Talk:Murtagh/Archive 1

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an archive of past discussions. Do not edit the contents of this page. If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the current talk page.

This is really really random and I know it's going to sound weird, but I simply must say it - Murtagh is hot. And Thorn (on the cover of Eldest) is gorgeous. He makes Saphira look too thin and not muscled enough - but maybe female dragons are built more delicately then male dragons. I actually hope that Murtagh and Thorn come over to the good side, so Saphira chooses Thorn over the green dragon who is obviously meant for her. And I agree that we can expect a relationship between Murtagh and Nasuada once Galbatorix is defeated.

Please try to keep the talk page focused on the article itself. :) Amina skywalker 17:19, 26 April 2006 (UTC)

But the artical is about the character!!! - The person without an account.

can anyone get the image of Murtagh from the movie (promotional pic) - the one with him and his sword? I don't know how to check for the copyright and there should be a picture of him. Emmaking May 3 2006

Done. :) « amiИa . skyшalkeя (¿Hábleme?) 23:14, 14 June 2006 (UTC)

Good pic. I agree. Murtagh is hot.

Oh yeah, he is totally hot. Will he die, do you think? I'd die! -- Frenchgal88 July 6 2006

puuuuuuuuuuurrrrrtagh.

Yeah, Murtagh!! -- canitwooz

As another person said earlier, let's try and keep this talk page focused on the article, not the character. (But I agree that he's hot) -- Emmaking July 8 2006

Murtagh is definitely the most interesting character in Inheritance (I'm not a fan, but an A-S girl if you know what I mean), and he's a huge favorite with everybody. I think he's pretty cool - but Paolini doesn't seem to like him very much. I mean, Murtagh's smarter and stronger than Eragon, and if it weren't for that stupid elf magic and dragon magic, he'd kick Eragon's ass. Eragon himself couldn't beat Murtagh, it's his undeserved "special abilities" that can do it. Paolini gives Murtagh a pretty raw deal, if you ask me. - isolde42, July 29th 2006

That's true! *sob* CP does hate him!! But I love love love Murtagh. He's the better brother, the better soldier, the better man! Why doesn't CP understand that? Murtagh saved Eragon's ass three times, and yet he's still called "Evil!" - micah, August 6th 2006

Yeah, Christopher doesn't give a damn about what Murtagh goes through or what will happen to him, he only care about Eragon and Arya. It's kinda obvious, isn't it? Murtagh's my favorite character, and if he dies in Book 3 then I'm going to completely lose faith in Christopher as a writer. You can't just callously kill off such an amazing character - why can't your hero die?! Oh wait I forgot, Eragon can't die because of Angela's stupid prophecy and Deathwatch, which gave away all the plot endings. Nice way to build suspense Christopher. Murtagh deserves better than you.

If Murtagh dies, C.P. is getting the meanest hate letter of his life. Too many of my favorite characters in different books have died (Dustfinger, The Black Rider, Garet Jax, ect). I hate when you know that a character is most likely going to die, and you can only wait to find out. Murtagh doesn't deserve to die!!!!! He's too smart and hot to die!!!!! - The person without an account

• I. LOVE. MURTAGH. He's the coolest, most impressive character in the trilogy and he's much better than Eragon! MURTAGH TOTALLY ROX!!!

• I TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU!!!!!!! I agree that CP does favor Eragon and Arya and they're gonna get a perfect life in the end. - The person without an account

Murtagh: Live or Die?

It sucks that he's barely featured in the Eragon teaser that came out ages ago...like 0.5 seconds, and he's the most interesting character in the trilogy! That's off topic, but I had to let it out...okay, I want to set up a kind of poll here. Who thinks Murtagh will survive Book 3, and who thinks he will die? I think he's dead. - inkblot2 July 13 2006

he is soooo hot and i dont want him to die, but i think he will at the end some kind of self sacrifise like gollum or something else i dono...-midnight Jully 14, 2006

I would absolutely hate it if he died, and hate Paolini for being so callous, but somehow I don't think he will. I think something much worse will happen - he survives, but Thorn dies. That is monstrously cruel...Murtagh has lost or been betrayed by all of his loved ones in life (father tried to kill him then died himself, mother ran off and left him; he was raised by enemies and then his only friend was killed, his brother is now his enemy...), and his life so far has been absolutely horrible, and then to lose his bonded brother? It'll crack him, he'll finally just break. But I don't see how Thorn can possibly survive - he's going to be killed in battle by Saphira and the green dragon. It's very likely that Murtagh will go down with him, and I'd almost prefer it to Murtagh surviving without Thorn. That is just awful. Either way, Murtagh is doomed - he can either die when he's actually done nothing wrong, or he can survive and live a cursed life. Those are his only options. -- Emmaking, July 14 2006

