Talk:Bani Utbah
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The Bani Utbah(Arabic: بني عتبة banū l-`utbah) originated from the region of Hijaz in central Arabia.
The Al Bin Ali Tribe are the Utub relating to their great grand father Ali Al-Utbi who is a desendant of their great grand father Utbah hence the name Bani Utbah which means sons of Utbah. Utbah is a section of Khafaf from Bani Sulaim bin Mansoor from Mudhar from Adnan.Being that they are the only tribe to carry the last name Al Utbi in their Ownership's documents of Palm gardens in Bahrain as early as the year 1699 - 1111 Hijri. The plural word for Al Utbi is Utub and the name of the tribe is Bani Utbah.
One of these Documents which belongs to Shaikh Salama Bin Saif Al Utbi one of the Shaikh's of the Al Bin Ali states that Mariam Bint Ahmed Al Sindi, a shia women has sold a Palm Garden in the Island Of Sitra at Bahrain to Shaikh Salama Bin Saif Al Utbi dating to the year 1699 - 1111 Hijri before the arrival of Al-Khalifa to Bahrain by 84 years. [1].
The ruler of Basra has mentioned in an Ottoman document that the tribes of the Utub and Al-Khalayfat have 150 ships and on each ship 2-3 cannons and 30-40 men carrying riffles [2].
This document not only proves that the Utub were living in Bahrain in 1701 but it also proves that the Utub that were mentioned in the Ottoman Document that were living in Bahrain in the year 1701 were the Al Bin Ali because this document which was dated in 1701 is two years after Shaikh Salama Bin Saif Al Utbi's buying of a Palm Garden in Bahrain which was dated in 1699 which means that the Utub that were meant were Al Bin Ali.
Isa Bin Tarif , Chief of the Al Bin Ali Al Utbi Tribe , is a desendant of the Original Utub who conquered Bahrain [3]. Isa Bin Tarif was the Chief of the Al Bin Ali Tribe from the beginning of the 19th Century until his death in 1847. This assertion by Saldanha along with the Ownership documents by the Al Bin Ali Tribe which carry the last name Al Utbi proves without a shadow of a doubt that the Al Bin Ali are the Original Utub who carried the last name Al Utbi in their ownership's document.
Another Document which belongs to Shaikh Mohamed Bin Derbas Al Utbi states that Juma Bin Athbi Al-Jalhimi( the uncle of Rahma Bin Jabir Al Jalahma ) has sold a Palm Garden in the Island of Nabih Saleh in Bahrain to Shaikh Mohamed Bin Derbas Al Utbi dating to the year 1804 [4].
After the Arrival of the great Grandfather's of the Al Khalifa , Al Sabah , and Al Jalahma in the first quarter of the 18th Century to Kuwait [5] ,they entered under the umbrella of the Original Utub Al Bin Ali which was the strongest tribe living in Kuwait at that time. The great Grandfather's of the Al-Khalifa, Al-Sabah, and Al-Jalahma raised the Al-Sulaimi flag of the Utub Al Bin Ali after entering under their umbrella in Kuwait .
The Utub Al Bin Ali carry the Al-Sulaimi flag [6] as they call it in Bahrain, Qatar , Kuwait , and Eastern province in the kingdom of saudi Arabia. The correct name literally is Al-Sulami and it is red and white and is distinguished with four red stripes with three white stripes.It was raised on their ships during wartime and in the pearl season and on special occasions such as weddings and during Eid and in the "Ardha of war" [7].
[edit] References ^ Ownership's Document of a Palm Garden in Island of Sitra, Bahrain belonging to Shaikh Salama Bin Saif Al Utbi dated 1699 - 1111 Hijri, http://www.members.lycos.co.uk/alsahirr/up/pic/aalbin7.gif ^ Ottoman document dated 21 Rajab 1113 Hijri - December 1701, in the archives at the ottoman’s Prime Minister in Istanbul, http://www.the-saudi.net/howela/howela-arabian-gulf/doc01.jpg ^ the Precis Of Turkish Expansion On The Arab Littoral Of The Persian Gulf And Hasa And Katif Affairs, By J. A. Saldana; 1904 , I.o. R R/15/1/724 ^ Ownership's Document of a Palm Garden in Island of Nabih Saleh, Bahrain belonging to Shaikh Mohamed Bin Derbas Al Utbi dated 1804 - 1219 Hijri, http://www.attawash.com/albinali002.jpg ^ The watheeka magazine (third edition) second year, July 1983, p14 ^ Gazetteer of the Persian Gulf, Oman, and Central Arabia, Geographical, Volume 1, John Gordon Lorimer, 1905 ^ Picture of the Al Sulaimi Flag in the "Ardha of War" which was celebrated in Eid Al Fitr in Muharraq 1956 which was attended by Shaikh Salman Bin Hamad Al-Khalifa, ex Ruler of Bahrain, http://www.attawash.com/albinali.jpg
[edit] See also Al Bin Ali History of Kuwait: The Anazia and Bani Utbah (Early Migration and Settlement) History of Bahrain History of Qatar Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bani_Utbah" Categories: Arab groups | Kuwaiti families | Persian Gulf states
[edit] Edits by Alutubi / Arab17
Hi Alutubi, I understand your reasoning. But as I have mentioned before, your claims may be true but they are YOUR claims and do not belong on Wikipedia until they are published somewhere else first. You have taken several primary sources and made your own conclusion, which may or may not be a correct interpretation, but nonetheless violates Wikipedia's policy of Wikipedia:No original research. The page states (WP:PSTS):
To the extent that part of an article relies on a primary source, it should:
- only make descriptive claims about the information found in the primary source, the accuracy and applicability of which is easily verifiable by any reasonable, educated person without specialist knowledge, and
- make no analytic, synthetic, interpretive, explanatory, or evaluative claims about the information found in the primary source.
Furthermore, many of your primary sources are not even verifiable, especially the scanned documents published on the websites such a this one: [1]. How do we know that the document is authentic and has not been doctored? Has it been published elsewhere? Does it even exist in the private library of Shaikh Salama bin Saif? If we can not verify this then the document can not be accepted. (See WP:VER).
For these reasons I will remove your edits. Please don't take it personally.
