Talk:Battle of Debecka Pass

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

	This article is within the scope of the Military history WikiProject. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the project and see lists of open tasks and regional and topical task forces. To use this banner, please see the full instructions.
Start	This article has been rated as Start-Class on the quality scale.
Additional information and associated task forces: This article has been checked against the following criteria for B-Class status: Referencing and citation: criterion not met Coverage and accuracy: criterion not met Structure: criterion met Grammar: criterion met Supporting materials: criterion met Associated task forces (nations and regions): United States military history task force

Contents 1 Size of Iraqi forces 2 We Didnt fight Iraq 3 Like Hell We Didn't Fight Iraq 4 Let me try to clear up a few things

[edit] Size of Iraqi forces

The infobox says <100 Troops but the main text says "They found themselves facing an Iraqi mechanized company with hundreds of troops". One of the linked articles say "a reinforced Iraqi motorized rifle company numbering in the hundreds" but the other says "dealt with an Iraqi infantry brigade that was equipped". Does anyone have an idea of the strength of a Iraqi company or brigade? Do any Iraqi accounts of the battle exist? --Mr link 20:27, 24 January 2006 (UTC)

[edit] We Didnt fight Iraq

This was isnt against Iraq, its the insurgents in Iraq.

This was during Operation Iraqi Freedom, during which US forces engaged the Iraqi Army while Hussein was still in power. Note the date of the battle, this was only days after the invasion kicked off. --M45k3d N1Nj4 G4R0 20:46, 9 September 2006 (UTC)

The insurgents do not have tanks to my knowledge.

[edit] Like Hell We Didn't Fight Iraq

The armed forces of a sovereign nation are a representation of that nation. If you fight them you are fighting the nation. Regardless if it was a former regime or not.

The original article has many inaccuracies and a lot of chronological errors about the sequence of events.

Frank, please tell the truth. 3rd Special Forces Group and ODA 391 were not in charge of the ground or the operation. Why don't you quit show-boating, and admit tht ODA 044 and the 10th Special Forces Group was in charge of the operation. If you read the accounts of 3rd Group, you would think they were the only unit there? I hope you enjoyed the attention.

Regardless, according to ODA 044, at one point of the battle, 3rd Group withdrew and left ODA 044 to fend for themselves. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 75.71.165.229 (talk) 17:43, 8 March 2008 (UTC)

[edit] Let me try to clear up a few things

I was physically present during this engagement and captured the account from my perspective in the book: "Roughneck Nine One."

There were several documented accounts of the battle that were written by members of the media that interviewed members of my A-Team or the members of the other two teams that were involved. Almost all were different to some degree.

The actual numbers of Iraqi soldiers we fought that day was between 150-200.

The initial Iraqi assault had:

4ea T-55 Main Battle Tanks (4 man crews) = 16 men 8ea MTLB APCs (2 man crew plus 11 infantry)= 104 Men 3ea 2-1/2 Ton Trucks (2 man crew plus 10+ infantry) = 36+ There were also several small jeeps and SUV as well, each with a few passengers.

This is where we get the 150-200 man estimate.

Of the 19 Javelin Missiles fired, 16 hit enemy vehicles, two actually hit other structures (mud hut, monument) as a result of gunner error, (accidentally locking on the wrong target) and one missile actually missed.

So technically the missiles were 18 for 19 for hitting what they locked on.

We were then counter attacked the following day by a larger force of 6ea T-55 Main Battle Tanks and 16 MTLBs. We took out the lead tank with a Javelin and dropped some bombs on the rest. The counter attack stalled when the enemy turned around and withdrew, later abandoning their vehicles about 3 kilometers away.

The US force consisted of: 26 Special Forces Qualified Soldiers 3 USAF Combat Controllers 2 US Army Military Intelligence soldiers Total= 31 Americans and 80 Pesh (Kurds)

We (US) had eight modified HUMMVs called GMVs (unarmored) armed with either a .50 cal M2HB machine gun or a Mk19 40mm grenade launcher. We had a total of 24 Javelins. We also had two Range Rovers.

The Kurds had one US M151 jeep with a 106mm recoilless rifle, a Toyota pickup with a .51 cal DsHK Machine Gun, one 2 ton truck and several SUVs (Toyota trucks and land cruisers)

Feel free to contact me at Roughneck91@cox.net if you have any additional questions.

Regards, Frank Antenori

I'm glad to see your involvement in this page, as I was about to make a post asking for some clarification by some veterans. While I do not doubt your account of the battle, this page currently has zero citations, though it does have appropriate references (including your book) listed. If you could clarify the facts by backing them up with parenthetical annotation (page number) from your book, and then a brief excerpt of the line you took from the book listed in a notes section, that would be great, and fix a lot of the outstanding problems with this page. This may seem tedious, but it is just part of keeping it professional.

Thank you for your service. This.machinery (talk) 16:04, 29 March 2008 (UTC)