It sucks that murtagh only has two options, both of which are so horrible. His life so far has been hell (I'm glad I'm not the only who finds something very wrong with a woman who abandons her son when his father just tried to kill him)..it's been worse than eragon's life! much, much worse. anyway, considering what emmaking said, i'd rather have murtagh die (sob) than have him live and thorn die. the author will probably kill murtagh though - he doesn't seem to give a damn about him. - shazzer july 15 2006

I don't want him to die. He is the only character that I actually care about and defend in a conversation. Anyone else could die, and I wouldn't care. He probably will die because almost all of my favorite characters from books are dead or probably will be. His life definatly has been hell. If he does die, it will probably be Galbatorix's stupid oaths fault. He would be at peace if he dies, though. I would rather have him die doing something right (like killing Galbatorix) than having him lived a cursed life misled by lies. - The person without an account

• • I agree, I'd rather have him die than live a cursed life. But he has so much potential - such a terrible waste! And plus, he's young, he's hot, he's powerful...a shame. Such a shame. - shazzer july 16 2006

• • how i love conflicted youth - murtagh's the hero in the fanfics i write. i see a lot of girls seem to love him...it's probably why my fanfics get so many reviews ^_^ - antimatter11

• • A lot of girls seem to love him...I wonder why? He does have a lot of potential. He's only about 18/19 (which makes it impossible for Morzan to be his father, as he was killed 20 years ago) and it would be horrible to die so young! I was just thinking about Murtagh dying, and I hate it when things are inevitable. He's gonna die...sadly. Note: I wrote the thing right above the bullets. - The person without an account

i dont want him to die because he's so smart and ya he's waaaay hot!!!! do you think we can write to christopher and plead, or maybe he's already finised the book i dont know because the deluxe edition of eldest in coming out in 2 months with a book 3 excerpt maybe that means book3 is finsihed? i hope they mention something of murtagh in the excerpt! and i also hope nasuada and murtagh get together.

Whoa, it's nice to see that so many people contributed to my "poll". I guess the general consensus is that yes, Murtagh will die. How depressing...but every big story has to have a tragic hero, right? Murtagh is to Inheritance what Sirius Black is to Harry Potter, or what Anakin Skywalker is to Star Wars. The only thing that bugs me is that I feel Murtagh is shortchanged - he isn't given enough "page space", especially in Eldest! I was so annoyed by that. And I also feel Murtagh is more interesting and has more potential than Eragon, so I don't like that either. *sigh* - inkblot2, July 18 2006

• I think Murtagh is more important to Inheritance than Sirius Black is to Harry Potter. Murtagh's personality maybe closer to Sirius, but his role is more like Snape's, I think. Both of them are arguably the most complex characters in their respective series, and nobody knows if they're good or evil. They both have pivotal roles, although I agree that Murtagh is shortchanged. I think the poor boy's doomed. - arya

• I agree with arya and inkblot2. Murtagh doesn't get enough page space at all! Paolini hates him! Being obsessed with him, I hope that he gets more page space in book III. - The person without an account

• Murtagh's going to die, purely because some main character has to die, and since Christopher Paolini would never kill his pwecious Awya and Ewagon (sorry, but I have a major problem with them), or that idiot Roran, he's going to offhandedly kill Murtagh - one of the few characters with true potential and who's actually likeable. I'm planning on reading Book 3 only to find out what happens to Murtagh, but I know I'm going to be so pissed off when he dies tragically (and unnecessarily) and Eragon, Arya, and their dragons get the perfect happy ending. Of course Eragon will be happy - he didn't exactly trouble himself mourning Murtagh and Ajihad at the beginning of Eldest, did he? He and Saphira showed up at Ajihad's funeral drunk, for God's sake. And he spent exactly one paragraph thinking about Murtagh's death. Oh, the mysteries of 1D, character-less characters. - isolde42 July 29 2006

isolde42, I completely 100,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000% agree with you. CP doesn't give a damn about Murtagh. I swear, if CP kills off Murtagh, I'm going to write CP a really nasty letter, and make sure he gets it (and a lot of the people in my guild will write a letter too). Plus, I'll cry for days. Everyone might think I'm crazy, but unlike Eragon, I'd mourn Murtagh's death (Eragon would probably go to the funeral drunk too). That's why I'm gonna read the book in my room so I can have peace and quiet and cry if Murtagh dies. I feel better now that I said all of that... - The person without an account

I agree with isolde42 as well, and it makes me mad. Murtagh should have been the hero of Inheritance, not Eragon. He's smarter, stronger, cooler and waaay more interesting, plus he grew up amidst all the historical events and power figures of the day. He saw the last of the Thirteen Forsworn, Galbatorix and the mysterious Selena who I suspect got laid with more men besides Morzan. He grew up in the royal palace and met the Evil King (omigosh GALBY!), and I suspect his thoughts would be more interesting to read about - he isn't a whiner who goes running to his dragon every time he pricks his toe. He's not an original character, but I wish he'd been created by a more competent and caring writer than Christopher, a writer who actually cared about him. - pikachu2raichu August 6th 2006

• Lighten up people. Murtagh isn't going to die a tragic death. Murtagh is the single coolest character in Inheritance, and he's not about to let anybody kill him or insult him - he's going to break free of his bonds and teach Galbatorix what happens to people who mess with him. Murtagh's going to kick ass and rule the world.

