki who came up with the specific idea for twin towers. After extensive negotiations, the New Jersey and New York State governments, which oversee the Port Authority, agreed to support the World Trade Center project at the Radio Row site on the lower-west side of Manhattan. To make the agreement acceptable to New Jersey, the Port Authority agreed to take over the bankrupt Hudson & Manhattan Railroad (renamed as PATH), which brought commuters from New Jersey to the Lower Manhattan site.

The towers were designed as framed tube structures, which provided tenants with open floor plans, uninterrupted by columns or walls. This was accomplished using numerous closely-spaced perimeter columns to provide much of the strength to the structure, along with gravity load shared with the core columns. The elevator system, which made use of sky lobbies and a system of express and local elevators, allowed substantial floor space to be freed up for use as office space by making the structural core smaller. The design and construction of the World Trade Center twin towers involved many other innovative techniques, such as the slurry wall for digging the foundation, and wind tunnel experiments. Construction of the World Trade Center's North Tower began in August 1968, and the South Tower in 1969. Extensive use of prefabricated components helped to speed up the construction process. The first tenants moved into the North Tower in December 1970 and into the South Tower in January 1972. Four other low-level buildings were constructed as part of the World Trade Center in the 1970s, and a seventh building was constructed in the mid-1980s.

Contents

[edit] Planning

In 1942, Austin J. Tobin became the Executive Director of the Port Authority, beginning a 30-year career during which he oversaw the planning and development of the World Trade Center.[1] The concept of establishing a "world trade center" was conceived during the post-World War II period, when the United States thrived economically and international trade was increasing. In 1946, the New York State Legislature passed a bill that called for a "world trade center" to be established.[2] The World Trade Corporation was founded, and a board was appointed by New York Governor Thomas E. Dewey to develop plans for the project.[2] Architect John Eberson and his son Drew devised a plan that included 21 buildings over a ten-block area, at an estimated cost of $150 million.[3] In 1949, the World Trade Corporation was dissolved by the New York State Legislature, and plans for a "world trade center" were put on hold.[4]

[edit] Original plans

Architect's model for the proposed World Trade Center on the East River
Architect's model for the proposed World Trade Center on the East River

During the post-war period, economic growth was concentrated in Midtown Manhattan, in part stimulated by the Rockefeller Center, which was developed in the 1930s. Meanwhile, Lower Manhattan was left out of the economic boom. One exception was the construction of One Chase Manhattan Plaza in the Financial District by David Rockefeller, who led urban renewal efforts in Lower Manhattan.[5] In 1958, Rockefeller established the Downtown-Lower Manhattan Association (DLMA), which commissioned Skidmore, Owings and Merrill to draw up plans for revitalizing Lower Manhattan. The plans, made public in 1960, called for a World Trade Center to be built on a 13 acres (53,000 m²) site along the East River, from Old Slip to Fulton Street and between Water Street and South Street.[6][7] The complex would include a 900-foot (275 m) long exhibition hall, and a 50–70 story building, with some of its upper floors used as a hotel.[8] Other amenities would include a theater, shops, and restaurants.[9] The plan also called for a new securities exchange building, which the Downtown-Lower Manhattan Association hoped would house the New York Stock Exchange.[7]

David Rockefeller suggested that the Port Authority would be a logical choice for taking on the project,[7] and argued that the Trade Center would provide great benefits in facilitating and increasing volume of international commerce coming through the Port of New York.[9] Given the importance of New York City in global commerce, Port Authority director Austin J. Tobin remarked that the proposed project should be the World Trade Center, and not just a "world trade center".[10] After a year-long review of the proposal, the Port Authority formally backed the project on March 11, 1961.[11]

[edit] Agreement

Location of World Trade Center and originally proposed site
Location of World Trade Center and originally proposed site

The States of New York and New Jersey also needed to approve the project, given their control and oversight role of the Port Authority. Objections to the plan came from New Jersey Governor Robert B. Meyner, who resented that New York would be getting this $335 million project.[5] Meanwhile, ridership on New Jersey's Hudson and Manhattan Railroad (H&M) had declined substantially from a high of 113 million riders in 1927 to 26 million in 1958, after new automobile tunnels and bridges opened across the Hudson River.[12] Toward the end of 1961, negotiations with outgoing New Jersey Governor Meyner regarding the World Trade Center project reached a stalemate. In December 1961, Tobin met with newly elected New Jersey Governor Richard J. Hughes, and made a proposal to shift the World Trade Center project to a west side site where the Hudson Terminal was located.[13] In acquiring the Hudson & Manhattan Railroad, the Port Authority would also acquire the Hudson Terminal and other buildings which were deemed obsolete.[13] On January 22, 1962, the two states reached an agreement to allow the Port Authority to take over the railroad and to build the World Trade Center on Manhattan's lower west side.[14] The shift in location for the World Trade Center to a site more convenient to New Jersey, together with Port Authority acquisition of the H&M Railroad, brought New Jersey to agreement in support of the World Trade Center project.

