Wikipedia:Version 1.0 Editorial Team/Biography articles by quality/9

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

You have new messages (last change).


← (prev) ↑(up) (next) →


[edit] Wikipedia:WikiProject Biography

Contact with WP Biography
Article
Date
Comments
Genichi Taguchi [1] March 26, 2007 B
Genichiro Tenryu [2] December 16, 2006 B
Genie (feral child) [3] August 28, 2006 B *High- person is famous in child psychology cases.
  • B-Class- article looks good, could use some more work, is more concised than a start article. (edit comment)
Geoffrey Chaucer [4] September 14, 2006 B
Geoffrey Lane, Baron Lane [5] September 5, 2006 B
Georg Brandes [6] January 22, 2007 B
Georg Christoph Lichtenberg [7] December 7, 2006 B
Georg Philipp Telemann [8] October 31, 2006 B
Georg Solti [9] October 22, 2006 B
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel [10] August 15, 2006 B
George 'Gabby' Hayes [11] February 15, 2007 B
George A. Burton [12] March 2, 2007 B
George Allen (U.S. politician) [13] October 4, 2006 B
George Anthony Walkem [14] August 11, 2006 B
George Armstrong Custer [15] November 7, 2006 B Can someone please edit the article to remove the references to Lil Romeo and Jay-Z?

I don't believe they featured in the biography of Custer or the goings-on at Little Big Horn.

They came in much later.

CaptCrumb 22:04, 1 February 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
George B. Rodney [16] December 7, 2006 B
George Balanchine [17] January 4, 2007 B
George Berkeley [18] November 22, 2006 B
George Bernard Shaw [19] July 29, 2006 B Needs references plange 01:49, 30 July 2006 (UTC)

I have increased the number of references and linked them to full texts when such are available on-line. I am concerned about the spate of articles synopsizing individual plays: Nearly all of them include brief biographies of Shaw, which makes the repetitious. Should they be amended?

Wugo 04:21, 20 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
George Best [20] September 5, 2006 B
George Bradshaw [21] March 2, 2007 B I have to admit to finding Wiki's rating system way over my head. However I will say an article about Bradshaw is totally justified. I have edited one word (so far) and that is important. The first Bradshaw was the first compilation of railway timetables. There had been railway timetables before. It's obvious there were and various books show these like Train & Transport showing an 1835 Stockton & Darlington one. I have an 1838 Grand Junction one headed Time Table in Cornish's guide. Should anyone be able to input a more exact last date (exact day) for the last 1961 Bradshaw that would be helpful. Robertforsythe 14:24, 10 February 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
George Brett (baseball player) [22] March 2, 2007 B
George Burns [23] March 4, 2007 B
George Byng, 1st Viscount Torrington [24] February 24, 2007 B
George Campbell (Presbyterian minister) [25] March 2, 2007 B
George Carey [26] March 30, 2007 B
George Clooney [27] August 24, 2006 B
George D. Sax [28] March 10, 2007 B
George Despot [29] March 26, 2007 B
George Edwardes [30] October 26, 2006 B
George Eliot [31] February 17, 2007 B This is a good beginning to the Eliot page, but I believe that it could stand with some reorganization and additions.
  • The biography section should be split into subsections so that it is not so long (this is a wikepedia convention).
  • I would argue that the section on her works should be greatly expanded; perhaps even a subsection on each major novel or perhaps a subsection on each genre in which she wrote.
  • The article has an excellent list of sources but is not itself footnoted - please do so.
  • The lead should reflect the rest of the article; right now, it is oddly focused on her name.
  • Also, she should be referred to as "Eliot" throughout the article. I don't want to get into a big feminist debate, but seeing her referred to as Mary Ann, etc. rankled. I have a feeling the Dickens article does not refer to him as "Charles."

Awadewit 09:45, 17 February 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
George Foreman [32] December 23, 2006 B
George G. Haven, Jr. [33] March 10, 2007 B
George Galloway [34] August 9, 2006 B The page is good but seems to lack a Neutral POV. It swings between pro- and anti-Galloway dependant on section.GiollaUidir 20:57, 9 August 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
George Gershwin [35] March 8, 2007 B
George Grant (philosopher) [36] February 15, 2007 B
George Gray (senator) [37] September 1, 2006 B *The framework for this article is COMPLETE and meets the current standard for this series of articles, including:
introductory paragraph, section formatting, and categories
infobox, succession boxes, nav boxes, public offices table and election results table
references, links, and places with information
  • suggestions for future improvements:
  1. additional detail about Gray's judicial career
  2. additional details about the political environment in Delaware in the late 19th century
  3. additional details about the issues and accomplishments of Gray in intermational law.
  4. additional details about the issues and accomplishments of Gray's term as senator
  • The best known sources for additional information are: (please add others known to you)
  1. unknown

