Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Herbertson
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
[edit] Craig Herbertson
It's claimed that he's a notable author, a notable actor, a notable musician, a notable songwriter, a notable illustrator. Yet the entire history of the GoogleNews archive throws up absolutely nothing of note. [1] Instead, the facts are that as an author he fails WP:BK, as an actor he fails WP:ENTERTAINER, and as a musician and songwriter he fails WP:MUSIC. This is a WP:single-purpose account that, so far, has expressed no interest in contributing anything to Wikipedia apart from Mr. Herbertson's biography, Mr. Herbertson's non-notable fantasy novel, and an anthology that Mr. Herbertson once appeared in, and then peppering other articles with spamlinks to Mr. Herbertson and all of his doings. [2] Qworty (talk) 07:57, 5 June 2008 (UTC)
- Strong Delete. SPA devoted to this person maybe with a COI. The non-notability listed above, to me, makes this a delete. Minkythecat (talk) 12:55, 5 June 2008 (UTC)
Oh dear, this was not my intention. I am Mr Herbertson's wife and sometimes do his promotional work. I didn't think this was promotional though.
I am German and although I am more or less fluent I didn't read all the criteria. I was more concerned with trying to make the article function. I see now the mistake - this notability part. (and conflict of interest) I also wasn't peppering, just trying to respond to the need for references.
Google says this if you google 'herbertson' and 'emerald city':
.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craig_Herbertson - 29k - Cached - Similar pages
Emerald City - #108 For those who like such things, there are photos on the Emerald City web site. ...... like Craig Herbertson, whose brilliant first novel she is publishing, ... www.emcit.com/emcit108.shtml - 195k - Cached - Similar pages
Emerald City - #108 Oh, and welcome to Emerald City, I hope you enjoy it. This issue sees a guest article from multiple Hugo-winning fan writer and Worldcon chair, Mike Glyer. ... www.emcit.com/emcpr108.shtml - 175k - Cached - Similar pages
But I now appreciate that isn't notable enough because it is not multiple. And I think that these critics of the music would probably not be either. I can delete all the articles and references if you want. Sorry! Silkekingofthedirigibles (talk) 15:39, 5 June 2008 (UTC)
CD-Rezension: LORD OF WHISKY Scots' folk at its best kann man da nur sagen!
www.cd-kritik.de, 06.07
CD-Rezension: LORD OF WHISKY Eine mitreißende Folk-CD!
MUSIKER Magazin, 03.06
CD-Rezension: LORD OF WHISKY ... gut gemachte schottische Musik, die nicht zwangsmodernisiert wurde ... Ohrwurmqualität ...
Folker! – Das Magazin für Folk, Lied und Weltmusik, 04.06
CD-Rezension: HEARTS OF GLORY Für Schottland-Fans empfehlenswert, für Hearts-Fans ein absolutes Muss ...
Folker! – Das Magazin für Folk, Lied und Weltmusik, 03.05