[edit] Controversy

Even once the agreement between the states of New Jersey, New York, and the Port Authority was finalized, the World Trade Center plan faced continued controversy. The site for the World Trade Center was the location of Radio Row, which was home to hundreds of commercial and industrial tenants, property owners, small businesses, and approximately 100 residents.[5] The World Trade Center plans involved evicting these business owners, some of whom fiercely protested the forced relocation.[5] In June 1962, a group representing approximately 325 shops and 1,000 other affected small businesses filed an injunction, challenging the Port Authority's power of eminent domain.[15] The dispute with local business owners worked its way through the court system, up to the New York State Court of Appeals, which in April 1963 upheld the Port Authority's right of eminent domain, saying that the project had a "public purpose."[16][17] On November 12, 1963, the United States Supreme Court refused to accept the case.[18][19] Under the state law, the Port Authority was required to assist business owners in relocating, though many business owners regarded what the Port Authority offered as inadequate.[18][20] Questions continued while the World Trade Center was constructed, as to whether the Port Authority really ought to take on the project, described by some as a "mistaken social priority."[21]

Private real estate developers and members of the Real Estate Board of New York also expressed concerns about this much "subsidized" office space going on the open market, competing with the private sector when there was already a glut of vacancies.[5][22] An especially vocal critic was Lawrence A. Wien, owner of the Empire State Building, which would lose its title of tallest building in the world.[5][23] Wien organized a group of builders into a group called the "Committee for a Reasonable World Trade Center" to demand that the project be scaled down.[24]

In January 1964, the Port Authority inked a deal with the State of New York to locate government offices at the World Trade Center.[25] The Port Authority began signing commercial tenants in the spring and summer of 1964, including several banks.[26] In 1965, the Port Authority signed the United States Customs Service as a tenant.[27]

A final obstacle for the Port Authority was getting approval from New York City Mayor John Lindsay and the New York City Council, who raised concerns about the limited extent that the Port Authority involved the city in the negotiations and deliberations. Negotiations between The City of New York and the Port Authority were centered on tax issues. A final agreement was made on August 3, 1966, that the Port Authority would make annual payments to the City, in lieu of taxes, for the portion of the World Trade Center leased to private tenants.[28] In subsequent years, the payments would rise as the real estate tax rate increased.[29]

[edit] Design

On September 20, 1962, the Port Authority announced the selection of Minoru Yamasaki as lead architect, and Emery Roth & Sons as associate architects.[30] Originally, Yamasaki submitted to the Port Authority a concept incorporating twin towers, but with each building only 80 stories tall. Yamasaki remarked that the "obvious alternative, a group of several large buildings, would have looked like a housing project."[31]

A typical floor layout and elevator arrangement of the WTC towers
A typical floor layout and elevator arrangement of the WTC towers

To meet the Port Authority's requirement to build 10 million square feet (930,000 m²) of office space, the buildings would each need to be 110 stories tall. A major limiting factor in building heights is elevators; the taller the building, the more elevators are needed to service the building, requiring more space-consuming elevator banks.[32] Yamasaki and the engineers decided to use a new system with sky lobbies, which are floors where people can switch from a large-capacity express elevator, which goes only to the sky lobbies, to a local elevator that goes to each floor in a section (the local elevators can be stacked within the same elevator shaft). Located on the 44th and 78th floors of each tower, the sky lobbies enabled the elevators to be used efficiently, while also increasing the amount of usable space on each floor from 62 to 75 percent by reducing the number of required elevator shafts.[33] The World Trade Center towers were the second supertall buildings to use sky lobbies, after the John Hancock Center in Chicago.[34] This system was inspired by the New York City Subway system, whose lines include local stations where local trains stop and express stations where all trains stop.[35]

Original architectural and engineering model
Original architectural and engineering model

Yamasaki's design for the World Trade Center was unveiled to the public on January 18, 1964, with an eight-foot model.[31] The towers had a square plan, approximately 207 feet (63 m) in dimension on each side.[36] The buildings were designed with narrow office windows, only 18 inches (45 cm) wide, which reflected on Yamasaki's fear of heights and desire to make building occupants feel secure.[37] Yamasaki's design called for the building facades to be sheathed in aluminum-alloy.[38] In all, the World Trade Center complex contained six buildings within the 16 acres (65,000 m²) superblock.

The World Trade Center design brought criticism of its aesthetics from the American Institute of Architects and other groups.[39][38] Lewis Mumford, author of The City in History and other works on urban planning, criticized the project and described it and other new skyscrapers as "just glass-and-metal filing cabinets."[40] Television broadcasters raised concerns that the World Trade Center twin towers would cause interference in television reception for viewers in the New York City area.[41] In response to these concerns, the Port Authority offered to provide new television transmission facilities at the World Trade Center.[42] The Linnaean Society of the American Museum of Natural History also opposed the Trade Center project, citing hazards the buildings would impose on migrating birds.[43]

The structural engineering firm Worthington, Skilling, Helle & Jackson worked to implement Yamasaki's design, developing the tube-frame structural system used in the buildings. The Port Authority's Engineering Department served as foundation engineers, Joseph R. Loring & Associates as electrical engineers, and Jaros, Baum & Bolles as mechanical engineers. Tishman Realty & Construction Company was the general contractor on the World Trade Center project. Guy F. Tozzoli, director of the World Trade Department at the Port Authority, and the Port Authority's Chief Engineer, Rino M. Monti, oversaw the project.[44]

[edit] Structural design

As an interstate agency, the Port Authority was not subject to local laws and regulations of the City of New York, including building codes. Nonetheless, the Port Authority required architects and structural engineers to follow the New York City building codes. At the time when the World Trade Center was planned, new building codes were being devised to replace the 1938 version that was still in place. The structural engineers ended up following draft versions of the new 1968 building codes, which incorporated "advanced techniques" in building design.[45]

