Pravda
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Pravda (Russian: Правда, "The Truth") was a leading newspaper of the Soviet Union and an official organ of the Central Committee of the Communist Party between 1918 and 1991. This paper was closed down in 1991 by decree of President Yeltsin, but a paper with the same name is still in operation in Russia and the web based Pravda.ru, founded by former Pravda employees is now a tabloid-style Russian news source. The earlier Pravda is most famous in Western countries for its pronouncements during the period of the Cold War. A number of other, less famous, newspapers both also were and are presently called Pravda.
Contents |
[edit] Origins
[edit] The Vienna Pravda
The original Pravda was founded by Leon Trotsky as a Russian social democratic newspaper aimed at Russian workers. The paper was published abroad to avoid censorship and was smuggled into Russia. The first issue was published in Vienna, Austria on October 3, 1908. The editorial staff consisted of Trotsky and, at various times, Victor Kopp, Adolf Joffe and Matvey Skobelev. The last two had wealthy parents and supported the paper financially.
Since the Russian Social Democratic Labor Party was then split into multiple factions and since Trotsky was a self-described 'non-factional social democrat', the newspaper spent much of its time trying to unite party factions. The editors tried to avoid the factional issues that divided Russian emigres and concentrated on the issues of interest to Russian workers. Coupled with a lively and easy to understand style, it made the paper very popular in Russia.
In January 1910, the party's Central Committee had a rare plenary meeting with all party factions represented. A comprehensive agreement to re-unite the party was worked out and tentatively agreed upon. As part of the agreement, Trotsky's Pravda was made a party-financed central organ. Lev Kamenev, a leading member of the Bolshevik faction and Lenin's close associate, was made a member of the editorial board, but he withdrew in August 1910 once the reconciliation attempt failed. The newspaper published its last issue on April 22, 1912.
[edit] The St. Petersburg Pravda
[edit] Before the 1917 Revolution
After the breakdown of the January 1910 compromise, the Bolshevik faction of the RSDLP started publishing a Saint Petersburg-based legal weekly, Zvezda, in December 1910. When the Bolsheviks formally broke away from the other factions at their conference in Prague in January 1912, they also decided to convert Zvezda, which was by then published three times a week, into a daily.
The Bolsheviks finally realized their plan when the first issue of Pravda was published in Saint Petersburg on April 22, 1912. It continued publishing legally, although subject to government censorship, until it was shut down in July 1914 by the government at the beginning of World War I.
Due to police harassment, the newspaper had to change its name 8 times in just 2 years[1]
- Рабочая правда (Rabochaya Pravda, Worker’s Truth)
- Северная правда (Severnaya Pravda Northern Truth)
- Правда Труда (Pravda Truda, Labor’s Truth)
- За правду (Za Pravdu, For Truth)
- Пролетарская правда (Proletarskaya Pravda, Proletarian Truth)
- Путь правды (Put' Pravdy, The Way of Truth)
- Рабочий (Rabochy, The Worker)
- Трудовая правда (Trudovaya Pravda, Labor’s Truth)
In what appeared to be a minor development at the time, in April 1913 Trotsky was so upset by what he saw as a usurpation of 'his' newspaper's name that he wrote a letter [1] to Nikolay Chkheidze bitterly denouncing Vladimir Lenin and the Bolsheviks. Trotsky was able to suppress the contents of the letter in 1921 to avoid embarrassment, but once he started losing power in the early 1920s, the letter was made public by his opponents within the Communist Party in 1924 and used to paint him as Lenin's enemy.
After a period of relative social calm in 1908-1911, 1912-1914 was a time of rising social and political tensions in Russia following the Lena execution in April 1912. In contrast to Trotsky's Pravda, which had been published for the workers by a small group of intellectuals, the Bolshevik Pravda was published in Russia and was able to publish hundreds of letters by the workers. A combination of rising social tensions and workers' participation made it quite popular and its circulation fluctuated between 20,000 and 60,000, a respectable number for its time, especially considering its audience and government harassment. Another difference between the two Pravdas was the fact that Trotsky's version was financially supported by wealthy contributors while the Bolsheviks were experiencing financial difficulties at the time and had to rely on workers' contributions.
