Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Hajj Amin Elahi

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Contents

[edit] Closing administrator's closing analysis

If you choose to add comments to this page, please do so in a new section below, do not inturrupt my comments here.

[edit] Raw count analysis

  • Delete
  1. Teleomatic (12 edits) <nominator>
  2. Tiddly Tom
  3. Terraxos (2 edits)
  4. Mostlyharmless (2 edits)
  5. Tevildo (3 edits)
  • Keep
  1. SchmuckyTheCat
  2. Georgewilliamherbert
  3. Ali doostzadeh
  4. Neon white (2 edits)
  5. Kevin Murray (3 edits)
  • Non-participatory
  1. Jerry (2 edits) - identifying sockpuppet and SPA
  2. SineBot (2 edits) - signing unsigned comments
  3. The wub - delsort
  4. Yamamoto Ichiro (3 edits) - closed then reverted self and relisted
  5. Gyrofrog (8 edits) !voted, reverted self, abstain from boting, identified sockpuppets
  • SPAs, SUSPSOCKs, and/or invalid rationale
  1. Octavian history (14 edits)
  2. Hasan075
  3. 12.0.30.180
  4. 208.125.21.226
  5. 198.22.123.103
  6. Kurdestani
  7. Musicspotgreen

[edit] Valid delete arguments

  • no notability; fails WP:N, WP:MUSIC
  • references invalid
  • notability not inherited
  • no non-trivial coverage

[edit] Invalid delete arguments

  • previously speedy deleted twice (CSD#A7, CSD#G12)

[edit] Valid keep arguments

  • no obvious failure of WP:BIO/ WP:N
  • assertion made for foreign language sources
  • Tanbur Society webpage provides some context

[edit] Invalid keep arguments

  • nominator has not been with WP very long
  • nominator misstated policy
  • source being book on father does not mean son not notable
  • Notable musician, specially for those that know Eastern music
  • speedy deletion criteria does not apply at AfD; article does not need references
  • WP:ILIKEIT
  • it is hard to find sources on this subject
  • sources not needed if the statements are all true
  • passes smell test
  • recognized as a master of a instrument and famous within a stateless nation
  • deletion is censorship

[edit] Summary

This AFD was polluted by sockpuppet abuse. After filtering the non-valid participation, there was no consensus. JERRY talk contribs 14:43, 3 February 2008 (UTC)