The World Trade Center towers included many structural engineering innovations in skyscraper design and construction, which allowed the buildings to reach new heights and become the tallest in the world. Traditionally, skyscrapers used a skeleton of columns distributed throughout the interior to support building loads, with interior columns disrupting the floor space. The tube-frame concept was a major innovation, allowing open floor plans and more space to rent. The buildings used high-strength, load-bearing perimeter steel columns called Vierendeel trusses that were spaced closely together to form a strong, rigid wall structure. There were 59 perimeter columns, narrowly spaced on each side of the buildings. These were designed to provide support for virtually all lateral loads (such as wind loads) and to share the gravity loads with the core columns.[46] Structural analysis of major portions of the World Trade Center were computed on an IBM 1620.[47]

Typical WTC architectural floor plan
Typical WTC architectural floor plan

The perimeter structure was constructed with extensive use of prefabricated modular pieces, which consisted of three columns, three stories tall, connected by spandrel plates. The perimeter columns had a square cross section, 14 inches (36 cm) on a side, and were constructed of welded steel plate.[48] The thickness of the plates and grade of structural steel varied over the height of the tower, ranging from 36,000 to 100,000 pounds per square inch[49] (260 to 670 MPa). The strength of the steel and thickness of the steel plates decreased with height because they were required to support lesser amounts of building mass on higher floors.[48] The tube-frame design required 40 percent less structural steel than conventional building designs.[50] From the 7th floor to the ground level, and down to the foundation, the columns were spaced 10 feet (3 m) apart.[51] All columns were placed on bedrock, which, unlike that in Midtown Manhattan, where the bedrock is shallow, is at 65–85 feet (20–26 m) below the surface.[52]

The spandrel plates were welded to the columns to create the modular pieces off-site at the fabrication shop.[53] The modular pieces were typically 52 inches (1.3 m) deep, and extended for two full floors and half of two more floors.[48] Adjacent modules were bolted together, with the splices occurring at mid-span of the columns and spandrels. The spandrel plates were located at each floor, transmitting shear stress between columns, allowing them to work together in resisting lateral loads. The joints between modules were staggered vertically, so the column splices between adjacent modules were not at the same floor.[48]

The building's core housed the elevator and utility shafts, restrooms, three stairwells, and other support spaces. The core of each tower was a rectangular area 87 by 135 feet (27 by 41 m), and contained 47 steel columns running from the bedrock to the top of the tower.[48] The columns tapered after the 66th floor, and consisted of welded box-sections at lower floors and rolled wide-flange sections at upper floors. The structural core in 1 WTC was oriented with the long axis east to west, while that of 2 WTC was oriented north to south. All elevators were located in the core. Each building had three stairwells, also in the core, except on the mechanical floors where they were located outside the core.[54]

Schematic of composite floor truss system
Schematic of composite floor truss system

The large, column-free space between the perimeter and core was bridged by prefabricated floor trusses. The floors supported their own weight, as well as live loads, provided lateral stability to the exterior walls, and distributed wind loads among the exterior walls. The floors consisted of 4 inch (10 cm) thick lightweight concrete slabs laid on a fluted steel deck. A grid of lightweight bridging trusses and main trusses supported the floors. The trusses had a span of 60 feet (18.2 m) in the long-span areas and 35 feet (11 m) in the short span area.[48] The trusses connected to the perimeter at alternate columns, and were on 6 foot 8 inch (2.03 m) centers. The top chords of the trusses were bolted to seats welded to the spandrels on the exterior side and a channel welded to the core columns on the interior side. The floors were connected to the perimeter spandrel plates with viscoelastic dampers, which helped reduce the amount of sway felt by building occupants. The trusses supported a 4-inch (100 mm) thick (10 cm) lightweight concrete floor slab, with shear connections for composite action.[48]

Hat trusses (or "outrigger truss") located from the 107th floor to the top of the buildings were designed to support a tall communication antenna on top of each building.[48] Only 1 WTC (north tower) actually had an antenna fitted, which was added in 1978.[55] The truss system consisted of six trusses along the long axis of the core and four along the short axis. This truss system allowed some load redistribution between the perimeter and core columns and supported the transmission tower.

[edit] Wind effects

The tube frame design using steel core and perimeter columns protected with sprayed-on fire resistant material created a relatively lightweight structure that would sway more in response to the wind, compared to traditional structures such as the Empire State Building that have thick, heavy masonry for fireproofing of steel structural elements.[56] During the design process, wind tunnel tests were done at Colorado State University and at the National Physical Laboratory in the U.K. to establish design wind pressures that the World Trade Center towers could be subjected to and structural response to those forces.[57] Experiments also were done to evaluate how much sway occupants could tolerate. Subjects were recruited for "free eye exams," while the real purpose of the experiment was to subject them to simulated building sway and find out how much they could comfortably tolerate.[58] Many subjects did not respond well, experiencing dizziness and other ill effects. One of the chief engineers Leslie Robertson worked with Canadian engineer Alan G. Davenport to develop viscoelastic dampers to absorb some of the sway. These viscoelastic dampers, used throughout the structures at the joints between floor trusses and perimeter columns, along with some other structural modifications reduced the building sway to an acceptable level.[59]