stilltim 01:42, 31 August 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
George H. O'Brien, Jr. [38] September 5, 2006 B
George H. W. Bush [39] March 8, 2007 B
George Harris, 4th Baron Harris [40] March 2, 2007 B
George Harrison [41] November 26, 2006 B WPBeatles:
  • There is no official "References" section, and few, if any, in-line references, but the article is very well-rounded. It covers George's entire life: early life, life with the Beatles, and life by decades after that. It has a few pictures, mostly of him, but a few more wouldn't hurt. (Maybe some on the left side of the page?)--Gordon (2 April 2006)
  • Needs inline citations (probably shouldn't be an A without them, as it wouldn't get GA). --kingboyk 11:19, 14 August 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
George Henry Lewes [42] February 15, 2007 B
George Herbert [43] February 15, 2007 B
George II of Great Britain [44] February 16, 2007 B 0.5
George J. Maloof, Jr. [45] March 10, 2007 B
George Jellicoe, 2nd Earl Jellicoe [46] March 6, 2007 B
George Johnstone Stoney [47] November 7, 2006 B
George Jones [48] December 29, 2006 B
George Lakoff [49] March 18, 2007 B
George Lincoln Rockwell [50] March 6, 2007 B
George Lucas [51] July 12, 2006 B
George Martin [52] August 13, 2006 B Comments from WikiProject The Beatles:
  • I rated this article B-Class only because it lacked references. I gave it a top priority because George is considered one of the driving forces behind the Beatles. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by The Man13 (talk • contribs) 15:50, 4 July 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
George Mason [53] September 8, 2006 B
George McGovern [54] November 4, 2006 B
George Michael [55] August 24, 2006 B
George Moscone [56] March 4, 2007 B
George Orwell [57] January 5, 2007 B Informative, but uncited, with structute problems and a trivia section that shoud be trimmed.--Yannismarou 19:10, 4 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
George P. Burdell [58] January 30, 2007 B
George Pataki [59] March 4, 2007 B
George Patterson (cricketer) [60] March 2, 2007 B
George Pearkes [61] January 8, 2007 B
George Peppard [62] March 26, 2007 B
George Psychoundakis [63] August 27, 2006 B
George Pérez [64] January 1, 2007 B
George R. R. Martin [65] March 2, 2007 B
George R. Riddle [66] September 4, 2006 B
George Read (signer) [67] September 3, 2006 B
George Rickey [68] March 8, 2007 B
George S. Greene [69] October 2, 2006 B
George S. Williams [70] December 7, 2006 B
George Sand [71] December 12, 2006 B
George Smith (royal servant) [72] September 5, 2006 B
George Soros [73] August 11, 2006 B inline HTML links needs to be converted to ref tags and otherwise also needs inline references. plange 23:08, 11 August 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
George Stephen, 1st Baron Mount Stephen [74] March 30, 2007 B
George Stoneman [75] October 28, 2006 B
George Swindin [76] September 5, 2006 B
George Takei [77] December 31, 2006 B
George Temple-Poole [78] December 20, 2006 B This could soon be a good article with slight expansion information about his life. (edit comment)
George Thorne [79] October 26, 2006 B
George Truitt [80] September 4, 2006 B
George Vancouver [81] January 7, 2007 B
George Voinovich [82] March 6, 2007 B
George Wallace [83] March 14, 2007 B
George Washington Steele [84] March 6, 2007 B
George Westinghouse [85] February 26, 2007 B
George Whitefield [86] January 11, 2007 B
George Whitefield Chadwick [87] December 19, 2006 B
George-Étienne Cartier [88] September 4, 2006 B
Georges Cuvier [89] January 26, 2007 B
Georges Dumézil [90] March 20, 2007 B
Georges-Pierre Seurat [91] December 7, 2006 B
Georgie Henley [92] February 2, 2007 B I copied the B class rating from the Wikiproject Narnia template to the Wikiproject biography template. The article covers the subject well and from a NPOV. It has some sources but could be improved in that area. It is generally WP:MOS compliant, but the trivia section should probably be merged into the article body. There are no major ongoing edit disputes. Eluchil404 12:42, 2 February 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Georgios Papadopoulos [93] November 16, 2006 B
