User talk:Ben Chroneos

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] The Louisville Cardinal

You opposed the redirect I placed on the above on the ground that the journal is "relevant as any other student newspaper on wikipedia". However, I believe you may be confusing "relevance" and "importance" with "notabilty". The notability of each subject is usually independent of another. True that there are articles for other college journals on wikipedia, but as you know, there are no barriers to creation, so your argument would be akin to "other crap exists". However, articles' existence may be challenged if another editor feels that they fail any policy or guideline. As a journal of several decades' standing, I think there is likely to be press coverage of the paper by another source, but the article does not cite any. I would enlist your help in enriching the article should you have information at hand. I shall re-evaluate the article in a few days, and will decide whether or not to put the article up for deletion then. Ohconfucius 03:07, 19 April 2007 (UTC)