[edit] Aircraft impact

The structural engineers on the project also considered the possibility that an aircraft could crash into the building. In July 1945, a B-25 bomber that was lost in the fog had crashed into the 79th floor of the Empire State Building. A year later, another airplane nearly crashed into the 40 Wall Street building, and there was another near-miss at the Empire State Building.[60] In designing the World Trade Center, structural engineers considered the scenario of a fully loaded Boeing 707 impacting the 80th floor of the buildings at 600 mph (1,000 km/h).[61][62] NIST found a three page white paper that provided evidence that aircraft impact was indeed considered, but the original documentation of the study was lost when Port Authority offices were destroyed in the collapse of WTC1 and the copies held in WTC7 were also lost.[63] In 1993, John Skilling recalled doing the analysis, and remarked, "The building structure would still be there."[62] However in the analysis, it is unclear whether the effect of jet fuel and aircraft contents was a consideration in the original building design.[64] They assumed that the World Trade Center's lightweight trusses and columns would perform as well as the heavy masonry and steel structure in the Empire State Building.[65] Leslie Robertson did a second analysis of this possibility which is also now lost, but after the 9/11 attacks, he remarked, "To the best of our knowledge, little was known about the effects of a fire from such an aircraft, and no designs were prepared for that circumstance."[61]

[edit] Fire protection

Sprayed-fire resistant materials (SFRMs) were used to protect some structural steel elements in the towers, including all floor trusses and beams.[66] Gypsum wallboard in combination with SFRMs, or in some cases gypsum wallboard alone, was used to protect core columns.[66] Vermiculite plaster was used on the interior-side and SFRMs on the other three sides of the perimeter columns for fire protection.[66] The 1968 New York City building codes were more lenient in some aspects of fire protection, such as allowing three exit stairwells in the World Trade Center towers, instead of six as required under older building codes.[67]

More fireproofing was added after a fire in February 1975 that spread to six floors before being extinguished.[68] After the 1993 bombing, inspections found fireproofing to be deficient. The Port Authority was in the process of replacing it, but replacement had been completed on only 18 floors in WTC 1, including all the floors affected by the aircraft impact and fires on 9/11,[69] and on 13 floors in WTC 2, although only three of these floors (77,78 & 85) were directly affected by the aircraft impact.[70][71]

The 1968 New York City building codes did not require sprinklers for high-rise buildings, except for underground spaces. In accordance with building codes, sprinklers were originally installed only in the underground parking structures of the World Trade Center.[72] Following a major fire in February 1975, the Port Authority decided to start installing sprinklers throughout the buildings. By 1993, nearly all of Tower 2 [South Tower] and 85 percent of Tower 1 had sprinklers installed,[73] and the entire complex was retrofitted by 2001.[74]

[edit] Construction

In March 1965, the Port Authority began acquiring property at the World Trade Center site.[75] The Ajax Wrecking and Lumber Corporation was hired for the demolition work, which began on March 21, 1966 to clear the site for construction of the World Trade Center.[76]

Groundbreaking was on August 5, 1966, marking the beginning of construction of the World Trade Center's foundations.[77] The site of the World Trade Center was located on landfill, with the bedrock located 65 feet (20 m) below.[78] In order to construct the World Trade Center, it was necessary to build the "bathtub", with the slurry wall along the West Street side of the site, to keep water from the Hudson River out. This method was used in place of conventional dewatering methods because lowering the groundwater table would cause large settlements of nearby buildings not built on deep foundations.[79] The slurry method involves digging a trench, and as excavation proceeds, filling the space with a "slurry" mixture, composed of bentonite which plugs holes and keeps water out. When the trench was dug out, a steel cage was inserted, with concrete poured in, forcing the "slurry" out. The "slurry" method was devised by Port Authority chief engineer John M. Kyle, Jr. Towards the end of 1966, work began on building the slurry wall, led by Montreal-based Icanda, a subsidiary of an Italian engineering firm, Impresa Costruzioni Opere Specializzate (I.C.O.S.).[80] It took fourteen months for the slurry wall to be completed, which was necessary before excavation of material from the interior of the site could begin.[80] The original Hudson Tubes, which carried PATH trains into Hudson Terminal, remained in service as elevated tunnels until 1971 when a new PATH station was built.[81]

World Trade Center in 1973
World Trade Center in 1973

Construction work began on the North Tower in August 1968 with construction beginning on the South Tower by January 1969.[82] In January 1967, $74 million in contracts were awarded to the Pacific Car and Foundry Company, Laclede Steel Company, Granite City Steel Company, and Karl Koch Erecting Company to supply steel for the project.[83] The Port Authority chose to use many different steel suppliers, bidding on smaller portions of steel, rather than buy larger amounts from a single source such as Bethlehem Steel or U.S. Steel as a cost-saving measure.[84] Karl Koch was also hired to do all the work of erecting the steel, and a contract for work on the aluminum facade was awarded to the Aluminum Company of America.[83] Tishman Realty & Construction was hired in February 1967 to oversee construction of the project.[85]

Extensive use of prefabricated parts for the perimeter framing and floor truss systems helped speed up the construction process and reduce costs, while providing greater quality control.[50] Steel components were freighted into a Penn Central yard in Jersey City. From there, they were brought in early morning hours through the Holland Tunnel to the construction site, and lifted into place by a crane.[86] Larger pieces were brought to the construction site by tugboats.[87] A special type of crane, suitable for constructing such tall buildings, that used hydraulics to lift components and provided its own power was used in construction of the World Trade Center. The Favco Standard 2700 Crane, manufactured by Favelle Mort Ltd. of New South Wales, Australia was informally called a "kangaroo crane".[88]

