Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Hills Have Eyes documentaries

Requested by 203.143.248.114. StaticGull Talk 16:27, 9 June 2008 (UTC)

Comment. The article was subjected to a proposed deletion on 4 June. The rationale was "While the Hills Have Eyes films appear to meet Wikipedia's inclusion standards, these documentary snippets about the films do not." An IP, noted above, removed the PROD tag and indicated that it should proceed to AFD. No comment on deletion, but the PROD rationale is the only provided deletion rationale, so I thought it prudent to post it here. Best, UltraExactZZ ^Claims ~ Evidence 00:08, 10 June 2008 (UTC)

Weak delete. I don't have much opinion either way on this article - I don't think these documentaries are inherently notable, but the article isn't blatantly violating any policies either. It is verifiable, as they do have pages on IMDB (see this search for 'The Hills Have Eyes': [1]) - which may also be evidence of some degree of notability - but we don't generally have articles on spin-off documentaries, unless they're particularly notable in their own right (the only example I can think of is Empire of Dreams, and even that's questionable). Perhaps this is an area where a new notability guideline is needed. Terraxos (talk) 14:15, 10 June 2008 (UTC)