Talk:Phish: Live in Brooklyn (DVD)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This article is part of Wikipedia:WikiProject Jam bands, which aims to expand Wikipedia's coverage of bands, albums, festivals, ect., that relate directly or indirectly with the jam band culture. If you would like to participate, you can choose to edit the article attached to this page (see Wikipedia:Contributing FAQ for more information).

[edit] Vote

Don't do it. I was dissappointed when I was redirected to the Album when I had set my sights on reading about the DVD. TommyBoy76 23:04, 11 September 2006 (UTC)

Weak Oppose. I think it makes sense to have different articles for different media, but some of the information at what is currently the CD article (Phish: Live in Brooklyn) should be moved to the DVD article (Phish: Live in Brooklyn (DVD)). For example, the section on "Bonus material" applies to the DVDs, not the CD set (side note: included bonus footage from 6/18/06 is not mentioned). Also, the (separate) "Bonus disc" is no longer available, but as far as I know, it was only available with pre-orders of the DVD from Phish Dry Goods (the only source I have to confirm this is a promotional e-mail I received). For these reasons, I'd suggest moving only those two sections from the CD article to the DVD article, and renaming (moving) Phish: Live in Brooklyn to Phish: Live in Brooklyn (CD) (also possibly giving the non-parenthetic title to the DVD article). If either article is given a parenthetic title, it should be the soundtrack, not the movie, as the DVD includes material not found on the CD, yet the CD's entire content is included on the DVD. Whatever happens, unless Phish: Live in Brooklyn becomes the umbrella article discussing both, Template:Phish requires an edit, as both the CD and DVD links point there; this is probably what misled TommyBoy76. Tobogganoggin 05:10, 2 October 2006 (UTC)