In 1970, tugboat workers went on strike, halting the transport of material to the construction site.[89] The Port Authority attempted other means of transporting material, including via helicopter. When this method was tried, the helicopter lost its load of steel into the Kill Van Kull.[90] Some other mishaps occurred during the construction process, including disruption of telephone service in Lower Manhattan when telephone cables were crushed by pile drivers.[91] On March 16, 1970, a propane gas explosion injured six workers when a truck hit a propane tank.[92] In all, 60 workers were killed in construction accidents while the World Trade Center was being built.[93]

The Topping out ceremony of 1 WTC (North Tower) took place on December 23, 1970, with 2 WTC's ceremony (South Tower) occurring later on July 19, 1971.[82] The first tenants moved into the North Tower in December 1970, and into the South Tower in January 1972.[94] The buildings were dedicated on April 4, 1973; Tobin, who had resigned the year before, was absent from the ceremonies.[95]

Building the World Trade Center involved excavating 1.2 million cubic yards (917,000 m³) of material.[96] Rather than transporting this material at great costs out to sea or to landfills in New Jersey, the fill material was used to expand the Manhattan shoreline across West Street.[96] Work to demolish the piers began on January 5, 1967, including Pier 7 to Pier 11 which were all constructed around 1910.[97] The demolition work moved forward, despite conflicts between David Rockefeller, Governor Nelson Rockefeller and Mayor John Lindsay regarding plans for Battery Park City.[98] Landfill material from the World Trade Center was used to add land, and a cellular cofferdam was constructed to retain the material.[78] The result was a 700 foot (210 m) extension into the Hudson River, running six blocks or 1,484 feet (450 m).[96] This land was a "gift" to New York City, allowing more tax-generating developments in Battery Park City.[99]

The original estimates put forth by the Port Authority had the costs for construction of the World Trade Center at $350 million—an optimistic figure.[100] In December 1966, the Port Authority announced increased cost estimates, bringing the estimated total to $575 million.[101] This announcement brought criticism of the project from private real estate developers, The New York Times, and others in New York City.[102] The critics charged that the Port Authority figure was an unrealistically low estimate, and they estimated the project would end up costing $750 million.[103] When the World Trade Center twin towers were completed, the total costs to the Port Authority had reached $900 million.[104] The project was financed through tax-exempt bonds issued by the Port Authority.[105]

[edit] Other buildings

The World Trade Center complex included four other smaller buildings constructed during the 1970s. 3 World Trade Center was a 22-story building, which was home to the Marriott World Trade Center. It was designed by Skidmore, Owings and Merrill in 1978–79.[106] 4 World Trade Center, 5 World Trade Center, and 6 World Trade Center were all 8–9 story buildings that were designed by the same team as the Twin Towers, including Minoru Yamasaki, Emery Roth & Sons, and Skilling, Helle, Christiansen, Robertson.[107] A seventh building (7 World Trade Center) was built in the mid-1980s, just to the north of the main World Trade Center site. The 47-story building was designed by Emery, Roth & Sons, and constructed on top of a Con Edison power substation.[108]

[edit] Modifications

Over time, numerous structural modifications were made to suit the needs of tenants in the Twin Towers. Modifications were made in accordance with the Port Authority's Tenant Alteration Review Manual and were reviewed by the Port Authority to ensure the changes did not compromise structural integrity of the buildings. In many instances, openings were cut in the floors to accommodate new stairways to connect tenant floors. Some steel beams in the core were reinforced and strengthened to accommodate heavy live loads, such as large amounts of heavy files that tenants had on their floors.[109]

Repairs to structural elements on the lower levels of 1 WTC [North Tower] were made following the 1993 World Trade Center bombing. The greatest damage occurred on levels B1 and B2, with significant structural damage also on level B3.[110] Primary structural columns were not damaged, but secondary steel members experienced some damage.[111] Floors that were blown out needed to be repaired to restore the structural support they provided to columns.[112] The slurry wall was in peril following the bombing and loss of the floor slabs which provided lateral support to counteract pressure from Hudson River water on the other side.[113] The refrigeration plant on sublevel B5, which provided air conditioning to the entire World Trade Center complex, was heavily damaged and replaced with a temporary system for the summer of 1993.[113] The fire alarm system for both towers needed to be replaced, after critical wiring and signaling in the original system was destroyed in the 1993 bombing. Installation of the new system took years to complete, and replacement of some components was still underway at the time of the September 11, 2001 attacks.[114]

