Image:Action1.JPG

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Fair use rationale

Non-free image data
Description

Cover for Action Comics #1 (June 1938) Art by Joe Shuster.

Source

http://www.comics.org/coverview.lasso?id=293&zoom=4 (similar file if not the one originally uploaded.)

Portion used

Full front cover as published.

Low resolution?

300px size unsuitable to use for high reproduction.

Other information

All DC Comics characters and the distinctive likeness(es) thereof are Trademarks & Copyright © 1938 DC Comics, Inc. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.


This image, Action1.jpg, is being linked here; though the picture is subject to copyright I (Hiding Talk) feel it is covered by the U.S. fair use laws because:

  1. No free alternative can exist given the likeness of the character Superman is a trademark and thus protected;
  2. It is a low resolution copy of a comic book cover;
  3. It does not limit the copyright owner's rights to sell the comic book in any way;
  4. Copies could not be used to make illegal copies of the comic book cover art on another comic book;
  5. The image is significant; it is the cover to Action Comics issue 1, the first appearance of Superman, thought to be the first super-hero;
  6. The issue in question is discussed within the article, thus using this image to identify the issue is thought fair use;
Non-free image rationale for Action Comics
Article

Action Comics

Purpose of use

For identification purposes in conjunction with discussion of the topic of the article.

  1. The image is significant; it is the cover to Action Comics issue 1, the first appearance of Superman, thought to be the first super-hero.
  2. The image is from the historically significant debut issue of the series.
  3. It illustrates an educational article about the comic book from which the cover illustration was taken.
Replaceable?

No free use image available. As this is a fictional, copyrighted character and a copyrighted publication, a freely-licensed alternative could not reasonably be obtained.

Non-free image rationale for Action Comics 1
Article

Action Comics 1

Purpose of use

For identification purposes in conjunction with discussion of the topic of the article.

  1. The image is significant; it is the cover to Action Comics issue 1, the first appearance of Superman, thought to be the first super-hero.
  2. The image is from the historically significant debut issue of the series.
  3. It illustrates an educational article about the comic book from which the cover illustration was taken.
Replaceable?

No free use image available. As this is a fictional, copyrighted character and a copyrighted publication, a freely-licensed alternative could not reasonably be obtained.

Non-free image rationale for American comic book
Article

American comic book

Purpose of use

Illustration of an example and/or a specific point within the article.

  1. It illustrates two educational articles about these interrelated topics (cf Superhero).
  2. The image is used as one of the primary means of visual identification of the article topic.
  3. The image is from the historically significant first appearance of the character Superman, the seminal archetype of the superhero, in one of the first major American comic books. It is one of the most famous and historically significant publications of what fans and historians call the Golden Age of Comic Books.
  4. The image is significant; it is the cover to Action Comics issue 1, the first appearance of Superman, thought to be the first super-hero.
  5. The issue in question is discussed within the article, thus using this image to identify the issue is thought fair use.
Replaceable?

No free use image available. As this is a fictional, copyrighted character and a copyrighted publication, a freely-licensed alternative could not reasonably be obtained.

Non-free image rationale for DC Comics
Article

DC Comics

Purpose of use

Illustration of a specific point within the article.

  1. It illustrates these two educational articles about the publishing company and a landmark case involving that company (cf National Comics Publications v. Fawcett Publications}.
  2. The image is used as one of the primary means of visual identification of the article topic.
  3. The image is from the historically significant debut of the character Superman, a cornerstone of DC Comics, and the subject of the lawsuit filed by DC very shortly following the debut of this issue and the character.
Replaceable?

No free use image available. As this is a fictional, copyrighted character and a copyrighted publication, a freely-licensed alternative could not reasonably be obtained.

Non-free image rationale for History of Superman
Article

History of Superman

Purpose of use

Illustration of a specific point within the article.

  1. It illustrates four interrelated educational article about the character Superman (cf Superman, Superman (Earth-Two), and Origin of Superman).
  2. The image is used as one of the primary means of visual identification of the article topic.
  3. The image is from the historically significant debut of the character.
Replaceable?

