Wikipedia:VfD decisions not backed by current policies

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This Wikipedia page is currently inactive and is retained primarily for historical interest. Per Wikipedia:Policies and guidelines: "A historical page is any proposal for which consensus is unclear, where discussion has died out for whatever reason."
If you want to revive discussion regarding the subject, you should seek broader input via a forum such as the village pump.

Note: This page is currently a policy proposal by User:SimonP. Please do not use this page at this time. A discussion on the merits of this proposal is ongoing on its talk page.

This is a list of pages where a significant majority of the voters on Wikipedia:Votes for Deletion supported deleting an article, but when this decision contravened standing policies. Pages listing valid reasons for deletion include Wikipedia:Deletion policy, Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not, and Wikipedia:Verifiability. For now these articles have been kept, merged, or redirected and a note has been placed on their talk page explaining that they may be deleted upon a change in Wikipedia policies.

1 Schools
2 Off-campus buildings
3 Books
4 Musical bands

[edit] Schools

Current policy: Wikipedia:Deletion policy makes no reference whatsoever to schools either way. Wikipedia talk:Deletion policy/schools only formed consensus regarding schools for those under age five and those automatically entered by a bot, consensus being 'delete'. Some guidelines for inclusion have been enunciated by User:Dpbsmith. See also: Wikipedia:Importance, Template:School.

St Edwards School (VfD votes)
St Andrew's High School, Kirkcaldy, Scotland (VfD votes)
St Stephen's School Bath (VfD votes)
Huntington School York (VfD votes)

[edit] Off-campus buildings

The following are off-campus student-run houses that are not affiliated with the university they are near.

Current policy: Nothing specific. Jimbo once got annoyed at such deletions. Some such submissions could fall under the category of vanity articles. Some could have fallen below the standard of Wikipedia:Importance, if that had been adopted.

Finlandia co-op (VfD votes)
Watermyn (VfD votes)

[edit] Books

Current policy: Nothing specific. Works by a vanity press or included in Wikipedia by their own author are taken to be vanity articles and/or advertising.

Meaning and Knowledge (VfD votes)
WP:FICT is relevant semi-policy, and regularly cited on VfD

[edit] Musical bands

Current policy: Nothing specific. Bands that have never released a record or receive few Google hits are routinely deleted as vanity articles and unverifiable. See also Wikipedia:Vanity page and Wikipedia:Verifiability