[edit] See also

[edit] References

  1. ^ Doig, Jameson W. (2001). "Chapter 1", Empire on the Hudson. Columbia University Press. 
  2. ^ a b "Dewey Picks Board for Trade Center", The New York Times, July 6, 1946. 
  3. ^ Crisman, Charles B.. "Plans are Tabled for Trade Center", The New York Times, November 10, 1946. 
  4. ^ "Lets Port Group Disband, State Senate for Dissolution of World Trade Corporation", The New York Times, March 11, 1949. 
  5. ^ a b c d e f Gillespie, Angus K. (1999). "Chapter 1", Twin Towers: The Life of New York City's World Trade Center. Rutgers University Press. 
  6. ^ Levinson, Leonard Louis (1961). Wall Street. New York: Ziff Davis Publishing, 346. 
  7. ^ a b c Grutzner, Charles. "A World Center of Trade Mapped Off Wall Street", The New York Times, January 27, 1960. 
  8. ^ Koch, Karl III (2002). Men of Steel: The Story of the Family That Built the World Trade Center. Three Rivers Press, p. 173. 
  9. ^ a b "Text of Trade Center Report by the Downtown-Lower Manhattan Association", The New York Times, January 27, 1960. 
  10. ^ "Tobin Says Proposed Center Should Be World's Best", The New York Times, May 5, 1960. 
  11. ^ "355 Million World Trade Center Backed by Port Authority Study", The New York Times, March 12, 1961. 
  12. ^ Cudahy, Brian J. (2002). Rails Under the Mighty Hudson. Fordham University Press, p. 56. 
  13. ^ a b Grutzner, Charles. "Port Unit Backs Linking of H&M and Other Lines", The New York Times, December 29, 1961. 
  14. ^ Wright, George Cable. "2 States Agree on Hudson Tubes and Trade Center", The New York Times, January 23, 1962. 
  15. ^ Clark, Alfred E.. "Injunction Asked on Trade Center", The New York Times, June 27, 1962. 
  16. ^ Crowell, Paul. "World Trade Center Here Upheld by Appeals Court", The New York Times, April 5, 1963. 
  17. ^ "Merchants Ask Supreme Court to Bar Big Trade Center Here", The New York Times / Associated Press, August 26, 1963. 
  18. ^ a b Arnold, Martin. "High Court Plea is Lost by Foes of Trade Center", The New York Times, November 13, 1963. 
  19. ^ 375 US. 4 - Courtesy Sandwich Shop, Inc., et al. v. Port of New York Authority
  20. ^ Apple, Jr. R.W.. "Port Body Raises Relocation Aid", The New York Times, November 16, 1963. 
  21. ^ "Kheel Urges Port Authority to Sell Trade Center", The New York Times, November 12, 1969. 
  22. ^ Knowles, Clayton. "New Fight Begun on Trade Center", The New York Times, February 14, 1964. 
  23. ^ Ennis, Thomas W.. "Critics Impugned on Trade Center", The New York Times, February 15, 1964. 
  24. ^ Knowles, Clayton. "All Major Builders are Said to Oppose Trade Center Plan", The New York Times, March 9, 1964. 
  25. ^ Sibley, John. "State Will Rent at Trade Center", The New York Times, January 14, 1964. 
  26. ^ "4th Bank Signed by Trade Center", The New York Times, July 14, 1964. 
  27. ^ Fowler, Glenn. "Customs to Move to Trade Center", The New York Times, July 7, 1965. 
  28. ^ Smith, Terence. "City Ends Fight with Port Body on Trade Center", The New York Times, August 4, 1966. 
  29. ^ Smith, Terence. "Mayor Signs Pact on Trade Center", The New York Times, January 26, 1967. 
  30. ^ Esterow, Milton. "Architect Named for Trade Center", The New York Times, September 21, 1962. 
  31. ^ a b Huxtable, Ada Louise. "A New Era Heralded", The New York Times, January 19, 1964. 
  32. ^ Huxtable, Ada Louise. "Biggest Buildings Herald New Era", The New York Times, January 26, 1964. 
  33. ^ Lew, H.S., Richard W. Bukowski, Nicholas J. Carino (September 2005). Design, Construction, and Maintenance of Structural and Life Safety Systems (NCSTAR 1-1). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. 9. 
  34. ^ Otis History: The World Trade Center. Otis Elevator Company. Retrieved on 2006-12-07.
  35. ^ Gillespie, Angus K. (1999). Twin Towers: The Life of New York City's World Trade Center. Rutgers University Press, p. 76. 
  36. ^ Lew, H.S., Richard W. Bukowski, Nicholas J. Carino (September 2005). Design, Construction, and Maintenance of Structural and Life Safety Systems (NCSTAR 1-1). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. 7. 
  37. ^ Pekala, Nancy. "Profile of a lost landmark; World Trade Center", Journal of Property Management, November 1, 2001. 
  38. ^ a b Huxtable, Ada Louise. "Who's Afraid of the Big Bad Buildings", The New York Times, May 29, 1966. 
  39. ^ Steese, Edward. "Marring City's Skyline", The New York Times, March 10, 1964. 
  40. ^ Whitman, Alden. "Mumford Finds City Strangled By Excess of Cars and People", The New York Times, March 22, 1967. 
  41. ^ Schumach, Murray. "TV Group Objects to Trade Towers", The New York Times, February 20, 1966. 
  42. ^ "TV Mast Offered on Trade Center", The New York Times, February 24, 1966. 
  43. ^ Knowles, Clayton. "Big Trade Center Called Bird Trap", The New York Times, March 16, 1967. 
  44. ^ National Construction Safety Team (September 2005). "Chapter 1", Final Report on the Collapse of the World Trade Center Towers (PDF), NIST, p. 1. 
  45. ^ Lew, H.S., Richard W. Bukowski, Nicholas J. Carino (September 2005). Design, Construction, and Maintenance of Structural and Life Safety Systems (NCSTAR 1-1). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. xxxviii. 