Georgy Zhukov [94] September 6, 2006 B
Gerald Gardner [95] December 7, 2006 B I rated this article as B-class because it is decent as it stands, but could be a lot more thorough as there is quite a bit more information available on Gardner. - AdelaMae (talk - contribs) 03:02, 7 December 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Gerald Mohr [96] November 3, 2006 B
Geraldine Ulmar [97] October 26, 2006 B
Gerhard Berger [98] March 8, 2007 B
Germaine Greer [99] September 24, 2006 B
Germaine Lindsay [100] September 5, 2006 B
Geronimo [101] March 4, 2007 B
Gerrit Smith [102] January 18, 2007 B
Gerry & the Pacemakers [103] August 13, 2006 B
Gerry Adams [104] March 6, 2007 B
Gerry Anderson [105] March 6, 2007 B
Gerry McGeer [106] January 29, 2007 B
Gerry Mulligan [107] March 22, 2007 B
Gert Wingårdh [108] January 9, 2007 B
Gertrude Bell [109] January 5, 2007 B
Gery Scott [110] September 5, 2006 B
Gessius Florus [111] August 24, 2006 B
Ghazi Kanaan [112] September 5, 2006 B
Ghostface Killah [113] December 30, 2006 B
Giacomo Agostini [114] March 6, 2007 B
Giacomo Casanova [115] March 6, 2007 B
Giacomo Leopardi [116] March 6, 2007 B
Giacomo Meyerbeer [117] March 2, 2007 B
Giacomo Puccini [118] September 28, 2006 B B-class, bordering on Start
  • poor structure
  • copyright problems with pictures. Both poster and second portrait claimed to be PD because the author died more than 70 years ago. But as the authors (the artist who designed the poster, or the photographer) are not mentioned, it is impossible to verify
  • in-line citations need to be added
  • Possible POV Errabee 12:21, 28 September 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Giada De Laurentiis [119] August 6, 2006 B
Gian Lorenzo Bernini [120] March 6, 2007 B
Gianfranco Zola [121] January 10, 2007 B
Gianni Vattimo [122] March 12, 2007 B
Gideon Mantell [123] December 21, 2006 B
Gideon Welles [124] March 12, 2007 B
Gifford Pinchot [125] March 6, 2007 B
Gigi Becali [126] March 14, 2007 B
Gil Gutknecht [127] March 16, 2007 B
Gil Kane [128] January 2, 2007 B
Gilbert du Motier, marquis de La Fayette [129] March 6, 2007 B
Gilgamesh [130] August 16, 2006 B
Gill Langley [131] March 4, 2007 B
Gille Brigte, Earl of Strathearn [132] August 4, 2006 B
Gille Brigte, Lord of Galloway [133] July 31, 2006 B
Gille Chlerig, Earl of Mar [134] August 4, 2006 B
Gille Coemgáin of Moray [135] August 4, 2006 B
Gille Críst, Earl of Mar [136] August 4, 2006 B
Gille Míchéil, Earl of Fife [137] August 4, 2006 B
Gilleasbaig of Menstrie [138] August 4, 2006 B
Gilles Deleuze [139] February 26, 2007 B
Gilles Duceppe [140] March 2, 2007 B
Gillian Anderson [141] September 3, 2006 B Good article - Needs infobox and intro expanded to summarize the article. Could be rated a Good Article soon. Morphh 17:29, 3 September 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Gillian Knight [142] September 14, 2006 B
Ginger Rogers [143] March 2, 2007 B
Giordano Bruno [144] March 6, 2007 B
Giorgio Agamben [145] March 16, 2007 B
Giorgio Vasari [146] March 2, 2007 B
Giorgione [147] March 2, 2007 B
Giovanni Pico della Mirandola [148] March 2, 2007 B
Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina [149] March 20, 2007 B
Girls Aloud [150] March 12, 2007 B
Giuseppe Garibaldi [151] September 27, 2006 B
Gleb Botkin [152] March 2, 2007 B
Glen Campbell [153] August 12, 2006 B Needs citing ....(Complain)(Let us to it pell-mell) 23:56, 12 August 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Glenda Jackson [154] March 2, 2007 B
Glenn Beck [155] February 26, 2007 B
Glenn Ford [156] March 2, 2007 B
Glenn Gould [157] August 18, 2006 B There is an error in the caption for the photo showing Glenn Gould at the piano with his piano instructor in the background. On the main page, the caption gives the year as 1945. If you click on it and enlarge the photograph, the caption gives the year as 1955.

