Wikipedia:Version 1.0 Editorial Team/Neopaganism articles by quality

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

You have new messages (last change).
↑ Index Neopaganism articles by quality assessment table log, statistics →


[edit] Wikipedia:WikiProject Neopaganism/Assessment

Contact with WP Neopaganism/Assessment
Article
Date
Comments
Aradia, or the Gospel of the Witches [1] Mid January 25, 2007 Featured article FA 0.5
Janet Farrar [2] High January 6, 2007 Good article GA Since I marked the article as GA-class, I'd just like to comment that it's been tagged as a GA since February and appears well-referenced, well-illustrated, and fairly neutral and stable. - AdelaMae (talk - contribs) 02:50, 7 December 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Stewart Farrar [3] High January 5, 2007 Good article GA Article was passed as a GA - here are the comments from Katsam, who passed it. - AdelaMae (talk - contribs) 16:59, 7 December 2006 (UTC)

[edit] GA

I'm passing this article. I don't know anything about Stewart Farrar or Neopaganism but it is a well-referenced article and smoothly written, easy for an uninvolved person to understand.

Some suggestions: I did notice that the footnotes were mostly inside the punctuation when I think they're supposed to be outside the punctuation, but that's a quibble. A meatier suggestion is that it would be good to know why Farrar was considered so influential in Wiccan/Neopagan circles. Was it because of the What Witches Do book? Did he attract people into Wicca/Neopaganism with his novels? Or was it the Eight Sabbats for Witches book? And finally, if you're going to mention that he had seven wives, maybe you should mention it in the "early life and career" section -- it's a little too startling to be packed into a sentence fragment. Katsam 11:28, 7 December 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Importance

