User:NuclearUmpf/NBGPWS

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Contents 1 Statement of the dispute 1.1 Description 1.2 Evidence of disputed behavior 1.2.1 WP:POINT / WP:3RR / WP:VANDAL (possible) 1.2.2 WP:CIVIL / WP:NPA 1.2.3 WP:AGF 1.2.4 Disruption / Threats 1.2.5 WP:C 1.2.6 Spamming 1.2.7 Other 1.2.8 WP:NOT 1.2.9 WP:U 1.3 Applicable policies and guidelines 1.4 Evidence of trying and failing to resolve the dispute 1.5 Users certifying the basis for this dispute 1.6 Other users who endorse this summary

[edit] Statement of the dispute

This is a summary written by users who dispute this user's conduct. Users signing other sections ("Response" or "Outside views") should not edit the "Statement of the dispute" section.

[edit] Description

{Add summary here, but you must use the section below to certify or endorse it. Users who edit or endorse this summary should not edit the other summaries, other than to endorse them.}

• NBGPWS (talk · contribs · logs · block user · block log)
• Fairness And Accuracy For All (talk · contribs · logs · block user · block log)

[edit] Evidence of disputed behavior

(Provide diffs. Links to entire articles aren't helpful unless the editor created the entire article. Edit histories also aren't helpful as they change as new edits are performed.)

[edit] WP:POINT / WP:3RR / WP:VANDAL (possible)

1. [1] [2] [3] [4]

   NBGPWS decided to spam a noticeboard that he did not agree with, adding material obviously not in line with the conspiracy theory angle of the noticeboard. He began adding an article on homosexual acts repeatedly as noted above. He was blocked for the behaviour by Luna Santin [5] who cited 3RR violation, disruption and WP:POINT violation. User has since admitted to violating WP:POINT [6] I and others regarded this incident as vandalism.

[edit] WP:CIVIL / WP:NPA

1. "deletionists" / "deletionist hit squad" - [7] [8] [9] [10] [11]
2. "Wiki Stalinists" - [12]
3. "Moron" - [13]
4. "WHAT???? If you think THAT'S an attack, You need more (or less) Byron!" - [14]

   Note: Byron reffering to The Byron Technique, "a sexual technique in which two male homosexual partners are involved" [15] [16]

5. "There is NO justification to remove the numerous reviews! Acting out in bitterness over the disasterous election results, huh?" - [17]
6. "Back to the 'Conspiracy Theories'! What's with you guys? Thank g_d you have your own club!" - [18]
7. "Wiki RepubliCon Cabal" & "FREEPER SCUM DEATH MERCHANTS !" - [19]

   Note this dif is provided below for proof of AGF as well.

[edit] WP:AGF

1. [20] "so the Wiki RepubliCon Cabal who deleted his entry SOLELY because it reflected VERY badly on the (mostly) Conservatives bloggers, Freepers and Scamdy Posters"

[edit] Disruption / Threats

1. [21] "You'll be hearing a LOT more about what some feel is your intentional misuse of BLP, beatty. A LOT more."

   Comment repeated [22]

2. [23] "As much as your OWN behavior and justification for it helped you LAST TIME, huh? LOL!"
3. [24] "If I desire your feedback, I'll post to YOUR user page!"

   User was blocked for the above series of comments by MONGO [25], stated reason of disruption.

4. [26] "Nuclear, you CAN'T just post your comments at the top, the page goes in time order, repost them where they belong, at or near the bottom of the page. You know better than that! ANI nex time you do it"
5. [27] "You're currently on probation for the exact sort of behavior you're exhibiting here, and did on the Votergate talk page, as well. You might consider changing that behavior before you get banned"

   This is in response to the below WP:C violation when I asked the user for proof the producers released the movie for download on YouTube.

[edit] WP:C

1. [28][29][30]

   User contended as noted above that producers released the video for public download on YouTube. When asked for proof, none was presented and instead the link was readded.

[edit] Spamming

1. [31] " I just discovered you were Zer0Faults too! Zer0faults has abandoned that account and opened a new account"

   User spammed this in about 3 different places, before posting here they spammed it on my talk page twice, purposeful disruption. Dif's of previous posts, note the edit summaries: [32][33][34]

[edit] Other

1. Accusations:

   [35] - "HD was NOT produced by HBO. One must question why nuclear insists on repeatedly inserting false info into the article"

   Note: at no point did I ever write it was.

2. Vote stacking:

   [36] "ANOTHER politically motivated AfD! ... No wonder they want to delete it." -

   [37] "The actions of these editors are all laid out right here. Votergate featured Andy Stepehenson who was the subject of a bitter AfD."

[edit] WP:NOT

1. Soapbox:

   [38] "March to CNN for Anti-War Tribunal"

   Warning given for it - [39]

2. Battleground: Posting of comments from political hotbed forums.

   [40] [41]

   Attempting to import off wiki arguements and general drama into Wikipedia space.

[edit] WP:U

1. NBGPWS = NeoConsBegoneProtestWarriorsSuck [42]

   Proof of acronym - [43]

   Also uses the name PWS (Protest Warriors Suck) on DemocraticWarrior.com

[edit] Applicable policies and guidelines

{list the policies and guidelines that apply to the disputed conduct}

1. WP:POINT
2. WP:3RR
3. WP:CIVIL
4. WP:NOT#Wikipedia_is_not_a_soapbox
5. WP:NOT#Wikipedia_is_not_a_battleground
6. WP:AGF
7. WP:NPA
8. WP:C
9. WP:U
10. WP:VANDAL (possible)

[edit] Evidence of trying and failing to resolve the dispute

(provide diffs and links)

[edit] Users certifying the basis for this dispute

{Users who tried and failed to resolve the dispute}

[edit] Other users who endorse this summary