I don't have the photo. I do not know what year it was, whether '45, '55 or some other year altogether so I cannot correct the caption. But I do know that it cannot be both and if ONE of them is correct, it is probably the former because the person at the piano looks like a kid, not a 23-year-old adult.Isolde3 03:10, 12 September 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Glenn McCarthy [158] March 4, 2007 B
Glenn Miller [159] March 22, 2007 B Talk:Glenn Miller/Comments (edit comment)
Glenn T. Seaborg [160] August 23, 2006 B I recently submitted an edit to this article. It had said that Seaborg sneaked a tiny camera past Soviet guards to photograph Kennedy and Khrushchev signing the Limited Test Ban Treaty in 1963. In fact, the Treaty was signed in Moscow, but Kennedy was not present. The U.S. delegation was headed by Averill Harriman, who signed for the U.S. I edited the article to remove the Kennedy reference. (edit comment)
Gloria Estefan [161] March 22, 2007 B
Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo [162] December 14, 2006 B
Gloria Swanson [163] March 2, 2007 B
Glynis Johns [164] March 2, 2007 B
Gnaeus Domitius Ahenobarbus (consul 32) [165] December 7, 2006 B
Gnaeus Domitius Corbulo [166] August 23, 2006 B
Gnaeus Julius Agricola [167] November 22, 2006 B
Gnassingbé Eyadéma [168] September 5, 2006 B
Go Seigen [169] December 7, 2006 B
Golda Meir [170] March 4, 2007 B
Goldfrapp [171] March 10, 2007 B
Goldie Hawn [172] March 2, 2007 B
Gomer Jones [173] February 26, 2007 B
Gondophares [174] August 27, 2006 B
Gordie Howe [175] August 12, 2006 B
Gordon Campbell [176] August 12, 2006 B
Gordon Parks [177] August 27, 2006 B
Gordon Ramsay [178] March 30, 2007 B
Gorgias [179] August 17, 2006 B
Gorgoroth (band) [180] March 30, 2007 B
Gorillaz [181] February 2, 2007 B This page seems very good ill give a 9/10 since it needs some more edidting Blood8815 04:32, 2 November 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Gottfried Helnwein [182] December 11, 2006 B
Gottfried von Cramm [183] January 22, 2007 B
Gotthard Heinrici [184] March 30, 2007 B
Gottlob Frege [185] March 16, 2007 B
Gotō Shōjirō [186] December 30, 2006 B
Gough Whitlam [187] September 16, 2006 B
Gove Saulsbury [188] September 19, 2006 B
Governorship of Mitt Romney [189] January 10, 2007 B
Grace Hopper [190] March 18, 2007 B
Grace Jones [191] March 12, 2007 B
Grace Kelly [192] January 20, 2007 B
Gracie Allen [193] March 4, 2007 B
Graham Chapman [194] February 25, 2007 B
Graham Gouldman [195] March 2, 2007 B
Graham Greene [196] October 27, 2006 B
Graham Hill [197] March 2, 2007 B
Graham Kennedy [198] September 5, 2006 B
Graham Poll [199] July 29, 2006 B
Graham Richardson [200] March 8, 2007 B
Grand Duchess Anastasia Mikhailovna of Russia [201] March 22, 2007 B
Grand Duchess Elizabeth Fyodorovna [202] December 11, 2006 B Could be expanded. Needs inline citations. Format needs to be wikified. + Ceoil 17:37, 10 December 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Grand Duchess Maria Nikolayevna, Duchess of Leuchtenberg [203] February 15, 2007 B
Grand Duchess Maria Pavlovna of Russia (1890-1958) [204] January 6, 2007 B It seems ver nice, but I cannot rate it higher than B, because it has not yet gone through a GAC review.--Yannismarou 09:06, 6 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Grand Duchess Olga Alexandrovna of Russia [205] March 4, 2007 B
Grand Duke Dmitri Pavlovich of Russia [206] March 4, 2007 B
Grant Hill (basketball) [207] November 16, 2006 B
Grant Morrison [208] January 1, 2007 B
Grant Neufeld [209] August 5, 2006 B
Grant Withers [210] August 11, 2006 B I'd try to expand lead per WP:LEAD - also, try to work Trivia into the prose above. Are there any other references available that might help flesh out this article? plange 22:59, 11 August 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Grateful Dead [211] January 17, 2007 B
Greg Paulus [212] March 6, 2007 B
Gregor MacGregor [213] March 4, 2007 B
Gregoria de Jesus [214] December 28, 2006 B
Gregory Benford [215] March 2, 2007 B
Gregory Nava [216] February 1, 2007 B
Gregory Peck [217] October 29, 2006 B Refs needed ....(Complain)(Let us to it pell-mell) 06:13, 7 August 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Greta Garbo [218] February 25, 2007 B
Grigori Perelman [219] August 22, 2006 B
Grigori Rasputin [220] March 12, 2007 B
Groucho Marx [221] October 14, 2006 B
Grover Cleveland [222] March 2, 2007 B
Grover Norquist [223] March 6, 2007 B
Guan Yu [224] October 29, 2006 B
Gudea [225] August 16, 2006 B
Guided by Voices [226] March 4, 2007 B
Guido von List [227] January 25, 2007 B
Guillermo Vilas [228] February 26, 2007 B
Gulzhana Karagusova [229] December 25, 2006 B
Gunning Bedford, Sr. [230] September 4, 2006 B
Gurbaksh Singh Dhillon [231] August 27, 2006 B
Guru Gobind Singh [232] March 30, 2007 B
Gustaf VI Adolf of Sweden [233] February 15, 2007 B
Gustav Heinrich Ralph von Koenigswald [234] March 10, 2007 B
Gustav I of Sweden [235] November 4, 2006 B
Gustav III of Sweden [236] February 15, 2007 B
Gustav IV Adolf of Sweden [237] February 15, 2007 B
Gustav Mahler [238] March 4, 2007 B
Gustave Caillebotte [239] March 18, 2007 B
Gustave Courbet [240] March 22, 2007 B
Gustavus Adolphus of Sweden [241] February 15, 2007 B
Guus Hiddink [242] October 28, 2006 B
Guy Bates [243] September 1, 2006 B
Guy Davenport [244] September 5, 2006 B I've reassessed this article and think it is still B class. However, it has several strengths and not much work should be needed to get it up to A class.