I rated this as High, but I'm very much of the opinion it's BARELY high importance, as it IS. I think the article needs to show his importance more, and maybe that isn't a reasons for saying mid level importance, but a quality issue, which si why I went with high. He is, outside of Alex Sanders, the most well known Alexandrian, and co-author of a number of seminal works about Wicca.--Vidkun 18:44, 4 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Stregheria [4] High January 10, 2007 Good article GA
Neopaganism [5] Top January 6, 2007 B Article has a lot of information, but it seems that it is generally agreed to be a bit of a mess. Needs more source citations and cleanup. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 06:46, 6 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Alex Sanders (Wiccan) [6] High January 22, 2007 B
Gerald Gardner [7] High January 14, 2007 B I rated this article as B-class because it is decent as it stands, but could be a lot more thorough as there is quite a bit more information available on Gardner. - AdelaMae (talk - contribs) 03:02, 7 December 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Wicca [8] High January 5, 2007 B I have rated this article in both the quality and importance scales. I gave it a B for quality, because while it does tell a lot about Wicca in general, it needs a whole lot more sourcing. As for importance, considering that from a reader's POV, Wicca is probably one of the most notable forms of NeoPaganism, I feel this justifies a High rating, maybe verging on Top.--Vidkun 18:30, 4 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Bideford witch trial [9] Mid January 25, 2007 B
Feri Tradition [10] Low January 11, 2007 B Looks like it could be a GA with cleanup. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 00:42, 11 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Artemis [11] January 25, 2007 B Some reference to her history before the Indo-European conquest of Greece is probably called for. See Karl Kerényi's books for some details. Badbilltucker 20:47, 24 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Gleb Botkin [12] March 10, 2007 B
Kemetic reconstructionism [13] January 3, 2007 B
Magic (paranormal) [14] January 25, 2007 B
Magic (paranormal)/Archive of the Paranormal March 2, 2007 B
Margaret Murray [15] January 25, 2007 B
Triple Goddess [16] January 25, 2007 B
Coven [17] Mid January 11, 2007 Start Citations needed. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 00:38, 11 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Raymond Buckland [18] Mid January 14, 2007 Start Bibliography is twice the length of article content. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 22:24, 13 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Faerie faith [19] Low January 11, 2007 Start Article needs expansion and consistent citation method. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 00:26, 11 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Faery Wicca [20] Low January 11, 2007 Start Very nice links and references; needs expansion. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 00:31, 11 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Gerina Dunwich [21] Low January 14, 2007 Start The article is more than a stub, but it is rather disorganized and lacks references, which is very much a bad thing in a bio of a living person. It seems to be on the right path. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 09:47, 9 December 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Allen H. Greenfield [22] February 2, 2007 Start New article, looks pretty darned good but it is fighting an AfD. Once the KEEP is in, I would upgrade this to a B. --Bill W. Smith, Jr. (talk/contribs) 01:17, 2 February 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Aradia (goddess) [23] January 25, 2007 Start
Aradia di Toscano [24] January 25, 2007 Start
Book of Veles [25] January 22, 2007 Start
Celtic Reconstructionist Paganism [26] January 25, 2007 Start
Central Valley Wicca [27] February 8, 2007 Start I'm unsure if this article meets the notability guidelines. It is a good start on an article as far as that goes, but this may be too specialized or obscure a topic for Wikipedia as a whole. (edit comment)
Circle Sanctuary [28] January 25, 2007 Start
Council of Magickal Arts [29] January 22, 2007 Start As the author of this page, I simply set the class to Start. --Bill W. Smith, Jr. 05:25, 22 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Covenant of the Goddess [30] January 25, 2007 Start
Diana (mythology) [31] January 25, 2007 Start
Dianic Wicca [32] January 25, 2007 Start
Dianic tradition [33] January 25, 2007 Start
Dorothy Clutterbuck [34] January 25, 2007 Start
Eclectic Wicca [35] January 25, 2007 Start
Ellinais [36] January 25, 2007 Start
Fivefold kiss [37] January 25, 2007 Start
Gardnerian Wicca [38] January 25, 2007 Start
Germanische Glaubens-Gemeinschaft [39] January 25, 2007 Start
Handfasting [40] January 6, 2007 Start Unreferenced; could be B-class if properly referenced. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 16:33, 5 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Hard polytheism [41] January 6, 2007 Start Article lacks references and large portions may be original research. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 16:35, 5 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Homosexuality and Wicca [42] January 6, 2007 Start Article lacks references and I am unsure of its accuracy. Needs to be edited for grammar/style. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 17:08, 5 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Homosexuality in Norse paganism [43] March 18, 2007 Start
Isaac Bonewits [44] January 25, 2007 Start
Laurie Cabot [45] January 25, 2007 Start
Margot Adler [46] January 6, 2007 Start I rated this article as Start-class because much more information is needed and it appears kind of disorganized. It seems comparable to the articles listed as examples of Start-class work. - AdelaMae (talk - contribs) 02:56, 7 December 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Neo-druidism [47] January 25, 2007 Start Needs citation of sources. Badbilltucker 01:59, 24 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
New Forest coven [48] February 2, 2007 Start
Nornirs Ætt [49] January 25, 2007 Start
Pagan Spirit Gathering [50] January 25, 2007 Start
Pagan's Night Out [51] January 22, 2007 Start
Pagans In Recovery [52] January 25, 2007 Start
Polytheistic reconstructionism [53] January 25, 2007 Start
Raven Grimassi [54] January 25, 2007 Start
Reclaiming (neopaganism) [55] January 25, 2007 Start
Romuva (church) [56] January 25, 2007 Start
Scott Cunningham [57] January 25, 2007 Start
Selena Fox [58] January 25, 2007 Start
