User talk:Radiotrib
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Contents |
[edit] If I can ask a favour
(Radiotrib 11:27, 6 March 2007 (UTC))
I am in Europe, so I may not respond within certain time periods, but I will respond as soon as I log in again. I intend to post my responses to other posts, on this page. Wherever appropriate I will try to thread them by editing them into the existing post. Doing this saves me from trying to maintain a conversation across two or more talk pages, and it keeps a continuity in the topics, making them simpler for others to read.
Please sign your posts using four tildes (like this ~~~~). Unsigned posts are unlikely to receive replies, and might even be deleted.
[edit] For the sake of preserving the text
Radiotrib 13:19, 6 March 2007 (UTC) (Kevin Salt - Technical Webmaster - European Space Agency - Research Science Division)
This is a transcript of the message I have left for US Water Rockets and WRA2 via their WRA2 talk page.
Inappropriate Censorship
Please do not delete any more edits or remove links from the Water Rockets page without opening a discussion on the talk page. If you have an objection to the alterations, that is where they should be discussed and resolved. If the edits can be shown to be incorrect, then they will be removed by the contributor. You, either in the guise of WRA2 or USWR do not need to police the page, not do you have the right to censor other people's contributions.
Please read the Wikipedia:Resolving_disputes regarding how to conduct a dispute, for guidance about what I have just asked, and why. Having re-read this request, I feel I should also refer you to pages Wikipedia:Neutral_point_of_view and Wikipedia:NPOV_tutorial
[edit] Response from the WRA2
To the IWRA Members:
Please do not delete the information on, or edit the the information about the WRA2 or its teams without opening a discussion on the talk page. If you have an objection to the information contained therein (other than your objection to the reality that a governing body for water rocketry has existed for several years before your upstart organization formed), that is where they should be discussed and resolved. If the information can be shown to be incorrect, then it will be removed by the contributor. You do not need to insert disclaimers and "conspiracy theories" to this page in your continuing quest to promote your competing organization, nor do you have the right to censor other people's contributions.
Given that you have been asked numerous times in the past to leave the WRA2 to conduct it's business in peace, and you have never done so before, the above will probably fall on deaf ears and your smear campaign will contine as usual.
The links you accuse us of removing were removed by the editors. They have a policy that links to forums and commercial sites are not allowed. They removed the link to all the other forums, including ours.
Plagiarism
The above is a slightly modified version of the message I left for WRA2/USWR regarding their efforts to stifle independant contributions to the Water_rockets page which conflict with their own opinions. Ref: Talk:Radiotrib. It would be appropriate to remove it in deference to the original author.
Radiotrib 08:56, 9 March 2007 (UTC) - (Kevin Salt - Technical Webmaster - European Space Agency - Research Science Division)
[edit] Water rocket dispute
To all participants in the current controversy on the water rocket article: please discuss this issue on Talk:Water rocket before proceeding any further. -- The Anome 09:21, 7 March 2007 (UTC)
