User:Cailil/cailil sandbox 5

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This page is a report into disruptive editting by the user User:Loneranger4justice.

Loneranger4justice has been adding unsourced and dubious material to Wikipedia since August 2006. Their claims are that feminists are nazis, that profeminist men are like Ku Klux Klan auxilaries and that women only become feminists because they are "are seriously psychologically troubled". Loneranger4justice has not made many edits to Wikipedia their count as of August 4th 2007 is 150 however their contribution has neither been helpful nor encyclopedic. This is a long term vandal account but has so far avoided any blocks. They have already been given a level 4 NPOV warning in April [1] but they have continued to violate WP:NPOV after final that warning.

Contents

[edit] Most current problems

Continual reinsertion of unsourced and unverifiable POV criticism of feminism in Feminazi[2], Violence_Against_Women_Act[3] and Pro-feminist men[4]. On august 4th 2007 Loneranger4justice re-added claims that feminists are nazis and pro-feminist men are WKKK auxiliaries. This material had already been removed twice. On August 15th these pieces were re-added yet again.[5][6][7][8][9]

[edit] POVpush in Articles

[edit] Pro-feminist men

POVpush that feminists are nazis and that radical feminists are much like the WKKK[10]. This material was removed by User:21380.115.15 and then reinserted [11] by Loneranger4justice. This was reverted by User:TedFrank because it is original research [12] but once again Loneranger4justice reinserted it on April 28th 2007 [13]; and again on July 8th 2007 [14].

On 26th of February 2007, Loneranger4justice added profeminist men as a see also link in Ku Klux Klan artice.[15]

In radical feminism, Loneranger4justice inserted: "Male supporters of radical feminism are arguably similar to members of the Klan's Colored Man's Auxilliary, by supporting a hate based movement directed against themselves."[16].

[edit] WKKK & Femininazi

"Critics of feminism view radical feminist propaganda and legislature such as the VAWA as fueling similar profiling, sexual symbolism, and encouraging false allegations against all men." [17]

Loneranger4justce inserted unsourced material, making similar claims, to Feminazi [18]. This was removed by User:Operator50 but reverted by Lonerager4justice[19]. This was again deleted by User:Gamete but then reverted by Loneranger4justice [20]. Over the next ten days this was again deleted by user:DNewhall and Gamete

In April Loneranger4justice reinserted inappropriate external links - which were removed by User:TedFrank [21]

Loneranger4justice has also altered the see also sections of men's rights [22]and nazism [23] to reflect the above position.


[edit] 2006 Duke University lacrosse team scandal

On April 15th TedFrank warned Loneranger4justice with {{uw-npov4}} [24]. Loneranger4justice's response was "I am requesting that this matter to be escalated for review of the POV policies that you alledge".

Loneranger4justice added this content at 05:14, 15 April 2007

Men's rights and Father's rights advocates view this scandal as typical of radical feminist and feminazi agenda to vilify men. It is ironic as the use of false sexual accusations was a main tactic of the WKKK which invovlved white women making false accusations against black men, as typified in the Rosewood film. The role of Pro-feminist men can be viewed as an absurd paradox similar to the colored man's KKK auxiliaries.

[25]. TedFrank deleted this as per WP:NOT#SOAP & WP:NOR [26]. Loneranger4justice reinserts this 40 minutes later.[27]

[edit] Women's studies

On 3rd April 2007 Loneranger4justice added paragraphs of unsourced 'criticism' into Women's studies. This material claimed that: "Feminist and women's studies are often grouped with gay, lesbian and transgender studies on college campuses, and all four can be described as disorders of psychosexual development. [...] Ms. O'Leary concluded that some women who are deeply committed to feminist ideology "are seriously psychologically troubled" due to trans- generational dysfunctional father-daughter relationships." [28]. This material was removed by user:Cailil[29]. The points take from Ms. O'Leary in Loneranger4justice's content are from [30] - the article does not conform to WP:RS or WP:ATT but you can find it on the white supremacist web-forum [www.stormfront.org/forum/showthread.php/radical-feminism-psychological-disorder-224608.html?p=2112459 stormfront].

This same material had ben posted in Psychoanalytic feminism on 8th August 2006[31] by Loneranger4justice. It was removed a month later by User:Onedayoneday [32]

[edit] Talkpage Soapboxing

[edit] WP:OWN

On October 2nd, 2006 Loneranger4justice warned "feminists/feminazis" not to remove the content that he added [37]:

this page is being repeatedly vandalized or revised to an exclusive feminist/feminazi POV. FemiNAZI's: Do not change these criticisms, just because it is contrary to your propaganda

[edit] Topics of interest

edit count information from wannabe kate