  46. ^ National Construction Safety Team (September 2005). "Chapter 1", Final Report on the Collapse of the World Trade Center Towers (PDF), NIST, p. 6. 
  47. ^ Taylor, R. E. (December 1966). "Computers and the Design of the World Trade Center". ASCE, Structural Division 92 (ST-6): pp. 75–91. 
  48. ^ a b c d e f g h National Construction Safety Team (September 2005). Final Report on the Collapse of the World Trade Center Towers (PDF), NIST. 
  49. ^ A36 steel has a nominal yield strength of 36,000 to 100,000 pounds per square inch.
  50. ^ a b American Iron and Steel Institute (1964). "The World Trade Center - New York City". Contemporary Steel Design 1(4). American Iron and Steel Institute. 
  51. ^ National Construction Safety Team (September 2005). Final Report on the Collapse of the World Trade Center Towers (PDF), NIST, p. 10. 
  52. ^ Tamaro, George J. (Spring 2002). "World Trade Center "Bathtub": From Genesis to Armageddon". Bridges 32(1). 
  53. ^ National Construction Safety Team (September 2005). Final Report on the Collapse of the World Trade Center Towers (PDF), NIST, p. 8. 
  54. ^ Lew, H.S., Richard W. Bukowski, Nicholas J. Carino (September 2005). Design, Construction, and Maintenance of Structural and Life Safety Systems (NCSTAR 1-1). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. 8. 
  55. ^ New York: A Documentary Film - The Center of the World (Construction Footage). Port Authority / PBS. Retrieved on 2007-05-16.
  56. ^ Glanz, James and Eric Lipton (2003). City in the Sky. Times Books, p. 138. 
  57. ^ Fanella, David A., Arnaldo T. Derecho, S.K. Ghosh (September 2005). Design and Construction of Structural Systems (NCSTAR 1-1A). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. 65. 
  58. ^ Glanz, James and Eric Lipton (2003). City in the Sky. Times Books, p. 139-144. 
  59. ^ Glanz, James and Eric Lipton (2003). City in the Sky. Times Books, p. 160-167. 
  60. ^ Glanz, James and Eric Lipton. "The Height of Ambition", The New York Times, September 8, 2002. 
  61. ^ a b Robertson, Leslie E. (2002). Reflections on the World Trade Center. The Bridge Volume 32, Number 1. National Academy of Engineering. Retrieved on 2006-07-28.
  62. ^ a b Nalder, Eric. "Twin Towers Engineered to Withstand Jet Collision", The Seattle Times, February 27, 1993. 
  63. ^ Sadek, Fahim. Baseline Structural Performance and Aircraft Impact Damage Analysis of the World Trade Center Towers(NCSTAR 1-2 appendix A). NIST 2005. pp. 305-307.
  64. ^ NIST wrote: "One view suggests that an analysis was done indicating the biggest problem would be the fact that all the fuel would dump into the building and there would be a horrendous fire. Another view suggests that the fuel load, and the fire damage that it would cause, may not have been considered. Without the original calculations, which were used to render its conclusions any further comment would amount to speculation
  65. ^ Glanz, James and Eric Lipton (2003). City in the Sky: The Rise and Fall of the World Trade Center. Times Books, pp. 138-139. 
  66. ^ a b c Lew, H.S., Richard W. Bukowski, Nicholas J. Carino (September 2005). Design, Construction, and Maintenance of Structural and Life Safety Systems (NCSTAR 1-1). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. 8. 
  67. ^ Lew, H.S., Richard W. Bukowski, Nicholas J. Carino (September 2005). Design, Construction, and Maintenance of Structural and Life Safety Systems (NCSTAR 1-1). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. 153. 
  68. ^ Hamburger, Ronald, et al. World Trade Center Building Performance Study (pdf). Federal Emergency Management Agency. Retrieved on 2006-07-27.
  69. ^ NCSTAR 1-6, (p lxxi) NIST lists upgraded floors as 92-100 and 102 plus 8 unspecified floors.
  70. ^ NCSTAR 1-6, (p lxvii-lxix) NIST lists upgraded floors as 77,78,85,88,89,92,96 and 97 plus 5 unspecified floors. Although replacement fireproofing was specified at 1.5 inches in thickness, NIST found the average thickness to be 2.5 inches. (NCSTAR 1-6A p xl ) NIST concluded that "The existing condition of the fireproofing prior to aircraft impact and the fireproofing thickness on the WTC floor system did not play a significant role".
  71. ^ Dwyer, Jim and Kevin Flynn (2005). 102 Minutes. Times Books, pp. 9-10. 
  72. ^ Lew, H.S., Richard W. Bukowski, Nicholas J. Carino (September 2005). Design, Construction, and Maintenance of Structural and Life Safety Systems (NCSTAR 1-1). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. 162. 
  73. ^ Lew, H.S., Richard W. Bukowski, Nicholas J. Carino (September 2005). Design, Construction, and Maintenance of Structural and Life Safety Systems (NCSTAR 1-1). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. 163. 
  74. ^ Evans, David D., Richard D. Peacock, Erica D. Kuligowski, W. Stuart Dols, William L. Grosshandler (September 2005). Active Fire Protection Systems (NCSTAR 1-4). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. 14. 
  75. ^ Ingraham, Joseph C.. "Port Agency Buys Downtown Tract", The New York Times, March 29, 1965. 
  76. ^ Gillespie, Angus K. (1999). Twin Towers: The Life of New York City's World Trade Center. Rutgers University Press, p. 61. 
