Article 200

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Article 200 (Articolul 200 in Romanian) was a controversial section of Romania's Penal Code that criminalised homosexual relationships. It was introduced in 1968, during the regime of dictator Nicolae Ceauşescu, and remained in force until it was repealed by the Năstase government on 22 June 2001. Under pressure from the Council of Europe, it was amended on 14 November 1996, when homosexual sex in private between two consenting adults was decriminalised. However, the amended Article 200 continued to criminalise same-sex relationships if they were displayed publicly or caused a "public scandal". It also continued to ban the promotion of homosexual activities, as well as the formation of gay-centred organisations (including LGBT rights organisations). Until it was repealed completely in 2001, the article was seen as the last Romanian law that discriminated against gays.

Contents

[edit] Content

Until November 1996, Article 200 stated that:

  1. Sexual relations between persons of the same sex are punishable by a prison term between one and 5 years.
  2. The act of a major having sexual relations with a minor of the same sex is punishable by a prison term between 2 and 7 and the withdrawing of some rights.
  3. Sexual relations with a person of the same sex in the impossibility of that person defending themselves or expressing their desire through constraint is punishable by a prison term between 3 and 10 years and the withdrawal of some rights.
  4. If the act committed in points 2 and 3 has the result of gravely injuring the body or health, the prison term will be between five and fifteen years, accompanied by the withdrawal of some rights, and if it has the result of the death or suicide of the victim, the punishment will be a prison term between 15 and 25 years and the withdrawal of some rights.
  5. The impulsion or lure of another person in the viewing of the practice of sexual relations between persons of the same sex, as well as propaganda or any other acts of prosyletism committed for the same purpose are punishable with a prison term between one and 5 years.

On 14 November 1996, when a new Penal Code came into force, the first paragraph of the article was amended to read:

  1. Sexual relations between persons of the same sex, committed in public or producing a public scandal, are punishable by a prison term between one and 5 years.[1]

This amendment brought about the legalisation of homosexual activity in private, but continued to criminalise it in certain circumstances. The wording "committed in public or producing a public scandal" was added as a compromise between those who wanted to maintain homosexuality as a crime (such as parliamentarians from the National Christian-Democratic Peasants Party) and those who wanted the entire article repealed (such as the Council of Europe and human rights organisations).

[edit] Repeal

Article 200 was repealed due to pressure from various organisations. One key factor in its repeal was the European Union, which stated that for Romania to become a full member of the EU, all laws discriminatory to homosexuality had to be abrogated. The Council of Europe also criticised the presence of the law as a negative contributor to Romania's human rights record. Additionally, there was significant pressure from Romanian human rights and LGBT groups, particularly ACCEPT, the largest gay rights organisation in the country.

This led to the start of the Article's repeal on 22 June 2001, when the government adopted Emergency Ordinance 89/2001 modifying the Penal Code and removing Article 200 completely. The ordinance was then sent to the two chambers of parliament for approval. The Chamber of Deputies approved the government's ordinance with 122 votes for, 63 against and 17 abstentions.[2]

The repeal of Article 200 was then approved by the Senate's Juridical Committee on 29 August 2001, with the Senate itself debating and approving the modified version of the Penal Code on September 6. During the debate in the Senate, a secretary of state from the Ministry of Justice, Costache Ivanov, stated that Article 200 was unconstitutional, violating Article 26 of the Constitution of Romania, which protects private life. Additionally, Article 200 came into conflict with Romania's Anti-Discrimination Law of 2000, which explicitly forbids discrimination on the grounds of sexual orientation. The ordinance repealing Article 200 was approved by the Senate, with 83 votes for, 32 against and 6 abstentions.[3]

A march by Noua Dreaptă, a far right-wing organisation, protesting at the decision to repeal Article 200. The poster reads "Do not repeal Article 200".
A march by Noua Dreaptă, a far right-wing organisation, protesting at the decision to repeal Article 200. The poster reads "Do not repeal Article 200".

The repeal of the article was opposed by various groups, sparking a significant amount of controversy. The far-right Greater Romania Party (PRM), which was the largest opposition bloc in both chambers of parliament, opposed the modification of the Penal Code. The party's Senator Aron Belascu stated that this "so-called harmonisation with European legislation was a fatal error"[3] while PRM parliamentarian Dumitru Balaiet argued that Romanians are an Eastern Orthodox people and could not accept homosexuality.[4] Additionally, most religious organisations (including the Romanian Orthodox Church and the Roman Catholic Church in Romania) were against the law's repeal[5]. In particular, Patriarch Teoctist of the Orthodox Church sent a letter to the parliament expressing his "grief and concern" at the intention to repeal the article, which sanctioned what he termed as "practices against nature".[4]. Far right-wing organisations, such as Noua Dreaptă, protested publicly at its abrogation.[6]

On the other hand, the repeal of Article 200 was welcomed both by LGBT rights organisations as well as human rights groups in Romania and worldwide. Adrian Coman, then the executive director of ACCEPT, the largest LGBT rights organisation in Romania, stated in an interview after the article was repealed that: "Thus has been eliminated a delicate subject that appeared on all international agendas regarding homosexuality. From a legislative point of view, Romania has chosen to respect human dignity, putting an end to a culture of fear and humiliation that its citizens of homosexual or bisexual orientation were forced to live through."[7] Additionally, the International Lesbian and Gay Association hailed the removal of Article 200 as a "major and historic step towards the complete elimination of all laws criminalising same-sex relationships in Europe", while also stating that it was a major step towards Romania's membership of the EU.[8]

[edit] Legacy

The repeal of Article 200 was a significant step forward for gay rights in Romania. It also led to a greater visibility and openness of LGBT culture, with the opening of several gay clubs in Bucharest and other urban centres, as well the organisation of the first pride parade and gay festival in Bucharest, in 2005 (see GayFest). More open attitudes about homosexuality also prompted a debate over same-sex marriage in Romania, which was supported by Traian Băsescu, currently president, during his presidential candidacy in the 2004 elections. Despite this, neither same-sex marriage nor any form of same-sex civil partnership are recognised in Romania as of 2007.

[edit] See also

  • Gay rights in Romania
  • Paragraph 175 of the German Criminal Code (banned male homosexual relationships until 1994)
  • Section 28 of the United Kingdom's Local Government Act 1988 (banned the promotion of homosexuality by local governments)

[edit] References

  1. ^ (Romanian) Text of Article 200
  2. ^ (Romanian) Homosexualii primesc drept de liberă practică (Homosexuals receive the right of free practice, Revista Presei
  3. ^ a b (Romanian) Attitude Magazine, Issue 6, September 2001
  4. ^ a b Romanian Chamber of Deputies Votes for Repeal of Article 200, International Lesbian and Gay Association
  5. ^ (Romanian) Catholica.ro - Articolul 200 din Codul Penal românesc va fi modificat, nu abrogat (Article 200 of the Romanian Penal Code will be modified, not repealed)
  6. ^ Protest by Noua Dreaptă regarding the repeal of Article 200
  7. ^ (Romanian) Special on Article 200, Attitude Magazine
  8. ^ Romania Steps Closer to EU after Article 200 Eliminated, The Washington Blade, 15 February 2002

[edit] External links


Rainbow flag Romanian LGBT topics Romanian flag
Law LGBT rights in Romania | Same-sex marriage in Romania | Article 200
People Florin Buhuceanu | Romaniţa Iordache | Lucian Dunăreanu | Toxice
Organisations ACCEPT | Be An Angel
Events GayFest | Gay Film Nights
Media Inklusiv | ENOLA | Switch | Angelicuss | GayOne.ro | Radio Q
This box: view • talk • edit
Languages