Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Animal Farm Movie Differences

This page is an archive of the proposed deletion of the article below. Further comments should be made on the article's talk page, if it exists; or after the end of this archived section. The result of the debate was delete. – ABCD 8 July 2005 19:46 (UTC)

[edit] Animal Farm Movie Differences

• Non-encylopedic essay. Rmhermen July 3, 2005 03:33 (UTC)
• Delete as original research. One can also read POV into it, given how diehard fans of other written works (*cough* Lord of the Rings *cough*) argue endlessly over movies' not staying 100% faithful to the book. --Idont Havaname 3 July 2005 03:53 (UTC)
• Cleanup to limit article to facts rather than opinions/speculations, and then merge into Animal Farm or redirect to Animal Farm (movie). Dcarrano July 3, 2005 05:20 (UTC)
• Merge and Delete: Grade-C classroom work. Could be used, perhaps, im Animal Farm, but we don't need this sort of index. --Alex12 3 3 July 2005 09:46 (UTC)
• Cleanup' and merge/move per Dcarrano. Kappa 3 July 2005 11:08 (UTC)
• Delete: First, it's original research. Second, there are multiple "movies" of Animal Farm, and not just one. Third, the topic is unsearchable. There are always "differences" between a novel and a film adaptation. Geogre 3 July 2005 13:11 (UTC)
• Delete as stated by Geogre above. Also most of the "Reasons" contain a "probably" which makes the whole thing questionable. There's also one "Reason" which contains an "I have no idea" which is kind of unusual in an "encyclopedic" article, which this definately is not. I can't see a way or even a point, in merging. Rossrs 3 July 2005 14:50 (UTC)
• Delete -- non-encyclopedic, beyond cleanup. Barely an outline. -- DavidH July 3, 2005 15:53 (UTC)
• Delete unencyclopedic CDC (talk) 3 July 2005 16:10 (UTC)
• Delete bad original reseach. — Chameleon 3 July 2005 16:41 (UTC)
• Delete Reason: I have no idea. Perhaps... is original research. ~~~~ 3 July 2005 17:23 (UTC)
• Delete, orig research. If there's any valuable content, then merge it as per Dcarrano. UkPaolo 3 July 2005 19:59 (UTC)
• Merge. Trim the minor differences, and add it as a subsection to the movie section (if'n it exists) in Animal Farm. --Maru 3 July 2005 21:44 (UTC)
• Delete original research. JamesBurns 4 July 2005 00:44 (UTC)
• This would have been useful when I was studying Animal Farm at school! Keep but Merge the pertinent information to Animal Farm. Somebody would have to volunteer to convert this into a readable article 'tho, I'd say the cleanup patrol would do that. Oliver Keenan July 4, 2005 22:18 (UTC)
• Delete, orig research. Merely lists trivial differences to no purpose. carmeld1 6 July 2005 04:23 (UTC)

The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be placed on a related article talk page, if one exists; in an undeletion request, if it does not; or below this section.