Wikipedia talk:Requests for adminship/Froth

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

User:Froth

      run at Fri Mar 9 16:54:50 2007 GMT

Category:       1
Help:   1
Image talk:     10
Image:  40
Mainspace       604
Portal: 15
Talk:   153
Template talk:  20
Template:       47
User talk:      382
User:   666
Wikipedia talk: 530
Wikipedia:      2463
avg edits per article   4.55
earliest        17:55, 11 July 2005
number of unique pages  1084
total   4932
2005/7  55      
2005/8  0       
2005/9  0       
2005/10         0       
2005/11         0       
2005/12         0       
2006/1  8       
2006/2  5       
2006/3  6       
2006/4  77      
2006/5  33      
2006/6  111     
2006/7  31      
2006/8  101     
2006/9  340     
2006/10         395     
2006/11         221     
2006/12         734     
2007/1  1564    
2007/2  1158    
2007/3  93


Mainspace
57      Counter-Strike: Source
53      Nintendo NSider Forums
27      MapleStory
14      Half-Life 2 controversies and criticisms
11      Age of the Earth
8       Progress Quest
7       Counter-Strike culture
7       SteamID
6       Halo: Combat Evolved
6       List of Microsoft Windows components
6       Mickey Mouse
4       Source engine
4       Cedarville University
4       Sum 41
4       RateMyTeachers
Talk:
17      MapleStory
15      Age of the Earth
9       Nintendo NSider Forums
9       Nintendo NSider Forums/Archive 1
6       Absolute terror field
5       Counter-Strike: Source
5       Bullshido
3       Ken Blackwell
3       SkiFree
2       Wish-Bone salad dressing
2       Flaming (Internet)
2       Rejected
2       FlashGet
2       FLCLimax
2       Mew glitch
Image:
4       Counter Strike Source2.png
4       Egeskov Slot spejling FOCUS.png
4       Flcl-flclimax.png
3       ISS.jpg
2       US Penny 2.PNG
2       Aerospike Engine Focus 2.PNG
2       Torre Agbar - Barcelona, Spain - Jan 2007 (edit 1).jpg
2       Aerospike Engine Focus.PNG
2       Vista Disk Mgmt.png
2       Ajaxf.JPG
Image talk:
2       Zipper animated.gif
Portal:
6       Computer science/Did you know
3       Computer science/Selected article/archive/1
2       Computer science/Selected article/archive
2       Computer science/Selected article
Template:
6       Counter-Strike series
6       Half-Life topics
6       Valve Technology
4       Day of Defeat series
3       Team Fortress series
3       POTD caption/2007-01-20
2       FPCdel
Template talk:
9       Half-Life topics
3       RD header
2       Please leave this line alone
User:
115     Froth
100     Froth/notes/Wikipedia:Reference desk/header
86      AmiDaniel/VP/Approval
62      AmiDaniel/VP/L
45      Froth/notes/Wikipedia:Reference desk/header/leftside
36      Froth/monobook.js
24      Froth/notes
21      Froth/notes/Wikipedia:Reference desk/header/toc
17      Froth/notes/Wikipedia:Reference desk/header/nav
12      Froth/notes/Wikipedia:Reference desk/header/howtoask
11      Froth/notes/mockup
11      Froth/test1
7       Froth/notes/Wikipedia:Reference desk/Miscellaneous
7       Froth/notes/Wikipedia:Reference desk/header/otherrd
6       Froth/notes/Wikipedia:Reference desk/Computing
User talk:
35      Froth
29      Prodego
15      Freshgavin/Sandbox/Reference desk
11      Betacommand
11      AmiDaniel/VP/L
7       Schgooda
6       Friday
6       Hipocrite
5       Tellyaddict
5       MacGyverMagic
5       Fir0002
4       218.214.70.16
4       Freshgavin
4       Ardo191
4       Mapletip
Wikipedia:
742     Reference desk/Computing
696     Reference desk/Miscellaneous
63      Reference desk/Science
50      Reference desk/RD header
35      Reference desk/Mathematics
34      Help desk
33      Reference desk/How to ask and answer
33      Reference desk/header
28      Featured picture candidates/Bezier curves
23      Reference desk/header/nav
20      Reference desk/Entertainment
18      Featured picture candidates
16      Reference desk/header/leftside
15      Requests for comment/User names
14      Reference desk/header/otherrd
Wikipedia talk:
443     Reference desk
27      Requests for comment/StuRat 2
12      Reference desk/guideline
10      Reference desk/guidelines
10      Reference desk/style change
7       Reference desk/RD header
3       Reference desk/colors
2       Reference desk/RD header/Archive
2       Reference desk archive/Computing/Early
2       Reference desk/purpose
2       Requests for comment/StuRat
2       Reference desk/rules

Edit count from Interiot's wannabe Kate's tool. Angus McLellan (Talk) 16:57, 9 March 2007 (UTC)

[edit] It will be interesting...

... to see how the crats determine consensus on this one. I personally find the oppose votes rather unimpressive. – riana_dzasta 01:19, 12 March 2007 (UTC)

I, personally, agree that the "oppose per Q1" argument is weak. However, its not uncommon for opposes to be made on the basis of a "need for tools" or "poor answer to questions" argument. When such a significant proportion of the !voting community are in agreement, its hard to see how a 'crat could discount them. We'll see, however. Rockpocket 01:54, 12 March 2007 (UTC)

I agree too, but regardless of how many people have used it, there is a difference between an argument that isn't accepted by everyone and an argument that's just frivolous. And I don't think it's really frivolous, wrong or not. -Amarkov moo! 02:59, 12 March 2007 (UTC)+

I think the point is that adminship is a privilege and admins should be expected to earn that privilege by helping out with some of the dirty, tedious chores around here, not just using the tools for their own personal area of interest. It's perfectly fair for the community to ask at an RfA what do we get in return for giving this candidate the tools. We need more admins to clear backlogs etc. Ironically, it seems those RfA candidates who have actually got stuck into the dirty work are more likely to fail to be elected because they've made enemies dealing with borderline trolls and vandals. --Folantin 09:31, 12 March 2007 (UTC)