Starhawk [59] January 25, 2007 Start
Starwood Festival [60] January 25, 2007 Start
Sybil Leek [61] January 25, 2007 Start
The Spiral Dance [62] January 25, 2007 Start
Traditions Magazine [63] January 25, 2007 Start
Unverified personal gnosis [64] January 25, 2007 Start
Wheel of the Year [65] January 25, 2007 Start
Zsuzsanna Budapest [66] January 25, 2007 Start
Ásatrú [67] January 25, 2007 Start
Great Rite [68] Mid January 13, 2007 Stub Article needs expansion and proper referencing. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 01:57, 13 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
A Witch Alone [69] Low January 16, 2007 Stub Article doesn't give explanation of why this book is significant/interesting. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 19:27, 15 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Adriana Porter [70] Low January 16, 2007 Stub
Alexei Kondratiev [71] Low January 13, 2007 Stub Expansion of this article has been requested. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 01:27, 13 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Altar (Wicca) [72] Low January 16, 2007 Stub
Animistic Tradition [73] Low January 16, 2007 Stub This article needs help. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 19:35, 15 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Arcadia VZW [74] Low January 16, 2007 Stub
Covenstead [75] Low January 14, 2007 Stub Article needs expansion; Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Covenstead may have some useful suggestions. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 22:19, 13 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Diipetes [76] Low January 14, 2007 Stub Article is only a few lines long, and covers two very different meanings of the word (one of which is not neopaganism-related). - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 22:08, 13 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Falcon River [77] Low January 11, 2007 Stub Article is two sentences long. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 00:33, 11 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heartland Pagan Festival [78] Low January 6, 2007 Stub Severely in need of expansion. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 16:24, 5 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Hellenion [79] Low January 6, 2007 Stub Tagged as stub, lacks independent sources. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 16:42, 5 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Old Stones, New Temples [80] Low January 14, 2007 Stub Needs more information on the significance of the book. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 22:21, 13 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
SpiralScouts International [81] Low January 25, 2007 Stub
Temple of Diana [82] Low February 5, 2007 Stub
Alp-luachra [83] January 22, 2007 Stub
Ann Forfreedom [84] January 22, 2007 Stub
Aquarian Tabernacle Church [85] January 22, 2007 Stub
Baedun Hill [86] January 25, 2007 Stub
Baltic neopaganism [87] January 25, 2007 Stub
Boline [88] January 25, 2007 Stub
Cassandra Eason [89] January 25, 2007 Stub
Celtic Wicca [90] January 25, 2007 Stub
Charge of Aradia [91] January 25, 2007 Stub
Charge of the Goddess [92] January 25, 2007 Stub
Church of Aphrodite [93] March 10, 2007 Stub
Correllian Nativist Church [94] January 25, 2007 Stub
Covenant of Unitarian Universalist Pagans [95] January 3, 2007 Stub
Craft name [96] January 25, 2007 Stub
Dafo [97] January 25, 2007 Stub
Deborah Lipp [98] January 25, 2007 Stub
Dievturība [99] January 25, 2007 Stub
Doreen Valiente [100] January 25, 2007 Stub
Drawing down the Moon (ritual) [101] January 25, 2007 Stub
Druidcraft [102] January 25, 2007 Stub
Earth religion [103] January 25, 2007 Stub
Eldaring [104] January 25, 2007 Stub
Foreningen Forn Sed [105] January 25, 2007 Stub
Gavin Frost [106] January 25, 2007 Stub
Gothi [107] January 25, 2007 Stub
Green Egg [108] January 25, 2007 Stub
Heidnische Gemeinschaft [109] January 6, 2007 Stub Article is tagged as a stub and very short. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 16:39, 5 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Herman Slater [110] January 6, 2007 Stub Article is very short, has several redlinks, and needs references other than the collection of eulogies. - AdelaMae (t - c - wpn) 16:51, 5 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Kemetic Orthodoxy [111] January 6, 2007 Stub
Kerr Cuhulain [112] January 25, 2007 Stub
Lady Gwen Thompson [113] January 25, 2007 Stub
M. Macha Nightmare [114] January 25, 2007 Stub
McFarland Dianic [115] January 25, 2007 Stub
Morning Glory Zell-Ravenheart [116] January 25, 2007 Stub
New Reformed Orthodox Order of the Golden Dawn [117] January 25, 2007 Stub
Odinist Fellowship [118] January 25, 2007 Stub
Our Lady of the Earth and Sky [119] January 25, 2007 Stub
Pagan Pride Day [120] January 25, 2007 Stub
Patricia Crowther (Wiccan) [121] January 25, 2007 Stub
Paul Beyerl [122] January 25, 2007 Stub
Reformed Druids of North America [123] January 25, 2007 Stub
Ritual magic [124] January 25, 2007 Stub Should be recreated as a separate article. Badbilltucker 17:27, 24 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Ross Nichols [125] January 25, 2007 Stub
Rule of Three (Wiccan) [126] January 25, 2007 Stub
Ruth Barrett [127] January 25, 2007 Stub Needs to be recreated as a separate article. Badbilltucker 17:26, 24 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Setianism [128] January 12, 2007 Stub
Silver RavenWolf [129] January 25, 2007 Stub
Skyclad [130] January 25, 2007 Stub
Slavic neopaganism [131] January 25, 2007 Stub
Soft polytheism [132] January 25, 2007 Stub
Spiral dance [133] January 25, 2007 Stub
Stead's Law [134] January 25, 2007 Stub
Summoner (Wicca) [135] January 25, 2007 Stub
Supreme Council of Ethnikoi Hellenes [136] January 25, 2007 Stub
Sveinbjörn Beinteinsson [137] January 25, 2007 Stub
T. Thorn Coyle [138] January 25, 2007 Stub
Taillten Fair [139] January 25, 2007 Stub
The Druid Network [140] January 25, 2007 Stub
The Troth [141] January 25, 2007 Stub
The Witches' Voice [142] January 25, 2007 Stub
Ukkos faith [143] January 25, 2007 Stub
Victor Anderson [144] January 25, 2007 Stub
Wiccan church [145] January 25, 2007 Stub
Wiccaning [146] January 25, 2007 Stub
Witch School [147] January 25, 2007 Stub
Witchcraft Today [148] January 25, 2007 Stub
Yvonne Frost [149] January 25, 2007 Stub
Íslenska Ásatrúarfélagið [150] January 25, 2007 Stub
Simon, King of the Witches [151] March 22, 2007 Unassessed
See also: assessed article categories. Last update: March 30, 2007



Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org../../../v/e/r/Wikipedia%7EVersion_1.0_Editorial_Team_Neopaganism_articles_by_quality_cfd8.html"