Wikipedia:User preferences for BCE/CE notation
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
This Wikipedia page is currently inactive and is retained primarily for historical interest. Per Wikipedia:Policies and guidelines: "A historical page is any proposal for which consensus is unclear, where discussion has died out for whatever reason." If you want to revive discussion regarding the subject, you should seek broader input via a forum such as the village pump. |
Contents |
[edit] The situation
- Dates in the Julian and Gregorian calendar are either AD or BC. The "AD" or "BC" bit isn't always used. For example, if someone asked you what this year is, you'd probably say "2005" not "AD 2005".
- The AD/BC notation is understood worldwide.
- However, some have argued that as the etymology of the AD/BC notation has Christian roots, the notation should be replaced so that it doesn't have Christian roots, preferring instead to use BCE/CE notation. In some fields and in some areas of the world, this notation has gained currency, but it has not gained currency amongst the general population worldwide.
- There have been recent problems on the English Wikipedia with those supporting the usage of BCE/CE notation encouraging its wholesale use across the English Wikipedia. This has been met with similarly strong resistance from those who do not wish to see it adopted wholesale.
- We should bear in mind both that we exist for our readers and that we need good editors. It therefore makes sense that a new "preference" functionality is developed. This preference would allow registered users who want to see BCE/CE notation to see it throughout Wikipedia. Unregistered users and registered users who have not chosen to see BCE/CE notation would see BC/AD notation.
[edit] What this page is doing
This page sets out the specifications of what would need to be programmed into the software. It assumes that, to work, all dates would need to be wikified - which here means that some of the text appears in double square brackets. Currently, not all dates are wikified. If this specification is adopted, the MoS will change to make clear that all dates should be wikified so the specification works.
The aim of this page is to help a developer develop the solution.
[edit] What this page is not doing
The solution in this page is not currently scheduled for development. We would still need to find a developer willing to take this on. However, it is hoped that by setting out what needs doing, a developer would need to spend far less time thinking through the programming and therefore may be more inclined to help.
[edit] Specification
[edit] Single years BC
This specification sets out how single years BC may be wikified and how they should appear on screen depending on whether a user preference for BCE/CE has been set or not. The example year is 100 BC.
| How year may be wikified | How it should look if BCE/CE preference is selected | How it should look if BCE/CE preference is not selected |
|---|---|---|
| [[100 BC]] | 100 BCE | 100 BC |
| [[100 BCE]] | 100 BCE | 100 BC |
| [[100 BC|100]] | 100 | 100 |
| [[100 BCE|100]] | 100 | 100 |
| [[100 BC|100 BCE]] | 100 BCE | 100 BC |
[edit] Single years AD
This specification sets out how single years AD may be wikified and how they should appear on screen depending on whether a user preference for BCE/CE has been set or not. The example year is AD 100.
| How year may be wikified | How it should look if BCE/CE preference is selected | How it should look if BCE/CE preference is not selected |
|---|---|---|
| AD [[100]] | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| A.D. [[100]] | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| ad [[100]] | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| a.d. [[100]] | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100]] AD | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100]] A.D. | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100]] ad | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100]] a.d. | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100|AD 100]] | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100]] CE | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100]] C.E. | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100]] ce | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100]] c.e. | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100 CE]] | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100|100 CE]] | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100]] [[Common Era|CE]] | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100]] [[common era|CE]] | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| 100 [[Common Era|CE]] | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| 100 [[common era|CE]] | 100 CE | AD 100 |
| [[100]] | 100 | 100 |
| [[100 CE|100]]| | 100 | 100 |
[edit] Decades BC
This specification sets out how single years BC may be wikified and how they should appear on screen depending on whether a user preference for BCE/CE has been set or not. The example decade is the 380s BC.
| How year may be wikified | How it should look if BCE/CE preference is selected | How it should look if BCE/CE preference is not selected |
|---|---|---|
| [[380s BC]] | 380s BCE | 380s BC |
| [[380s BCE]] | 380s BCE | 380s BC |
| [[380s BC|380s]] | 380s | 380s |
| [[380s BCE|380s]] | 380s | 380s |
| [[380s BC|380s BCE]] | 380s BCE | 380s BC |
[edit] Decades AD
This specification sets out how single years AD may be wikified and how they should appear on screen depending on whether a user preference for BCE/CE has been set or not. The example decade is the AD 90s.
| How year may be wikified | How it should look if BCE/CE preference is selected | How it should look if BCE/CE preference is not selected |
|---|---|---|
| AD [[90s]] | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| A.D. [[90s]] | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| ad [[90s]] | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| a.d. [[90s]] | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s]] AD | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s]] A.D. | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s]] ad | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s]] a.d. | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s|AD 90s]] | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s]] CE | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s]] C.E. | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s]] ce | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s]] c.e. | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s CE]] | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s|90s CE]] | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s]] [[Common Era|CE]] | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s]] [[common era|CE]] | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| 90s [[Common Era|CE]] | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| 90s [[common era|CE]] | 90s CE | AD 90s |
| [[90s]] | 90s | 90s |
| [[90s CE|90s]]| | 90s | 90s |
