Talk:The Traitor and the Jew

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I removed the links and quotes re the advocacy group, Vigile net which also included someone's personal "translation" from French to English of criticisms.

I also removed a "fact" notice that somebody inserted in a section that is a quote from the book.

Is an Wikipedia editor's own "translation" of a French language article acceptable aas a reliable source? J Martin81 23:19, 13 November 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Article by Gary Caldwell not Original Research

The criticism made by Gary Caldwell in the article "The Sins of the Abbé Groulx", published in Literary Review of Canada, volume 3, issue 7, July-August 1994, pages 17 to 23 is NOT original research. The removal of this material by J Martin81 is not justified as it is properly referenced. If the expression "asserted in essence" poses a problem, it can be changed for something else. I will revert to my last version unless serious objections are raised. -- Mathieugp 23:12, 14 November 2006 (UTC)