User talk:81.84.162.66

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Re. Desenrascanço

Well, the contents of that article were quite a good example of WP:BOLLOCKS. Here, I'll paste the deleted article to you below. It was somehow amusing anyway, but totally inadequate for an encyclopedia. Regards, Húsönd 18:16, 13 May 2008 (UTC)

Desenrascanço (loosely translated as "disentanglement"; pronounced: [dɨ.zẽ.ʁɐʃ.'kɐ̃.su]) is a Portuguese word used in certain specific contexts and situations. It is used to express an ability to solve a problem without the adequate tools or proper technique to do so, and by use of sometimes imaginative resourcefulness when facing new situations. Achieved when resulting in a hypothetical good-enough solution. When that good solution escapes us we get a failure (enrascanço — entanglement). Most Portuguese people strongly believe it to be one of their most valued virtues and a living part of their culture. However, some critics disagree with the association of desenrascanço to the Portuguese culture. They argue that this concept is related to the subjective evaluation of oneself, or of the Portuguese people, and that it belongs to the world of subjectivity and feeling. Some are of the opinion that the concept is related to the discoveries period of the 15th century. But sceptics doubt there is any substantial proof of that relation.

In the 16th and 17th centuries it was very common for other exploring nations, such as the Dutch, to bring a Portuguese national along during the voyages, because the Portuguese were allegedly the most skilled and knowledgeable in the proper handling of the occasional emergency aboard the ship when the control of the vessel was given to them (what is known among the Portuguese as "desenrascanço"). Desenrascanço is in fact the opposite of planning: it's managing that any problem does not get completely out of hand and beyond solution.

Desenrascanço in the Portuguese dictionary

In the Portuguese dictionary it is stated: enrascar | v. tr. | v. refl. (Eng. transitive verb, reflex verb)

transitive verb:

   * apanhar em rasca; (to mangle ropes)
   * enredar; (threading)
   * embaraçar cabos; (to abash cables)
   * velas; (sails)

figurative:

   * fazer cair em armadilha; (entrapment)
   * criar dificuldades; (cause difficulties)
   * atrapalhar; (to stand in the way)
   * encravilhar;
   * desenmerdar;

reflective verb:

   * meter-se em enrascada; (getting in trouble)
   * meter-se em problemas. (getting in trouble)

therefore, "des", a negation prefix, means exactly the opposite.

in the Portuguese dictionary also: desenrascar | v. tr. | v. refl. (transitive verb, reflex verb)

transitive verb:

   * desembaraçar o que estava enrascado; (disentangle what was previously entangled)
   * livrar alguém de apuros; (get someone out of trouble)

reflective verb:

   * livrar-se de uma dificuldade. (to overcome adversity)

Desenrascanço in the Praxe Académica

For a more universal and well known assumption of this section's theme see Praxe académica

Desenrascanço has a role in the academic culture (alumni culture, not Academia in general) in most educational institutions, although the use of the word Desenrascanço itself, is not common inside the majority of those institutions. In most universities and technical institutes, the older students known as doutores (Eng. doctors, loosely sophomores) teach Desenrascanço to freshmen (Port. Caloiros) through a ritual widely known in Portugal as the Freshmen Reception, a part of the "Academic Rite of Passage" (Port. Praxe Académica). It is said that this skill has been taught informally in the oldest Portuguese university (University of Coimbra) as one of Praxe's ritual characteristics since the 14th or 15th centuries. The freshmen are ordered to do the most impossible things. They must comply or they will be punished. To solve the challenges (desenrascar-se) they must be inventive and/or have a very compelling reason when unable to. Usually, if they cannot complete the task or if they are not smart enough and find a boring solution, a punishment is applied. The punishment is supposedly done under the Rite's Code (Port. Código de Praxe) and is allegedly harmless. But they can get dirty, do a lot of physical exercise or be publicly embarrassed; on the other hand they can even end up doing absolutely nothing and standing still for an hour. Freshmen perform this ritual in order to join academic fraternities and have fun in the continuous parties these groups hold throughout the academic year, and to generally gather a helpful group of friends. In the rituals, the doutores are dressed wholly in black (in 19th century traditional attire) and freshmen in white (usually a white shirt and blue jeans nowadays). This might be considered an initiation ritual in most Portuguese universities. The ritual varies widely between universities and technical institutes.