No free use image available. As this is a fictional, copyrighted character and a copyrighted publication, a freely-licensed alternative could not reasonably be obtained.

Non-free image rationale for Joe Shuster
Article

Joe Shuster

Purpose of use

Illustration of the artist's work.

  1. The image is significant; it is the cover to Action Comics issue 1, the first appearance of Superman, thought to be the first super-hero;
  2. The issue in question is discussed within the article, thus using this image to identify the issue is thought fair use;
Replaceable?

No free use image available. As this is a fictional, copyrighted character and a copyrighted publication, a freely-licensed alternative could not reasonably be obtained.

Non-free image rationale for National Comics Publications v. Fawcett Publications
Article

National Comics Publications v. Fawcett Publications

Purpose of use

Illustration of an example and/or a specific point within the article.

  1. It illustrates these two educational articles about the publishing company and a landmark case involving that company (cf DC Comics}.
  2. The image is used as one of the primary means of visual identification of the article topic.
  3. The image is from the historically significant debut of the character Superman, a cornerstone of DC Comics, and the subject of the lawsuit filed by DC very shortly following the debut of this issue and the character.
Replaceable?

No free use image available. As this is a fictional, copyrighted character and a copyrighted publication, a freely-licensed alternative could not reasonably be obtained.

Non-free image rationale for Origin of Superman
Article

Origin of Superman

Purpose of use

Illustration of an example and/or a specific point within the article.

  1. It illustrates four interrelated educational article about the character Superman (cf Superman, Supermn (Earth-Two), and History of Superman).
  2. The image is used as one of the primary means of visual identification of the article topic.
  3. The image is from the historically significant debut of the character.
Replaceable?

No free use image available. As this is a fictional, copyrighted character and a copyrighted publication, a freely-licensed alternative could not reasonably be obtained.

Non-free image rationale for Superhero
Article

Superhero

Purpose of use

Illustration of an example and/or a specific point within the article.

  1. It illustrates two educational articles about these interrelated topics (cf American comic book).
  2. The image is used as one of the primary means of visual identification of the article topic.
  3. The image is from the historically significant first appearance of the character Superman, the seminal archetype of the superhero, in one of the first major American comic books. It is one of the most famous and historically significant publications of what fans and historians call the Golden Age of Comic Books.
  4. The image is significant; it is the cover to Action Comics issue 1, the first appearance of Superman, thought to be the first super-hero.
  5. The issue in question is discussed within the article, thus using this image to identify the issue is thought fair use.
Replaceable?

No free use image available. As this is a fictional, copyrighted character and a copyrighted publication, a freely-licensed alternative could not reasonably be obtained.

Non-free image rationale for Superman
Article

Superman

Purpose of use

Illustration of an example and/or a specific point within the article.

  1. It illustrates four interrelated educational article about the character Superman (cf Superman (Earth-Two), History of Superman, and Origin of Superman).
  2. The image is used as one of the primary means of visual identification of the article topic.
  3. The image is from the historically significant debut of the character.
Replaceable?

No free use image available. As this is a fictional, copyrighted character and a copyrighted publication, a freely-licensed alternative could not reasonably be obtained.

Non-free image rationale for Superman (Earth-Two)
Article

Superman (Earth-Two)

Purpose of use

Illustration of an example and/or a specific point within the article.

  1. It illustrates four interrelated educational article about the character Superman (cf Superman, History of Superman, and Origin of Superman).
  2. The image is used as one of the primary means of visual identification of the article topic.
  3. The image is from the historically significant debut of the character.
Replaceable?

No free use image available. As this is a fictional, copyrighted character and a copyrighted publication, a freely-licensed alternative could not reasonably be obtained.

[edit] Liscensing

File history

Click on a date/time to view the file as it appeared at that time.

Date/TimeDimensionsUserComment
current01:22, 1 November 2006300×416 (50 KB)J Greb (Talk | contribs) (Reduced size of original upload as per Project discussion.)