There is an excellent, comprehensive collection of references and sources but the article itself needs to be fleshed out a bit more. More headings and sub-headings are definitely needed and some of the information in list format needs to be expanded into paragraphs. This is glaringly obvious in the commentary section, where there is no summary or explanation of critics' views.

I recommend contributing editors divide the existing information into relevant sub headings and attempt to provide at least a brief summary for sections currently in list form, where appropriate. Gruffle Gaw 17:30, 17 September 2006 (UTC)

The B grade stands. The article doesn't even have an infobox or persondata. It needs serious work to come close to an A rating. It should pass GA before even being considered for an A. - Duribald 08:54, 24 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Guy Fawkes [245] November 4, 2006 B
Guy Goma [246] August 24, 2006 B It's well sourced, which is good, and has a well written account of his interview, however after that, it just drops off in quality. It would be best improved to brush up the rest with a bit more depth. (edit comment)
Gwen Araujo [247] January 27, 2007 B
Gwen Stefani [248] March 20, 2007 B
Gwyneth Paltrow [249] March 8, 2007 B
György Lukács [250] March 6, 2007 B
Göran Malmqvist [251] December 21, 2006 B
Göran Persson [252] March 16, 2007 B
Günter Grass [253] August 12, 2006 B
Günther von Kluge [254] December 16, 2006 B
H. B. Hollins [255] March 2, 2007 B
H. Bruce Franklin [256] March 2, 2007 B
H. G. Wells [257] December 19, 2006 B
H. H. Asquith [258] February 25, 2007 B
H. H. Holmes [259] March 10, 2007 B
H. L. Mencken [260] August 25, 2006 B
H. P. Lovecraft [261] March 6, 2007 B
H. Reid [262] March 6, 2007 B
H. V. Evatt [263] March 8, 2007 B
Haakon, Crown Prince of Norway [264] March 16, 2007 B
Habib Bourguiba [265] March 16, 2007 B
Hafez [266] March 4, 2007 B
Hafez al-Assad [267] March 16, 2007 B
Hafizullah Amin [268] March 16, 2007 B
Hagop Kazazian Pasha [269] January 9, 2007 B The article looks greatly improved and in only two days. I rated it B pending a second opinion.
  • This looks borderline Start and B. Have you consulted the Steps for a B article? They suggest taking care of the missing citation and red links. And requesting Did you know... on the Main page.
I will post a request. I didn't think that Hagop Pasha would have Did you know... appeal, but I guess I am mistaken. Thx! --Free smyrnan 09:05, 9 January 2007 (UTC)
Posted "Did you know" submission as well requests for articles for the red links. --Free smyrnan 13:15, 9 January 2007 (UTC)
  • A link to a verifiable English Internet source other than Wikipedia derivatives like Answers.com would be helpful for those of us who don't know the language.

Best wishes. -Susanlesch 07:46, 9 January 2007 (UTC)

I'll try to find some. --Free smyrnan 09:05, 9 January 2007 (UTC)
Did Google search, found and added one citation. --Free smyrnan 13:15, 9 January 2007 (UTC)
For me it is a start article. It needs further expansion to be regerded as B-Class, despite the fact that it is well-referenced, and looks well-structured. Anyway, I wouldn't like to change unilaterally the rating. Let it be B, and let's hope to further improvement and to a successful GAC review. A [citation needed] I saw should be fixed.--Yannismarou 08:47, 9 January 2007 (UTC)
I put in the [citation needed] since I did not wish to immediately remove the paragraph and perhaps start an edit war about the Armenian genocide. Kazazian pasha was, by all accounts I could find, a successful Ottoman Pasha who enjoyed high favors by the palace, who lived and died before 1915 and left no descendants who could be affected by 1915. I intend to let it stand for now, and if no one comes forward with more facts, I intend to remove the paragraph since it seems not factual. --Free smyrnan 09:05, 9 January 2007 (UTC)
Moved that sentence to the talk page for further deliberation, as it seems not relevant to the article. --Free smyrnan 13:15, 9 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Haile Gebrselassie [270] March 20, 2007 B One of the best distance runners and a gold medal Olympian certainly rates mid importance at least, and the article is a pretty good start. Needs some style fixes and a bunch more refs. Staxringold talkcontribs 23:36, 19 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Haile Selassie I of Ethiopia [271] March 4, 2007 B
Haim Herzog [272] March 20, 2007 B
Hakim Habibur Rahman [273] March 24, 2007 B
Hakor [274] August 17, 2006 B
Hal Ashby [275] September 1, 2006 B Needs citing ....(Complain)(Let us to it pell-mell) 04:30, 2 September 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Hal Colebatch [276] March 20, 2007 B
Hal Mumme [277] September 20, 2006 B
Hal Turner [278] March 20, 2007 B
Hale Boggs [279] March 20, 2007 B
Hale Irwin [280] March 14, 2007 B
Haley Barbour [281] March 20, 2007 B The section "2003 Campaign Controversy" is constantly under POV attack by Haley's lackys. Any attempt to discuss the fact Haley was giving a stump speech at a whites' only school is routinely removed. (edit comment)
Half Man Half Biscuit [282] March 20, 2007 B
Hall Caine [283] February 23, 2007 B The article seems well-researched with inline citations where necessary. Also, the pictures are helpful to viewers. The prose is not bad, but could use some improvement and finesse.

