Talk:Collie/Comments

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I've assessed this article as start class. It is a decent start, but needs many more references of greater variety that meet Wikipedia reliability guidelines. Article is missing some key sections, infobox (if it can be made to fit an article on general breed type). It also has extraneous ones that seem unencyclopedic, such as Collie names (which seems more like NPOV conjecture). Some sections are unclear and have NPOV problems using bad sources (the sheepdogsforsale is a completely violation of proper sourcing and should be removed immediately, as is the other sales page). Collectonian 02:40, 6 November 2007 (UTC)