User talk:VoteFair

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] K-Y edits

I don't know if you're still editing, but I though you should know I made a pretty major overhaul to 'your' page Kemeny-Young method. I tried to seperate out three components:

• The Kemeny-Young method, the general system (which has no particular implementation) including the properties satisfied
• Kemeny's original method, "lowest wins"
• The VoteFair method, "highest wins" and various implementational improvements (e.g. unranked candidates are tied for last place)

If you'd like to differ on the particular execution of my cleanup, let's talk about how to do it before editing directly, so we're no accidentally changing each others' edits. CRGreathouse (talk | contribs) 16:06, 24 August 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Recent edits

On the K-Y page, you wrote:

To CRGreathouse, you offer no explanation of why you undid my recent edits. They involve many improvements. As one example I didn't list earlier, the "runtime" criteria does not involve an fairness issue, which is what this table conveys, so I moved it outside the table. The reversion restored numerous mistaken and confusing wordings, so I'll restore the correction. In the future, please make specific edits if there is something you don't agree with.

I don't believe I undid any of your recent edits. I have made only one edit to the article in the last 5 or 6 months, which was a careful edit to some ambiguous wordings.

I would like to discuss your proposed changes, though; I left a comment to that effect on the K-Y talk page. Also, I think you should make explicit which wordings you felt were mistaken or confusing so they can be improved. CRGreathouse (t | c) 14:10, 14 February 2007 (UTC)