Roger Owensby Jr Criminal Trial

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Roger Owensby, Jr was an unarmed twenty nine year old Black man who died during a scuffle with Cincinnati Police on November 7, 2000. His death was the twelfth consecutive Black male who died in custody or confrontations with police since 1995 during which time no Whites died during confrontations.^{[citation needed]} The indictment took place in January of 2001. After the unrelated death of Timothy Thomas by Cincinnati Police, in April of 2001, the 2001 Cincinnati Riots erupted. The individual civil (local) cases against the police officers, Jorg and Caton began concurrently October 22, 2001 and both were over November 2001 with Caton being acquitted and Jorg's case ending in a mistrial. On November 6, 2001 the Owenbsby family filed a federal lawsuit stating the police had violated Roger's civil rights claiming he was "assaulted, tortured and killed" by police.

March 17, 2006, the City and Owensby family appear to have reached a landmark $6.5 million settlement (which tops the $4.5 million paid out to sixteen total plaintiffs filed at about the same time) after a federal judge awarded a summary judgment, finding police had violated Owensby's civil rights by failing to provide medical care. The proposed settlement should end the Federal case, but there was a later confrontation which threatened to stop the settlement (see Other Notes below) regarding an apology.

As of March 17, 2006, the US Department of Justice is still investigating whether any of the officers should face criminal charges under federal civil rights laws, although the local justice system found none of the officers guilty of misconduct or negligence.

1 Civil trial
2 Other notes
3 External links

[edit] Civil trial

[edit] Indictments

The charges of manslaughter and misdemeanor assault were filed against the officers Jorg and Caton January 3, 2001 for Owensby's death. One of the main contentious points was which officer, between Jorg or Caton, may have caused his death through improper use of force. Jorg and Caton had individual trials often sharing the same evidence and witnesses, but neither officer was found to have caused his death even though, obviously, Owensby had died through improper police procedures.

[edit] Known facts of case

Undisputed actions by the officers at the scene & video records:

Ofc Hunter incorrectly identified Owensby as "L.A.", a suspected drug dealer who assaulted him while he was undercover recently to which the several police officers in the area responded by planning to question Owensby
There are video records and many civilian witnesses were present during the incident who were present during the initial scuffle and result but only one citizen was used for prosecutor testimony
Owensby was not armed and had no drugs in his possession but trace amounts of marijuana in his system
Owensby was initially cooperative until the police began to handcuff him
Owensby was initially tackled by Jorg around his head and Caton grabbed him around his lower body
A chemical irritant was used on Owensby within 6" of his face while he was held by multiple police when police procedures are for use at 5' and is against policy to use it on a restrained inidividual
After Owensby's initial struggling stopped, Jorg emerged with blood and edema fluid on the arm that was wrapped around Owensby
After Owensby was placed in the cruiser Caton was in the backseat striking him repeatedly while Owensby was handcuffed
Despite the amount of blood on Jorg's sleeve and another officer who saw the way Owensby was awkwardly placed in the backseat, no medical attention was given to him for some considerable time

[edit] Points of debate

Areas of contention that still seem unanswered:

Whether Owensby was conscious and reactive after Jorg and Caton had restrained him

Ofc Caton and Jorg state that Owensby was still actively resisting even after restraint
Ofc Hunter and several civilian witnesses state that the officers had to drag Owensby's unresponsive body to the car

Whether or not drugs were found in his possession at the scene

Jorg, who searched him on video, did not report finding any drugs on Owensby during the search but was thorough enough to find cigars, papers, and other items
12 days after the arrest it was reported that drugs were found in his possession, the date of the photographs of the items were 11/08/01, the day after the incident

The official reports by the police were shown to be time stamped at around 5pm that day. The incident did not occur until after 7pm.

[edit] Known questionable actions by police

Questionable actions by the police:

Jorg's bloody and stained sleeve was cut from his arm and placed in the trunk of the cruiser
The initial reasons Owensby was stopped, as reported to his family, were that he was a drug dealer found with drugs on his person, then changed to he was wanted for assaulting a police officer and finally that he was acting suspiciously. The Owensbys still state that they have not been told why he was initially stopped in an official manner
It was reported by journalists who were where the body was being held that unidentified police officers later showed up with cocaine evidence reportedly found on Owensby at the time of the confrontation. This was contrary to Jorg's initial statements and the store's video which shows otherwise. The police who brought the evidence did not leave it there and were never investigated
Caton and Jorg claimed Owensby's wellbeing was the responsibility of Hunter because it was Hunter's case. The other officers assumed it was Jorg's and Caton's responsibility because they were involved in the struggle.

