Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Paniq

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Summary of votes disputed

User:Radman1 inserted a summary of votes at 07:45, 12 Feb 2005. I saw the article in my watchlist shortly afterward and checked the diffs from my last viewing of the page last night (note my local time is UTC), I thus saw his tally (presented as an html comment). I noticed the my name was missing from the tally chart and so I checked the figures and I disagreed with both his keep and delete figures. The difference between versions is:

vote	Rad Man	Thryduulf
Keep	20	20
Delete/Userfy	14	14
Neutral	1	1
Suspect deletes	2	2
Suspect keeps	1	1

note RadMan adjusted his figures in the table above to account for the suspect keep after I pointed it out Thryduulf 08:53, 12 Feb 2005 (UTC)

note I adjusted my figures to take account of the four keep votes I missed. See bottom of this page. Thryduulf 10:21, 12 Feb 2005 (UTC)

See also the full diff between our versions of the page [1]

Rad Man's Tally is presented below, and mine below that. I should make it explicitly clear that I have voted to delete or userfy the article, Rad Man has voted "Extreme keep". Thryduulf 08:39, 12 Feb 2005 (UTC)

• Rad Man's workings:

KEEP votes:

Dan, Paniq, Wyss, Yuckfoo, RaD Man, Alkivar, Kappa, Tuf-Kat, G-Rider, HowardB, ZayZayEM, Samaritan, David Gerard, Centauri, ComCat, ShaunMacPherson, Dan100, Mel Etitis, Beta M, Andylkl (20)

DELETE votes:

Thryduulf, Ungle G, jni, Lawlore, Humblefool, Megan1967, Qdr, Korath, BM, Carp, OntarioQuizzer, Ben Brockert, bbx, ral315 (14)

NEUTRAL vote:

Gargaj (1)

NEW USER votes:

Skrebbel, Marcus22, SKissel (3) -->

• Thyrduulf's workings

Brackets indicate comments or userfy votes.

Delete

1. . Thryduulf (or userfy)
2. . Uncle G (userfy)
3. . Jni (userfy)
4. . Lawlore (userfy)
5. . Humblefool (userfy)
6. . Megan1967
7. . Qdr (or userfy)
8. . Korath
9. . BM
10. . Carrp (userfy)
11. . OntarioQuizzer
12. . Ben Brockert (or userfy)
13. . bbx (or userfy)
14. . ral315 (stron delete)

Suspect deletes

1. . Marcus22
2. . SKissel

Keep

1. . Paniq
2. . Wyss (weak)
3. . RaD Man (extreme)
4. . Alkivar
5. . Kappa
6. . Tuf-Kat
7. . GRider
8. . David Gerard
9. . Centauri
10. . Howard B
11. . ComCat
12. . ShaunMacPherson
13. . Dan100
14. . Mel Ettis
15. . Beta M
16. . Andylkl

Suspect keeps

1. . Skrebbel

---

You are discounting 4 valid Wikipedia members' votes. Please explain your rational. We agree on everything else. -R 08:43, 12 Feb 2005 (UTC)

I counted every bold vote that had not been struck through (or explicitly superceded in the case of Howard B) in the section below your marker. I have since checked and I missed Dan's vote above the section. Yuckfoo didn't bold his changed vote and so I missed it. As David Gerrard didn't bold his vote, Samaritan's vote appeared at a glance to run into his (I wasn't reading the comments, just the votes and names) and I attributed it as a very long vote and comment by David (they both voted the same way). I don't know why I missed ZayZayEM's vote (perhaps because its in the middle of a sentence after a long discussion?). All of the above are accidental errors on my part, for which I appologise. Thryduulf 08:53, 12 Feb 2005 (UTC)

If you will update your figures to reflect the 4 you accidentally missed, this dispute will be officially resolved. -R 10:00, 12 Feb 2005 (UTC)

done. Thryduulf 10:21, 12 Feb 2005 (UTC)