Although Lenin and the Bolsheviks edited many newspapers within and outside of Russia prior to their seizure of power in 1917, it was this 1912-1914 incarnation of Pravda, along with Iskra which ran from 1900 to 1903, that was later regarded by the Communists as the true forerunner of their official, post-1917, Pravda. The significance of Trotsky's Pravda was downplayed and, after Trotsky's expulsion from the Communist Party, the original Pravda was all but ignored by Soviet historians until perestroika.
Although Lenin was the leader of the Bolsheviks in 1912-1914, he lived in Europe (in Kraków between mid-1912 and mid-1914) in exile and couldn't exercise direct control over Pravda. Vyacheslav Molotov was the de facto editor who controlled the paper in 1912-1914 while other prominent Bolsheviks, including, briefly, Joseph Stalin (until his arrest and exile in March 1913) served on the board as circumstances permitted. As it later turned out, one of the editors, Miron Chernomazov, was an undercover police agent.
In order to avoid disruption in case of arrest, the real Bolshevik editors were not officially responsible for the paper. Instead, Pravda employed about 40 nominal "editors", usually workers, who would be arrested and go to jail whenever the police closed the paper[2].
During this period, the editorial board of Pravda often tried to avoid government fines or outright ban by moderating its content. This stance led to repeated clashes between Lenin and the editors, the latter sometimes altering Lenin's articles or even refusing to publish Lenin's works. These clashes were used by Nikita Khruschev in late 1961 when he was trying to discredit Molotov.
In December 1912 - October 1913 Pravda was also a battleground in Lenin's struggle with the Bolshevik Duma deputies, who were trying to mend fences with the Menshevik deputies while Lenin insisted on a complete break with the Mensheviks. In January 1914, Kamenev was sent to Saint Petersburg to direct Pravda and the Bolshevik faction in the Duma.
[edit] During the 1917 Revolution
The overthrow of Czar Nicholas II by the February Revolution of 1917 allowed Pravda to reopen. The original editors of the newly reincarnated Pravda, Molotov and Alexander Shlyapnikov, were opposed to the liberal Russian Provisional Government. However, when Kamenev, Stalin and former Duma deputy Matvei Muranov returned from Siberian exile on March 12, they ousted Molotov and Shlyapnikov and took over the editorial board.
Under Kamenev's and Stalin's influence, Pravda took a conciliatory tone towards the Provisional Government -- "insofar as it struggles against reaction or counter-revolution" -- and called for a unification conference with the internationalist wing of the Mensheviks. On March 14, Kamenev wrote in his first editorial:
- What purpose would it serve to speed things up, when things were already taking place at such a rapid pace?[3]
and on March 15 he supported the war effort:
- When army faces army, it would be the most insane policy to suggest to one of those armies to lay down its arms and go home. This would not be a policy of peace, but a policy of slavery, which would be rejected with disgust by a free people.[4]
After Lenin's and Grigory Zinoviev's return to Russia on April 3, Lenin strongly condemned the Provisional Government and unification tendencies in his April Theses. Kamenev argued against Lenin's position in Pravda editorials, but Lenin prevailed at the April Party conference, at which point Pravda also condemned the Provisional Government as "counter-revolutionary". From then on, Pravda essentially followed Lenin's editorial stance. After the October Revolution of 1917 Pravda was selling nearly 100,000 copies daily.
[edit] The Soviet period
The offices of the newspaper were transferred to Moscow on March 3, 1918 when the Soviet capital was moved there. Pravda became an official publication, or "organ", of the Soviet Communist Party. Pravda became the conduit for announcing official policy and policy changes and would remain so until 1991. Subscription to Pravda was mandatory for state run companies, the armed services and other organizations until 1989[5].
