User:BOZ/Gavin.RfM
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Involved Parties
- BOZ, filing party
- Jéské Couriano
- Gavin.collins
- SamBC(talk)
Articles involved
- Kender
- Generic role-playing game system
- Paladine (Dragonlance)
- Githyanki
- Lolth
- Car Wars
- Empire of Iuz
- Torg
- Lady of Pain
- Planescape
- Dragon (Dungeons & Dragons)
- Red Hand of Doom
- Amarillo Design Bureau
- These are a good sampling of the disputes involved; numerous other RPG articles are disputed
Other steps in dispute resolution that have been attempted
- RFC/U: Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Gavin.collins
- User talk:Gavin.collins/Archive 5#Good & Bad Edits
- User talk:Gavin.collins/Archive 5#Application of the Notability (books) cleanup template is disputed
- Talk:Kender#Descriptions of fictional characters are part of the plot summary?
- Talk:Planescape#Notability disputed
Issues to be mediated
There has been a long-running content dispute over at least the past six months between primarily Gavin.collins and a number of editors who contribute and edit articles on RPGs. This dispute has been centered around a variety of content issues believed to be possessed by these articles, including notability, reliable sources, plot summaries, in-universe perspective, original research, and a host of other issues.
Gavin has placed between one or more cleanup templates on hundreds of articles, and sometimes one or more editors will disagree that the templates apply. Even when an editor attempts to fix the issue, Gavin will usually assert that the article issues remain and that the cleanup issues have not been fully addressed.