  77. ^ "Jackhammers Bite Pavement to Start Trade Center Job", The New York Times, August 6, 1966. 
  78. ^ a b Iglauer, Edith. "The Biggest Foundation", The New Yorker, November 4 1972. 
  79. ^ Kapp, Martin S. "Tall Towers will Sit on Deep Foundations", Engineering News Record, July 9, 1964. 
  80. ^ a b Gillespie, Angus K. (1999). Twin Towers: The Life of New York City's World Trade Center. Rutgers University Press, p. 68. 
  81. ^ Carroll, Maurice. "A Section of the Hudson Tubes is Turned into Elevated Tunnel", The New York Times, December 30, 1968. 
  82. ^ a b Timeline: World Trade Center chronology. PBS - American Experience. Retrieved on 2007-05-15.
  83. ^ a b "Contracts Totaling $74,079,000 Awarded for the Trade Center", The New York Times, January 24, 1967. 
  84. ^ Gillespie, Angus K. (1999). Twin Towers: The Life of New York City's World Trade Center. Rutgers University Press, p. 83. 
  85. ^ Kihss, Peter. "Trade Center Job To Go To Tishman", The New York Times, February 27, 1967. 
  86. ^ Kaufman, Micheal T.. "Trade Center is Doing Everything Big", The New York Times, June 6, 1969. 
  87. ^ Gillespie, Angus K. (1999). Twin Towers: The Life of New York City's World Trade Center. Rutgers University Press, p. 88. 
  88. ^ Gillespie, Angus K. (1999). Twin Towers: The Life of New York City's World Trade Center. Rutgers University Press, p. 92-94. 
  89. ^ McFadden, Robert D.. "300 Tugboats Idle as Men Walk Out for Doubled Wage", The New York Times, February 2, 1970. 
  90. ^ Gillespie, Angus K. (1999). Twin Towers: The Life of New York City's World Trade Center. Rutgers University Press, p. 91. 
  91. ^ Carroll, Maurice. "Phones Disrupted by a Pile Driver", The New York Times, March 19, 1969. 
  92. ^ Van Gelder, Lawrence. "Propane Blast Hits Trade Center", The New York Times, March 17, 1970. 
  93. ^ America Rebuilds: Quick Facts. PBS. Retrieved on 2007-05-15.
  94. ^ Lew, H.S., Richard W. Bukowski, Nicholas J. Carino (September 2005). Design, Construction, and Maintenance of Structural and Life Safety Systems (NCSTAR 1-1). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. xxxvi. 
  95. ^ Darton, Eric (1999) Divided We Stand: A Biography of New York's World Trade Center, Chapter 6, Basic Books.
  96. ^ a b c Gillespie, Angus K. (1999). Twin Towers: The Life of New York City's World Trade Center. Rutgers University Press, p. 71. 
  97. ^ Horne, George. "Demolition Begun on 5 City Piers", The New York Times, January 5, 1967. 
  98. ^ Roberts, Steven V.. "Conflicts Stall Landfill Plans", The New York Times, January 17, 1967. 
  99. ^ "New York Gets $90 Million Worth of Land for Nothing", Engineering News Record, April 18, 1968. 
  100. ^ Gillespie, Angus K. (1999). Twin Towers: The Life of New York City's World Trade Center. Rutgers University Press, p. 70. 
  101. ^ Gillespie, Angus K. (1999). Twin Towers: The Life of New York City's World Trade Center. Rutgers University Press, p. 69. 
  102. ^ "Questions on the Trade Center", The New York Times, December 24, 1966. 
  103. ^ Phillips, McCandlish. "Estimate Raised for Trade Center", The New York Times, December 29, 1966. 
  104. ^ Cudahy, Brian J. (2002) Rails Under the Mighty Hudson: The Story of the Hudson Tubes, the Pennsy Tunnels, and Manhattan Transfer, Chapter 3, Fordham University Press.
  105. ^ Allan, John H.. "Bonds: Port of New York Authority to Raise $100-Million", The New York Times, February 28, 1968. 
  106. ^ McAllister, Therese, Johnathan Barnett, John Gross, Ronald Hamburger, Jon Magnusson (May 2002). "WTC3", World Trade Center Building Performance Study. FEMA. 
  107. ^ McAllister, Therese, Johnathan Barnett, John Gross, Ronald Hamburger, Jon Magnusson (May 2002). "WTC4, 5, and 6", World Trade Center Building Performance Study. FEMA. 
  108. ^ McAllister, Therese, Johnathan Barnett, John Gross, Ronald Hamburger, Jon Magnusson (May 2002). "WTC7", World Trade Center Building Performance Study. FEMA. 
  109. ^ Lew, H.S., Richard W. Bukowski, Nicholas J. Carino (September 2005). Design, Construction, and Maintenance of Structural and Life Safety Systems (NCSTAR 1-1). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. xliv. 
  110. ^ Lew, H.S., Richard W. Bukowski, Nicholas J. Carino (September 2005). Design, Construction, and Maintenance of Structural and Life Safety Systems (NCSTAR 1-1). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. xlv. 
  111. ^ Fasullo, Eugene. Experiences of the Chief Engineer of the Port Authority (PDF). United States Fire Administration. Retrieved on 2007-05-15.
  112. ^ Port Authority Risk Management Staff. The World Trade Center Complex (PDF). United States Fire Administration. Retrieved on 2007-05-15.
  113. ^ a b Ramabhushanam, Ennala and Marjorie Lynch. "Structural Assessment of Bomb Damage for World Trade Center". Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities 8(4): 229–242. 
  114. ^ Evans, David D., Richard D. Peacock, Erica D. Kuligowski, W. Stuart Dols, William L. Grosshandler (September 2005). Active Fire Protection Systems (NCSTAR 1-4). National Institute of Standards and Technology, p. 44. 

[edit] External links

v • d • e
World Trade Center