Wikipedia:Policy dispute

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This Wikipedia page is currently inactive and is retained primarily for historical interest. Per Wikipedia:Policies and guidelines: "A historical page is any proposal for which consensus is unclear, where discussion has died out for whatever reason. Historical pages also include any process no longer in use, or any non-recent log of any process. Historical pages can be revived by advertising them. " If you want to revive discussion regarding the subject, you should seek broader input via a forum such as the village pump.

A policy dispute occurs when an agreement cannot be reached regarding a policy or guideline.

An accepted or operational policy or guideline can not be declared "in dispute" unilaterally, compare: Wikipedia:Don't disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point:

• If you wish to change an existing procedure or guideline...
  • do set up a discussion page and try to establish consensus
  • don't push the existing rule to its limits in an attempt to prove it wrong, or nominate the existing rule for deletion

Which means declaring a policy or guideline to be in dispute can only be effectuated

1. if it can be demonstrated that there has been a reasonable effort to establish consensus;
2. if it can be established that there is a consensus that the best option forward is to declare the policy in dispute. This means broad consensus, for policy even very broad consensus.

All other attempts to declare a policy or guideline in dispute after it became accepted or operational will be considered vandalism or "highly disruptive egregious disruption".