Some of my other suggestions would be to lengthen the lead section (see Wikipedia's info on lead sections and revise the prose to make the writing style more eloquent. Also, perhaps starting the article with a pronoun like "He" is not as suitable as just saying "Caine."

Because it has not been through GA review, I would rate this article as B-class. However, through making some improvements I would recommend you submit this for GA nomination. Overall, a good effort from the main editors and contributors of this article, and I hope you'll all continue to improve this article in the future. If you have any other questions or concerns, feel free to leave a note on my talk page. - Lulu288 22:28, 23 February 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Halle Berry [284] December 25, 2006 B
Hamdija Pozderac [285] March 4, 2007 B
Hamid Dabashi [286] March 4, 2007 B
Hamilton Fish [287] March 20, 2007 B
Han Fei [288] August 20, 2006 B
Han van Meegeren [289] January 6, 2007 B
Hana Mandlíková [290] March 22, 2007 B
Hanan Ashrawi [291] March 22, 2007 B
Hande Yener [292] March 22, 2007 B
Hani Hanjour [293] February 1, 2007 B
Hanina Ben Dosa [294] March 22, 2007 B
Hank Aaron [295] September 29, 2006 B
Hank Marvin [296] March 20, 2007 B Much more information is needed about Hank Marvin's recent history. It isn't until the last sentence that we are told Hank split from The Shadows at all, let alone for 13 years. On the whole, this article is fairly well-written but it's seriously incomplete - Goldkill. (edit comment)
Hank Stram [297] September 5, 2006 B
Hank Williams [298] December 25, 2006 B
Hank Williams, Jr. [299] March 22, 2007 B
Hannah Spearritt [300] March 22, 2007 B
Hannes Hólmsteinn Gissurarson [301] March 24, 2007 B
Hannes Trautloft [302] February 25, 2007 B
Hanoch Levin [303] March 14, 2007 B
Hans Bethe [304] September 9, 2006 B
Hans Christian Andersen [305] September 11, 2006 B
Hans Eysenck [306] August 14, 2006 B comprehensive enough to be B class. Eysenck is in the top of his field. --Rikurzhen 03:56, 15 August 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Hans Köchler [307] March 4, 2007 B properly sourced with inline citations, this could be 'a' quality --Sapphic 17:40, 4 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Hans Morgenthau [308] March 2, 2007 B
Hans von Dohnanyi [309] September 18, 2006 B
Hans von Luck [310] March 16, 2007 B
Hans-Joachim Marseille [311] October 29, 2006 B
Harald I of Denmark [312] February 15, 2007 B
Harlan Ellison [313] December 27, 2006 B
Harold Bloom [314] March 6, 2007 B
Harold Cardinal [315] September 9, 2006 B
Harold Ford, Jr. [316] January 6, 2007 B The citations are only links and lack access dates, author names, etc. The prose has a few weasel words and one-sentence-paragraphs. Hemmingsen 13:30, 6 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Harold Godwinson [317] February 15, 2007 B
Harold Harefoot [318] March 8, 2007 B
Harold Holt [319] March 4, 2007 B
Harold Lowe [320] January 28, 2007 B
Harold Macmillan [321] March 30, 2007 B
Harold Melvin & the Blue Notes [322] March 20, 2007 B
Harold Ramis [323] July 15, 2006 B
Harold Roe Bartle [324] January 3, 2007 B
Harold Shipman [325] March 30, 2007 B
Harpo Marx [326] January 15, 2007 B Solid article, there does not seem to be much missing for debate. It lacks the clear timelines and organization to get a higher grade (i.e. the Groucho Marx article) (edit comment)
Harriet Miers [327] January 12, 2007 B Hello. Article looks very nice. The prose for the most part has citations and sources. I rated the article B because it appears to meet the requirements. You might look at an FA or another article to see how a Notes or References section can be done without external links inline. Different editors have different preferences for citations (I use something like this). Best wishes. -Susanlesch 04:53, 12 January 2007 (UTC)
I agree with the rating. Avoid the external jumps.--Yannismarou 11:24, 14 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Harriet Tubman [328] July 30, 2006 B needs inline citations plange 06:41, 30 July 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Harris B. McDowell, Jr. [329] September 21, 2006 B
Harris Miller [330] September 4, 2006 B
Harrison Ford [331] December 19, 2006 B
Harry A. Richardson [332] September 2, 2006 B *The framework for this article is COMPLETE and meets the current standard for this series of articles, including:
introductory paragraph, section formatting, and categories
infobox, succession boxes, nav boxes, public offices table and election results table
references, links, and places with information
  • suggestions for future improvements:
  1. additional detail about Richardson's business activities
  2. additional details about the political environment in Delaware in the early 20th century
  3. additional details about the issues and accomplishments of Richardson's term as senator
  • The best known sources for additional information are: (please add others known to you)
  1. Carter, Richard B. (2001). Clearing New Ground, The Life of John G. Townsend, Jr.. Wilmington: The Delaware Heritage Press. 

