Talk:Andrzej Gołota

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article is within the scope of WikiProject Biography. For more information, visit the project page.
Biography Portal
Start This article has been rated as Start-Class on the project's quality scale. [FAQ]
This article is supported by the Sports and games work group.
This article is part of WikiProject Boxing, an attempt to build a comprehensive and detailed guide to boxing on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, you can edit the article attached to this page, or visit the project page, where you can join the project and/or contribute to the discussion.
WikiProject Boxing "To Do"


Contents

[edit] Article name

Why the hell is this page here and not under his name (Andrzej Golota)? Halibutt 22:17, Jun 26, 2004 (UTC)

Because this is the English language Wikipedia and this is the name he is known by to English speakers. RickK 22:19, Jun 26, 2004 (UTC)
Yes, and Kościuszko is known to Americans as Kosciusko while Modrzejewska i called Modjeska. However, these were not the names of these people. It's not the case of English vs. original spelling, it's a case of original spelling vs. common mistake. His official webpage uses his original name in its English version and Gołota is still a Polish citizen. I think we should use the name he uses himself (apparently) and he's got in his papers, not the one used by some of the American newspapers. We don't translate names just for the sake of it, I believe you wouldn't move an article on Johann Sebastian Bach to John Sebastien Bach just because those names have their equivalent in English. I'll ask one of the admins to move this article to where it belongs. [[User:Halibutt|Halibutt]] 15:44, Sep 22, 2004 (UTC)
RickK is correct. If you go to his official website at www.golota.pl, while the graphic has Andrzej Golota on the top of the English section, he is listed as Andrew Golota throughout the text. Therefore, the page is in the correct location as it is -- it needs to stay at Andrew Golota with a redirect at Andrzej Golota. It is not the same as John Sebastien Bach by any stretch of the imagination.
Thanks, BCorr|Брайен 16:07, 22 Sep 2004 (UTC)
He is not referred to as Andrew Golota by his site, he is referred to as such by american boxing portals (check the source of all the info). There is a difference. Also, what is the difference between Kościuszko's name and the name of Gołota? Neither of them changed the name, both of them are called by the Americans in a simplified way. Does it mean that all encyclopedias should use nick-names rather than names? Let's move Adolph Hitler to Hitler or Fuehrer since that is how an average American calls him. Or perhaps we should move Wernher von Braun to Vinnie, because that's how his American pals called him?
I do not say that he is not referred to in America as Andrew Golota. What I say is that Andrew Golota is not his name, it is but a nick-name. Encyclopedias should follow strict naming rules. One of such rules should be to name articles after names, not nick-names. [[User:Halibutt|Halibutt]] 18:59, Sep 22, 2004 (UTC)
Halibutt, you aren't "listening" to people's comments here, and your patronizing tone isn't making your case any stronger while you make the same argument over and over! Here is the first thing on the English section of his official website (please visit it before responding to my comments):
News: There will be no trial against Golota
Prosecution office in Sopot, Poland has dropped charges against Golota on the grounds that alleged victim's wounds were minor ones. It means that Golota can only be sued privately, not by the state's prosecutor.
The case in discussion is related to alleged beating of Jaroslaw T. by Andrew Golota in Sopot in March 2003. It is not known if private charges will be brought up.
Then you will see farther down this section
Andrew's working hard
- Andrew has been working hard for five weeks now. He's gonna start sparring next week. So far we're focusing on conditioning -describes Sam Colonna, Golota's trainer.
He wakes up at 5am and jogs for 45 minutes. We do medicine ball training, skipping rope and heavy bag. We work on speed and leg strength. I promise he will in top shape for Ruiz. - He's always in the gym on time, yesteray sooner than I was.
At least once a week his son joins him who just turned seven last Wednesday. My kids have come to the gym also and we did a little party for Andrew Junior. He LOVES his father! Andrew said many times he doesn't want his son to become a boxer but you never know!
Andrew is as usually careful about his diet. He never ate junk food but he eats a lot of white meat, vegetables and fruit. He drinks one liter of still water during every training.
He does not use a psychologist. Don King made it up before the fight with Chris Byrd. That was a typical PR trick. Golota doesn't need a psychologist, he got me. I can assure you Golota is not afraid of Ruiz.
Also, Halibutt, on Golota's official page you will also find these headings:
  • Interview with Andrew Golota by Doghouseboxing.com
  • Andrew already in great shape
I hope this clarifies the difference between your arguments and the reality of how he refers to himself. Thanks, BCorr|Брайен 20:56, 22 Sep 2004 (UTC)
You didn't read my arguments either, did you. What I wanted to say (perhaps I failed in stating it clearly enough, I'm sorry if this is the case) is that the name the guy has in his passport and ID card seems more important that the name used by some newspapers or portals. I have yet to see a proof that either Gołota changed his name officially or at least uses the anglicized spelling himself. Other than that - I believe that this article should be at Andrzej Gołota, since that is the name he has in his documents and I never ever heard of Gołota refering to himself as "Andrew Golota". Do I make myself clear? Or are there still some nuances of my statements that need to be explained a bit? [[User:Halibutt|Halibutt]] 21:34, Sep 22, 2004 (UTC)
Yes I did read your arguments and I specifically refuted the ones that I felt were based on facts and not opinions.
One example: you said, "He is not referred to as Andrew Golota by his site (he is referred to as such by american boxing portals (check the source of all the info)" -- but he is called "Andrew Golota" right here on his official website http://www.golota.pl.
Simply put, you are incorrect, moj drug! BCorr|Брайен 20:07, 23 Sep 2004 (UTC)
Where has Halibutt been in the last ten years? Does he even know that The Spice Girls and Bill Clinton existed? Its not JUST SOME AMERICAN OUTLETS that call him Andrew Golota, its EVERY BOXING MAGAZINE, NEWSPAPER AND SPORTS SHOW IN THE WORLD THAT DOES. Besides, he may have never referred to himself as "Andrew", but he has never asked not to be referred as "Andrew" either! "Antonio Black Pink Lover Martin"
I admit that I was wrong, most of the articles quoted by his page ('though not the authors of the page itself) use the americanised spelling. However, this does not change anything, the guys still has different name. For me the americanised spelling of non-American names is sort of a nick-name. If so, the articles should have redirects pointing to the true names. However, perhaps you have other idea as to how should we name articles on wikipedia.
Using the abovementioned example of The Spice Girls: should article on Geri Halliwell be moved to Ginger Spice and article on Victoria Beckham to Posh Spice? That's how the media referred to them until the latter maried Beckham.. [[User:Halibutt|Halibutt]] 00:27, Sep 24, 2004 (UTC)
Hey, he is known worldwide as Andrew Golota. Who are they gonna look for when they are looking in the Internet for, Adrezki Golota or Andrew Golota? Our whole purpose is to educate the masses and maybe attract more contributors. And Andrew Golota shpuld stay as Andrew Golota cause, if not, then Michael Jordan should be changed to Michael Jeffrey Jordan as well! Who cares about Michael Jeffrey Jordan except his family? Now, Michael Jordan everybody cares about. How about Madonna Ciccione? Andrew Golota uses the name Andrew Golota professionally, just like Madonna uses Madonna and MJ uses MJ.

