User:TPK/Drafts/RPE
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
[edit] Talk page notice
This article has been randomly selected to be used in the random page experiment. Please go to this article's clone to fill in a quick survey on what you think of the content of this page. This will help build a picture of the average article, and hopefully help us to find Wikipedia's flaws.
[edit] Clone page notice
This article is a "clone" of an article in the main encyclopedia space. This page should not be edited, however, the original may be edited as usual without causing complications.
[edit] Clone talk page instructions
This "clone article" is part of a set of 100 randomly-selected articles that have been copied here so they can be commented on in situ, over a period of one month. It is hoped that the comments and scores accumulated here can help build a picture of Wikipedia's "average article", and that the deficiencies and strenghs thereof can be discovered.
Below are a number of topics on which you can rate this article. Please add your score (from 0 to 10) beneath the appropriate title. Please include your signature, to avoid any sockpuppetry. If you add a score for one topic, please try to add a score for every other topic. Any comments should be placed at the bottom of the page.
This page should not be used to discuss the article's content in the same manner as a normal talk page. As the article here is a "clone", and will not be changed, please direct any discussion regarding actual changes to its real talk page, unless those comments are pertinent to this experiment.
[edit] Introduction
Is the lead paragraph clear and concise? Is is obvious what the article refers to? Is the introduction compelling - would you read the article? (0 - horrible; 10 - perfect).
- Add your score below.
[edit] Spelling and grammar
Are there a lot of spelling errors? Is the grammar correct? (0 - horrible; 10 - perfect).
- Add your score below.
[edit] Content
Is the content interesting? Is it clear and well laid out? Would you read it all? (0 - horrible; 10 - perfect).
- Add your score below.
[edit] POV
Is this article fair and balanced? Is it obviously biased or is it NPOV? (0 - horrible; 10 - perfect).
- Add your score below.
[edit] Formatting
Does the article adhere to Wikipedia's standards? Is the formatting clear? Is it eye-catching? Are elements such as section headings and tables used properly? (0 - horrible; 10 - perfect).
- Add your score below.
[edit] Length
Is the article long enough for the topic? Is it a stub in need of expansion, or is it rambling? (0 - too short or too long; 10 - perfect).
- Add your score below.
[edit] Interconnectedness
Does this article contain a good number of wikilinks? Are the external links appropriate? Are there too many links? (0 - too few or too many; 10 - perfect).
- Add your score below.
[edit] Would you change this page?
How urgently would you change this page? (0 - no change neccessary; 10 - immediately).
- Add your score below.
[edit] Would you delete this page?
Would you delete this page or list it on VFD? (Yes or no).
- Add your answer below.