stilltim 01:12, 3 September 2006 (UTC)) (edit comment)
Harry Aubrey Toulmin, Sr. [333] December 7, 2006 B
Harry Brinkley Bass [334] September 29, 2006 B
Harry Connick, Jr. [335] September 11, 2006 B
Harry F. Byrd [336] August 27, 2006 B
Harry G. Haskell, Jr. [337] December 7, 2006 B
Harry Gibbs [338] September 9, 2006 B
Harry H. Corbett [339] March 2, 2007 B
Harry Harding [340] October 21, 2006 B
Harry Harlow [341] December 8, 2006 B
Harry Haywood [342] February 16, 2007 B
Harry Lee [343] January 20, 2007 B
Harry Magdoff [344] August 27, 2006 B
Harry Nilsson [345] March 4, 2007 B
Harry Redknapp [346] September 15, 2006 B I've rate this page a B because it is a good story, and given the current description of the rating system I will not give out negative ratings for fair pages. It doesn't mean that the page needs to be edited.

A picture and matching infobox is needed

The most of important part is referencing the page. There are plenty of sources available including the BBC and the Guardian, so it shouldn't be that hard. Nevertheless it is clear that it has been written by people who are knowlegable about the subject and therefore I have little doubt about the overall correctness of the page. I've marked three points which definitely need citation, however there are more things which need to be checked.

Since this is a football page, it is requires somebody to put the page on watch and protect it against vandalism. From what I can see it's still clean, but it is necessary in this case to maintain the quality, and prevent vandalism staying on the page for too long. KittenKlub 13:07, 15 September 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
Harsha [347] February 25, 2007 B
Harsiese A [348] August 17, 2006 B
Haruki Murakami [349] August 25, 2006 B
Harun al-Rashid [350] August 24, 2006 B
Harvey C. Barnum, Jr. [351] October 15, 2006 B
Harvey Logan [352] March 30, 2007 B
Harvey Proctor [353] January 22, 2007 B
Hasdrubal (Barcid) [354] August 20, 2006 B There are a number of errors here. The main ones that I saw were that Hasdrubal was Hamilcar's son-in-law, not son. Also, he was older than Hannibal.