[edit] Verdict and mistrial

Caton was found not guilty and Jorg's case ended in a mistrial with the jury deadlocked 10-2 for acquittal. The investigation and trial had some questionable details:

[edit] Dubious trial procedures

The concurrent trials hindered any findings from the resulting decision from one to influence the decision of the other. One of the biggest disputes was which officer was responsible for the action that caused Owensby's death, but both blamed the other and the trials reflected such.
Owensby's family and legal representation were unable to track the proceedings in a practical manner causing more stress and confusion as the trials went on
After the trial, Jorg abruptly quit the police force on the day the internal investigation was going to question on making questioning impossible and joined the Pierce Township police department
Police Officer Victor Spellen, a key witness in both Jorg's and Caton's individual trials, told the grand jury presiding over Caton's trial that Jorg used a tight head wrap on Owensby, but testified while a witness at Jorg's trial that it was loose. The testimony from the individual trials were not shared. He was later fired from the CPD for his false testimony but no charges were made against him for perjury.
Certain civilian witnesses allowed to testify in one trial in defense of the officer on trial were discredited and not allowed to testify in the other. There were dozens of civilian and police witnesses to the incident but Mike Allen, the Hamilton Co. prosecutor, dismissed most of them except the shakey testimony of one individual who:

In the Jorg case testified that Jorg put a choke hold on Owensby
In the Caton case testified that she never saw Caton before although that is a wideley known fact
She testified she had smoked marjiana before the incident which tainted her credibility and also testified she previously bought marjiana from Owensby

Many other witnesses were interviewed by the CIS (Cincinnati Internal Investigations) but were not used as prosecutor witness. Some witnesses reported being harassed by the police by being sought for interviews multiple times with unannounced visits.

The charges that Owensby was being arrested for had changed from the initial report to his parents until the final report by the police altering from drug possession allegations, previous warrants for assault on officers (which did not exist), being uncooperative at the scene previous to the struggle and even mistaken identity.
The Hamilton County prosecutor, Mike Allen, chooses not to re-try despite the introduction of Spellen's conflicting testimony and eyewitness testimonies that lead to the deadlocked jury

[edit] Combined complaint alleging racial profiling

A group combined individual civil claims against Cincinnati, the police force, and individual police as private citizens, into the Federal lawsuit brought by Tyehimba, filed March 14, 2001, on behalf of the Black men and their surving family that had died since 1995. They alleged racial profiling but made sure to emphasize a demand for behavioral change by the CPD beyond or instead of punative and restitutive damages.

[edit] Death of Timothy Thomas leads to riots

While the criminal trial was going on an unarmed 19-year old Black man, Timothy Thomas, was shot by CPD Ofc. Steven Roach during an on-foot pursuit. The combination of the rising tensions from the high-profile Owensby case and Thomas' death lead to the 2001 Cincinnati Riots.

[edit] Status of main officers involved

Caton later won his arbitration case against the decision to have him fired for "failure of good behavior" and was eligible to work for the police force again. Jorg quit the Cincinnati police force and started working for another nearby police force in Pierce Township until mid-2003. He later moved from Cincinnati and his current status is unknown but it was reported by his father that he was unemployed for 2½ years.

[edit] Other notes

At the end of one of the sessions during the arbitration to have Caton reinstated, an angry Roger Owensby asked Caton if he (Caton) knew who he (Roger) was to which Caton responded "I don't give a (expletive) who you are." Caton's attorney, however, claims that Caton was not disrespectful to anyone. Roger became enraged and was being restrained by family members to prohibit him from approaching Caton and continuing the confrontation. Although many of the people there with the Owensby family were shouting names and approaching Caton and his group, only Roger's other son, Shawn Owensby, was arrested for disorderly conduct.

Roger Owensby, the father, confronted City Council and during his confrontation made these claims:^{[citation needed]}

He said police planted drugs on his son after his death. He also said video of the encounter, kept on a convenience store computer's hard drive, was destroyed.
Owners of the store who saw the encounter were never called as witnesses during the criminal trial of officers Robert Blaine Jorg and Patrick Caton.
Former Mayor Charlie Luken sent Owensby Sr. a get-well-soon card after he suffered an anxiety attack and was hospitalized for a day. At the bottom of the card was a hand-written question: "Can we settle for $250,000?"
"I was supposed to receive a public and written apology for the death of my son, which I have not received yet," Owensby Sr. said.
The media has failed to report that his son was an eight-year Army veteran, and served with Owensby Sr. in Bosnia. Owensby Jr. also served in the first Gulf War.

The original claims by the police that Roger Owensby Jr was found to have drugs in his possession were later recanted by the police.^{[citation needed]}

Jorg, after leaving the Pierce Township police department, contacted the Owensbys seeking their cooperation to make money over the incident through book deals.^{[citation needed]}