Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Mall sainthwar

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Dear Moderator,

The article on "Mall Sainthwar" is absolutely corret & true. It should not be deleted. The content of the article is based on true history & presented in a scientefic manner.

Regds

Amit Mall Mumbai - India

I regret to inform you that the boundary for inclusion in Wikipedia is Verifiability, not truth. --tjstrf 07:21, 20 October 2006 (UTC)

Please do not go through the wordings. The itention of the sentence is that it is correct. Please note that the contents of the article is very much "verifiable". The same can be verified as per any standard procedure / practice under provisions of Wikipedia. The article is based on certains renowned books written by great historians & also on research.

Regards

Amit Mall

If it is verifiable by books, then by all means, please give us the names of those books! It's not like we want to delete your article to be mean or anything, it simply does not meet the standards for inclusion as it is presently written. --tjstrf Now on editor review! 08:26, 20 October 2006 (UTC)

Dear Moderator,

Regarding verification of article for deletion Mall Sainthwar Rajputs i request you not to delete it as there is enough references . One such book is ATTHARAHAWI SADI KE ZAMINDAR ( Landowners of eighteenth century) written by SAYED NAZMUL RAZA RIZVI. It is in Hindi and published by Peoples publishing house (pvt.)limited,5E,Rani Jhansi Road, New Delhi-55 .This publication was financially supported by INDIAN COUNCIL OF HISTORICAL RESEACH. This book is basically a study about the status of Landowners of eastern Uttar Pradesh.It is a research work done under the guidance of Prof. Dr. Radhey Shyam of the Department of History in Allahabad University.

           This book at page 55 mentions about Mall zamindar Raja Naathu Mall of Majhauli who was gifted Mansabdari by Emperor Jahangir [who ruled over Indiaduring1605-1628 and was author of Tuzuq -e -Jahangiri ].The author  gives reference of Tuzuq -e- Jahangiri English translation Rogers and Webries,London,1909 at page 79&216, Volume1.
          Author Rizvi also mentions about another Mall Zamindar Ajit Mall's status at page 56 and for this he quotes COMMISSIONER'S OFFICE REVENUE RECORDS  RELATEING TO GORAKHPUR VOL.1,FILE NO.4,SERIAL NO.16,PAGE 103.  Simmilerly he mentions about some Sainthwar families  at page 62 quoting above record's VOL..86, FILE NO.80,SERIAL NO. 4, PAGE 18-19  as well as VOL.66, FILE NO. 80, SERIAL NO.4,PAGE 19. 
        Apart from this there are many books where Mall & Sainthwar Rajputs have been mentioned .  Therefore I request you not to delete  the Article.

In case, you require some more clarifications, please inform me. I will try to provide all the informations to the extent possible.

Amit Mall