Talk:Clifton family

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is not for speedy--there is room for divergence of opinion about notability here, and I suggest a discussion at this talk page. (And, if there is no consensus here, then obtaining one at AfD.

I simply do not know whether or not pages like this are a good idea., They may be: combining paragraphs for relative minor members of a family is a way of handling intermediate between a full article and a redirect, and may be the solution to our problems with gentry and minor nobility. The problem, of course, is the standards to be used, both for having he page at all, and for what goes in it. It is actually easier to remove non notable pages at AfD than to remove non-notable paragraphs from an article if there is opposition. So I see it both ways, and I think this page is a good opportunity to explore the possibilities and the problems presented. DGG 19:42, 13 June 2007 (UTC)

I only nominated it because it looked like something someone made up about their family. If that's not the case then I've got no reason to fight for it's deletion. CJ 20:22, 13 June 2007 (UTC)