Talk:Bakewell tart
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
The article on Bakewell tart is supported by the Derbyshire WikiProject, which is an attempt to improve the quality and coverage of Derbyshire-related articles on Wikipedia. |
| Start | This article has been rated as start-Class on the quality scale. |
| Low | This article has been rated as low-Importance on the importance scale. |
Contents |
[edit] Picture request
There appears to be a bakewell tart already on the Bakewell cake. Is something different required or has someone just forgotton to take Bakewell cake off requested images? Dev920 16:18, 7 June 2006 (UTC)
[edit] De-merge Bakewell pudding
Anyone who has eaten Bakewell Pudding will know that it is nothing like Bakewell Tart. I suggest that there be an article for each one. JeremyA 21:57, 22 January 2006 (UTC)
Absolutely agree. Totally different. To have one article for these two things is nonsense. It's loike having one article ofr Glasgow Rangers and GLasgow Celtic - they're both football teams with Glasgow in the name, must be the same! Robsteadman 22:19, 9 February 2006 (UTC)
Agree - David (www.buxtonspabakery.co.uk)
[edit] Bakewell cake merger
The Bakewell tarts I have seen have all been significantly different from the Bakewell cakes; both in terms of size and in content (no jam, for a start). I vote against any merger with this article. (Like that's a surprise, seeing as I created the other article). Whitepaw 20:24, 9 February 2006 (UTC)
- Changed my mind after finding the Cherry Bakewell article, merge Bakewell cake with that instead of this. -- Whitepaw 15:30, 10 February 2006 (UTC)
I'd suggest merge Cherry Bakewell and Bakewell Cake into Bakeweell Tart and leave the Pudding article alone, exccpt from the erroneous statement that the Pudding and Tart are the same thing. Robsteadman 15:41, 10 February 2006 (UTC)
I think this is a total mess. Pudding is different, though has some links to Tart and Cake (though I'd never heard of the Cake before). Robsteadman 11:03, 25 February 2006 (UTC)
- Totally agree with your reasoning (merge Cherry Bakewell and Bakewell Cake into Bakewell Tart, with the necessary redirects; de-merge the Bakewell Pudding article). Meanwhile, I'm Wikifying the disambiguation page, awaiting your action as described! - Disambiguator 00:30, 7 March 2006 (UTC)
I also agree. These two items are very different. Plus there really is no such thing as a Bakewell Cake, this is the commercial version of a Tart, so named by Mr. Kipling Cakes. It is totally wrong that the Pudding and Tart are on the same page, when the Pudding is the original item and totally different from a Tart and/or the Cherry Bakewell varient. If anything there should be two pages, one for Pudding and one for Tart, with the Tart page acknowledging the varient of the Cherry variety. Awheewall 09:32, 21 March 2006 (UTC)
I work for a bakery in Buxton, near Bakewell. There are various different types of Bakewell "Cake" (which isn't a generic term) - and they are all very different. www.buxtonspabakery.co.uk make all the different types of Bakewell Pudding / Tart (including some different ones). Just my 2 cents worth!
It's now been almost 2 years since I wrote my last comments on the pudding/tart mess that this article is in. I see that the only commenters then and since tended to agree that the pudding and tart are two different things. So unless someone has any better ideas in the next couple of month, I'm going to de-merge the Pudding from this article and create it's own page. I will also make the appropriate reciprical links between the pages and also properly quoting the Cherry Bakewell variety on the tart page. Awheewall (talk) 20:13, 26 February 2008 (UTC)
[edit] Caps
I'm sure Pudding should be pudding, but what abut Bakewell or bakewell? Rich Farmbrough. 13:07, 23 February 2006 (UTC)
-
- BAkewell should have a B not a b Robsteadman 11:02, 25 February 2006 (UTC)
[edit] My two pennies
I was born and lived near Bakewell for 18 years... I have always understood a Bakewell pudding to be a Bakewell tart. I think the confusion arises from the fact that the Bakewell "tart" available in supermarkets is completely different to a real Bakewell Tart/Pudding. They simply call in a "tart" because I believe (but I may be incorrect here) that the term "Bakewell pudding" is protected by EU legislation.
[edit] Plagiarism
Almost the entire introduction of this page is taken directly from here. Once I find the proper template, I will be marking it as such. --Omnipotence407 (talk) 00:51, 8 March 2008 (UTC)
- Given that the introduction of the article appears to have been written piecemeal over the last 2 or so years it seems more likely to me that they copied from here rather than the other way round. —Jeremy (talk) 00:56, 8 March 2008 (UTC)
[edit] Tart v. cake & British context
First, I think needing a citation for the debate about tarts v. cakes is a bit silly; the whole sentence should probably just go -- this is worse than the above "cake vs. pudding" debate (depends on where you're from, generally, and how you want to use, or are accustomed to using, the terms.) (Especially silly in this context since "pudding" is probably a more dramatically changing word (geographically) than tart, which is rarely used to mean such wide ranging things as "dessert" and "custard.") In any case, it would be useful to add some additional context about the history/Britishness of Bakewells -- available in any supermarket, for example, could be modified by UK? Or wherever the homerange of Bakewells is. I have never noticed one in a grocers, although I'll start looking now.Kvcad (talk) 02:39, 18 March 2008 (UTC)