Other newspapers existed as organs of other state bodies. For example, Izvestia — which covered foreign relations — was the organ of the Supreme Soviet, Trud was the organ of the trade union movement, Komsomolskaya Pravda was the organ of the Komsomol organization, and Pionerskaya Pravda was the organ of Young Pioneers.
In the period after the death of Lenin in 1924, Pravda was to form a power base for Nikolai Bukharin, one of the rival party leaders, who edited the newspaper, which helped him reinforce his reputation as a Marxist theoretician.
Similarly, after the death of Stalin in 1953 and the ensuing power vacuum, Communist Party leader Nikita Khrushchev used his alliance with Dmitry Shepilov, Pravda's editor-in-chief, to gain the upper hand in his struggle with Prime Minister Georgy Malenkov.
[edit] The post-Soviet period
On August 22, 1991, a decree by Russian President Boris Yeltsin shut down the Communist Party and seized all of its property, including Pravda. Its team of journalists did not struggle for their newspaper or for its history. Instead, they registered a new paper with the same title just weeks after that.
A few months later, the then-editor Gennady Seleznyov (now a member of the Duma) sold Pravda to a family of Greek entrepreneurs, the Yannikoses. The next editor-in-chief, Alexander Ilyin, handed Pravda's trademark — the Order of Lenin medals — and the new registration certificate over to the new owners.
By that time, a serious split occurred in the editorial office. Over 90% of the journalists who had been working for Pravda until 1991 quit their jobs. They established their own version of the newspaper, which was later shut under government pressure. These same journalists led by former Pravda editors Vadim Gorshenin and Viktor Linnik in January 1999, launched Pravda Online, the first web-based newspaper in the Russian language; English, Italian and Portuguese versions are also available.
The new Pravda newspaper and Pravda Online are not related in any way, although the journalists of both publications are still in touch with each other. The paper Pravda tends to analyze events from a leftist point of view, while the web-based newspaper often takes a nationalist approach.
Meanwhile, in 2004, a new urban guide Pravda has been launched in Lithuania. It has no resemblance to the original communist Pravda whatsoever, although in its ironic mission it purports "to report the truth and nothing but the truth".
Pravda today is often used in a negative sense, to criticize media outlets that are one-sided and biased, in particular towards a leftist point-of-view.[citation needed]
[edit] Pravda in arts
- American science fiction author Robert A. Heinlein, wrote a nonfiction article about his experiences as a tourist in Russia during the Soviet period, titled "Pravda" means "Truth".
- The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress, a tale of Lunar revolution also by Heinlein, contains a paper (published in the city of Novy Leningrad) named Lunaya Pravda.
- In the film Alphaville, the secret agent Lemmy Caution claims at one point to be working for Figaro-Pravda, obviously an amalgamation of Pravda with right-wing newspaper Le Figaro.
- Pravda is often present in artistic works of Socialist Realism.
- In the novel Animal Farm Pravda is paralleled by a pig named Squealer.
[edit] References
- Cookson, Matthew (April 30, 2004). The spark that lit a revolution. Socialist Worker, p. 7.
[edit] Notes
- ^ See Tony Cliff's Lenin (1975), Chapter 19
- ^ See W. Bassow, The Pre-revolutionary Pravda and Tsarist Censorship in The American Slavic and East European Review, February 1954, partially quoted in Chapter 19 of Tony Cliff's Lenin (1975)
- ^ See Marcel Liebman, Leninism under Lenin, London, J. Cape, 1975, ISBN 0-224-01072-7 p.123
- ^ See E. H. Carr, The Bolshevik Revolution, London, Macmillan, 1950, vol. 1, p. 75.
- ^ See Mark Hooker. The Military Uses of Literature: Fiction and the Armed Forces in the Soviet Union, Westport, CT, Praeger Publishers, 1996, ISBN 0-275-95563-X p.34
[edit] See also
[edit] External links
- Pravda Newspaper
- Pravda Online (English), also links to (Russian), (Italian), (Portuguese)
- CNN Cold War Knowledge Bank - comparison of articles on Cold War topics in TIME Magazine and Pravda between 1945 and 1991
