Wikipedia:WikiProject Airlines/Airport clubs

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] How should airport clubs be listed?

My first reaction is to say a heading under the airline. That way it can be linked from other airlines that have access. I don't think that each club needs an article, though you could say that they are more important than schools due to the business transactions that occur in those rooms and deserve an article. Vegaswikian 17:21, 25 July 2005 (UTC)

Well... I agree with you. We should have a section in the airline page for the club locations. Many people have been arguing with me claiming that Wikipedia is not a Directory, which I believe is true. However, since the information provided uses less pages and eliminates the need to visit the airlines' website, we should have the information on the page itself. Having a link to the airline page eliminates the need for the section which therefore would mean that we wouldn't need the section whatsoever if we had a link to the airlines' website. The way it is in most pages right now is the way it should be. The whole point of putting the locations in the page was to eliminate the single pages just for the airline club. We have discussed this a while back and I believe this issue is arrising once again with different views. A few people who have thought that they should be on the airline page no believe they should not. We need to reach an agreement. View the discussion page as to how I still believe the section should be layed-out.--Golich17 02:12, 21 February 2007 (UTC)