As far as The Spice Girls, their real names became public fairly fast after tney became public figures. Trust me on this one, cause I was their #1 fan.

"Antonio Im in Strawberry Fields, the land of the....high lol Martin"

That's what the redirects are for, my friend. The page lists all the cases where redirects are applicable. Among them is the Pseudonyms, nicknames: Butcher of Kurdistan redirects to Ali Hassan al-Majid, Rev. Fred Phelps redirects to Fred Phelps line. [[User:Halibutt|Halibutt]] 09:03, Sep 24, 2004 (UTC)

[edit] Article name II

This is English language wikipedia - Andrzej's common name in English is Andrew Golota not Andrzej Gołota, therefore per WP:COMMONNAME this article should be moved.--Vintagekits (talk) 19:35, 15 May 2008 (UTC)
I don't think I have anything new to add to what I already stated above. Thanks for the notification though. //Halibutt 18:38, 18 May 2008 (UTC)

[edit] Low Blows

I altered the low blows sentence to correctly state that Bowe did not claim to be hit once in the groin, but rather that watching the fight clearly shows several low blows from Golota. I'm not sure the exact number of low blows, if that is known it should be added.


[edit] Bad Wording

Changed "Golota's behavior did not bode well with the crowd who booed and threw objects at him as he walked off towards his dressing room."

to

Golota's behavior did not go over well with the crowd, who booed and threw objects at him as he walked off towards his dressing room.

"Bode" is not really appropriate in this sentence. I replaced it with "go over" so as to change the wording a little as possible, but the entire structure of the sentence could probably be improved.

bode 1. To be an omen of: heavy seas that boded trouble for small craft. 2. Archaic To predict; foretell.


The entire paragraph is poorly constructed, confusing, and badly worded, in my opinion, and should be re-written.