It must be said that this is not an undisputed point. Some have a much less flattering view of these rituals and feel that these practises are degrading and should be stopped. The claim that the freshmen perform the rituals to join academic fraternities and parties throughout the year is said to be just a tactic to scare people into participating. Even the link between Desenrascanço and the Freshmen Reception is not universally accepted as it is argued that the rituals are pointless and uninventive.

In the most traditional academic institutions, another sort of rite is done, this time in secret and at night (due to its secrecy it has not spread to most new universities and is unknown by most) it is called sometimes as Praxe de doutor (Doctor's Rite) made by a veterano (veteran, a student that has been studying at the university for longer than the course's duration). The final part of this rite consists of difficult and sometimes impossible tasks that are typically harder than those for freshmen, but normally desenrascanço is made in a much better and inventive way. Because of its difficulty, collaboration between various doutores is needed and is also good strategy (desenrascanço is not always just lacking a plan). There are also other variations for these rites, some do not require desenrascanço.

Its is possible, although arguable that Siemens, a well known German company, has development and engineering offices in Portugal partly due to this Portuguese trait, employing hundreds of Portuguese staff. Desenrascanço is the finding of a quick and smart (and some times cheap) solution for a given problem.

Military

In popular parlance in Portugal (and indeed in the army), "enrascar" meant to put someone in an undesirable situation (or, sometimes, to punish). The person undergoing that situation would naturally try to get out of it by cunning, which was highly valued in the military subculture that cultivates 'esprit de corps', especially if it was done without putting anyone else at risk, better still if "saving" others along out of the same trouble (see the entry "desenrascar" in Lexicoteca Moderno Dicionario da Lingua Portuguesa, vol. 1, Circulo de Leitores, Lisboa, 1985, p. 770: 'to de-entangle what was "enrascado"' and (pop) 'to get out of trouble'). When talking about their time in service or instruction, the military often say A tropa manda desenrascar (The army orders you to apply desenrascanço).

Near equivalents in other cultures

Desenrascanço is vaguely similar to the English-language concept of a hack, the French système D or débrouillardise, the Spanish chapuza, the Brazilian Gambiarra, or the German durchwurschteln, though each of these has different nuances.

The concept of Bush technology used by Australian field geologists is perhaps the most accurate equivalent. Used to work in harsh conditions, where the proper tools can be several thousands of kilometers away, these geologists often repair cars and create useful devices with whatever they find available. The Australian road-builder and adventurer Len Beadell wrote several chronicles relating his experiences in the outback, often featuring the use of bush technologies.

This "desenrascanço" or "desenrasco" (another common word for desenrascanço) is indeed the ability to solve problems in very adverse conditions, and Portuguese are forced to be good at it. Many of the Portuguese inventions in the Geneva Inventions Exhibition are an example of how desenrascanço is used to create new tools that are typically cheaper.

'Desenrascanço' and the "Art of Muddling Through"

There are similarities between desenrascanço and "muddling through", see Lindeblom, C.E. (1959), The Science of Muddling Through, Public Administration Review, Spring, pp. 79-88 and Lindeblom, C.E. (1979), Still Muddling Not Yet Through, Public Administration Review, Nov/Dec, pp. 517-526. Lindblom description of management as "Muddling Through" is very similar to the Portuguese notion of "desenrascanço", to manage by one self (by cunning and possibly previous experience more than mere trial and error) a way out of dire situations. Lindblom is claimed to have been precursor of Quinn's notion of logical incrementalism (Quinn, James Brian (1978) Strategic Change as 'Logical Incrementalism', Sloan Management Review, Fall, pp.7-21). 1

Examples of 'Desenrascanço'

Although being a fictional American TV show character, MacGyver is a good example of 'Desenrascanço'. Whenever he finds himself in a jam (entanglement/'Enrascanço') he always manages to escape and to make the best of the situation using whatever items are at hand, e.g. using duct tape (it is important to notice that duct tape is little known in Portugal and zinc-coated steel wire can be roughly considered the portuguese alternative to american duct tape, since it is a strong, cheap and widely available fastener that can be worked with simple tools) as a temporary solution to hold things together (things that usually would need welding or screwing) or using his pocket knife like a full toolset. Another fine example of "Desenrascanço" is the crude filtering apparatus the engineers come up with at NASA when Apollo 13 was faced with a dangerously high CO2 level due to a contingency where the lunar module was not designed to support three astronauts(instead of the usual two) for the extended period of time that it did (as depicted in the movie, "Apollo 13")..