74.110.179.16 00:43, 31 January 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Hasdrubal Gisco [355] August 20, 2006 B
Hassan Dahir Aweys [356] March 26, 2007 B
Hassan Nasrallah [357] October 31, 2006 B This article uses unreliable sources in describing Nasrallah views on Israel. Many of the sources are dubious and we do not see any primary evidence provided. (edit comment)
Hasso von Manteuffel [358] October 15, 2006 B
Hattie Jacques [359] March 2, 2007 B
Hayao Miyazaki [360] December 30, 2006 B
Hayden Fry [361] August 15, 2006 B
Hayley Mills [362] March 2, 2007 B
Hayley Westenra [363] August 14, 2006 B Try and see if you can expand the lead to more than one paragraph per WP:LEAD. You've got some thing well-referenced, but try and see if you can get the rest sourced...plange 01:49, 15 August 2006 (UTC) (edit comment)
He Yingqin [364] March 18, 2007 B This a good, informative article about He, but it's too dense and needs breaking up into sections and/or editing back. As it is, eyes begin to freeze before the Japanese have invaded China. Citation and sources would help too. Edofedinburgh 04:12, 19 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
He Yong [365] March 18, 2007 B There is a real fluidity to this article, but it needs to cite its sources. For example, the Jacky Cheung remark seems to have been cited somewhere, the reader just needs to know where. Edofedinburgh 04:18, 19 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Hear'Say [366] March 18, 2007 B Comprehensive detailing of the band, but citations and references need to be added. Edofedinburgh 04:32, 19 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heath Herring [367] March 20, 2007 B Well-written article, but really needs some citation and footnotes. Photo would be useful. Edofedinburgh 18:51, 19 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heath MacQuarrie [368] March 20, 2007 B Decent description of his political career, but a reader would need to know a little about his background - how he got into politics, for instance. Edofedinburgh 18:58, 19 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heath Shuler [369] March 20, 2007 B This a good, solid article, but needs some citation on his political career - a reader would need some verified quotes. Also, it's not enough to say he's a 'moderate Democrat' - give examples of his stances on policies (with independent quotes) and leave the reader to decide for themselves. Edofedinburgh 19:54, 19 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heather Anderson [370] March 20, 2007 B Well-cited, concise article. Only criticism is there needs to be a photo of her. Edofedinburgh 22:04, 19 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heather Angel (actor) [371] March 20, 2007 B Reasonably complete description of her acting career, but a little on the sparse side. Her career in Hollywood is a good place to expand - how did she end up there, for instance? The Gone with the Wind titbit could be incorporated into the main body of the article. Her early life could be expanded too. Otherwise, a nicely-done little piece. Edofedinburgh 22:11, 19 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heather Armstrong [372] March 20, 2007 B Although the article has had a contested history, the article as it is now is reasonably clear and concise, with the information about the lawsuit being well-explained and backed up by independent links. As to the notability question, the links to the BBC's articles about her prove that she is a public figure. Just because you don't like someone's writing doesn't mean they shouldn't be included. A photo would help a lot, plus maybe a screengrab from the site. Edofedinburgh 00:32, 20 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heather Headley [373] March 20, 2007 B Well-written and reasonably comprehensive, this a decent little article. Some small things that need to be looked at: some more information on her background in T&T, and some citation and referencing. A bit of spit and polish needed here. Edofedinburgh 20:54, 20 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heather Juergensen [374] March 20, 2007 B Well-written and comprehensive article. But needs citation and reference added. Edofedinburgh 21:04, 20 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heather Locklear [375] March 20, 2007 B Decent biography, but needs citation and referencing. Expansion on her early career before Dynasty and Melrose Place is needed. Edofedinburgh 21:35, 20 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heather McCartney [376] August 16, 2006 B
Heather Mills [377] August 16, 2006 B
Heather Munroe-Blum [378] March 20, 2007 B This needs some tidying-up around the edges - there needs to be a picture of her, plus some more citation and referencing (especially about her period as Principal). Shouldn't what Bernard Shapiro did next be in his article, rather than this one? Overall pretty good, though - POV neutral, and fairly concise. Edofedinburgh 01:00, 21 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heather O'Rourke [379] March 20, 2007 B Well-written article, but there needs to be citations and references to back up the statements made. Edofedinburgh 02:21, 21 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heather Wilson [380] March 22, 2007 B The article is getting there, but needs some more citation (campaign ads and Janet Jackson controversy need work in particular). Needs a through look-over in terms of focus - is it concentrating too much on her controversies? Edofedinburgh 14:58, 21 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Heaven 17 [381] March 8, 2007 B
Heber J. Grant [382] March 22, 2007 B
Heber Jentzsch [383] March 2, 2007 B
Hector Andres Negroni [384] March 22, 2007 B
Hector Berlioz [385] March 22, 2007 B This is a terrific biography, but needs citation and references to firm up the assertions. Otherwise, great job - this could be real contender for FA if it was spruced up. Edofedinburgh 00:47, 23 March 2007 (UTC) (edit comment)
Hector Monro, Baron Monro of Langholm [386] March 22, 2007 B
Hedworth Meux [387] March 22, 2007 B
Hedy Lamarr [388] March 2, 2007 B
Heinrich Brüning [389] March 22, 2007 B
Heinrich Cornelius Agrippa [390] March 22, 2007 B
Heinrich Ehrler [391] January 11, 2007 B
Heinrich Himmler [392] December 9, 2006 B
Heinrich Müller [393] March 24, 2007 B
Heinrich Rudolf Hertz [394] October 31, 2006 B
Heinrich Schliemann [395] November 24, 2006 B
Heinz-Harald Frentzen [396] October 8, 2006 B
Helen Clark [397] March 4, 2007 B
Helen D'Oyly Carte [398] October 26, 2006 B
Helen Fisher (anthropologist) [399] March 24, 2007 B
Helen Gibson [400] March 24, 2007 B
See also: assessed article categories. Last update: March 30, 2007




← (prev) ↑(up) (next) →


Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org../../../v/e/r/Wikipedia%7EVersion_1.0_Editorial_Team_Biography_articles_by_quality_9_f9ae.html"