• I really like your idea, but i seriously doubt that's gonna happen. - The person without an account

• He's not going to die, peeps. And stop making out Chris to be a horrible character hating twerp. If he didn't like the character, he wouldn't have made it. And have any of you considered the fact that Saphira might not take to Greenie? I'm thinking Saphira/Thorn. Anyway, why in the hell would Thorn die? The only ones who would stand a good chance against him are Saphira and Greenie. And do you honestly think that they are going to kill one of the last remaining Dragons? A race can't be built on two alone, unless the siblings mate. What the Dragon's need are more females.

And it's quite possible that if Murtagh dies Thorn will die right along with him, Brom did mention that in most cases both Dragon and Rider die. My thinking points in the direction of Murt learning Galby's true name and somehow breaking free.

Nasuada

• So, does he like her or what? - arya
  • You made a fair point on the Snape thing. As for Nasuada...he never really got a chance to know her, right? Or did he? CP didn't really describe the days in Tronjheim after the battle, except for Eragon and his scar. When Eragon was being healed by Angela after killing Durza, Murtagh may have met Nasuada, as they were both in the battle. Then Murtagh was knocked unconscious and sent back...did she go see him? When Murtagh was scouring the dwarf tunnels with Ajihad, did he see her before he went off? None of that is explained, which is somewhat frustrating. From what we do know, Murtagh only met Nasuada once, and he thought she was hot. Noble, or something. - inkblot2 July 18 2006

I hate nasuada. she and murtagh shouldn't be together. - The person without an account

• Nasuada's cool. She's smart without being a snot, she doesn't insult other people's beliefs, and she isn't arrogant. If there's any female character I hate, it's Arya. - inkblot2 July 19 2006
  • oh thanks! Arya's not so bad. Nasuada's all right, given that Paolini doesn't really delve into her thoughts beyond battling the Empire, so we don't actually know that much about her mind and her feelings. I'm a bit indifferent to her. - arya

• • • No one ever agrees with me... - The person without an account
• I think it's more likely that Nasuada will end up with King Orrin. Murtagh and she seem to like each other, but it can't happen because they're enemies, and he'll be forced to die defending Galbatorix. Also, he's a Rider, she's a mortal. There's no getting around that - whether or not they like each other, they can never be together. And doesn't it seem practical for King Orrin...he and Nasuada are the two human leaders of the Rebellion. I can see them getting together, if only for political reasons. - Faultytowers July 19 2006

who thinks murtagh is like jack sparrow (i'm sorry, captain jack sparrow) from pirates of the carribean? sooo hot!! - brie108

• That's the first time I heard that. Now that I think about it... anyway...I agree that Nasuada should be with King Orrin. - The person without an account

• Jack Sparrow? Erm...not exactly. Well...hmm...no, not quite. I think Nasuada and King Orrin would be a good match. It could go either way with her.

• I think that person meant that Captain Jack Sparrow and Murtagh are both hot. - The person without an account

• I think Jack Sparrow is more funny than hot, although I agree Murtagh is definitely hot. He's the only character I really find interesting. As for Nasuada, she's cool - she's had some character development in Eldest, which is more than I can say for other characters that got more attention, like Arya or Eragon.. I think that all young heroes/anti-heroes in cheesy "epics" such as this one need a romantic interest. Eragon has Arya, Roran has Katrina, and even the Twins probably had Trianna...so who will Murtagh have? Elva? Too young. Angela? Too old, and weird besides. A noblewoman of the Empire? Can't be, because we don't know any and for a major character like Murtagh, it needs to be someone we've already been introduced to. Nasuada's perfectly positioned for a tragic tale of forbidden love - the Rebel leader and the King's right hand man. Not to mention she's been set up to be quite attractive, and Murtagh is the ultimate in fictional hot bad guys. There's a reason her appearance has been described - hot young women who are also prominent characters are incomplete without a love interest, as Paolini's treatment of Arya proves. So Nasuada looks like the most likely partner for Murtagh - and to be honest, I like her best out of all the female leads. - isolde42 July 29 2006

• I hate Nasuada I hope Murtagh ends up with someone better than her. But she is the best out of the female leads... I cant stand Arya or Eragon though! Why does the best character (Murtagh) have to die. (I dont think he is like Captain Jack Sparrow, but they are both hot) and whoever said Murtagh is like Snape is a genius only Murtagh is alot hotter and younger! - Midnight July 30 2006

• I totally agree with Midnight. - The person without an account

why do people think murtagh should be with nasuada? nasuada should be with king orrin! - The person without an account

• • Why are you so certain Nasuada should be with King Orrin? Read the 'Possible Romance' section of Murtagh's wiki page; there has been clear foreshadowing concerning Murtagh and Nasuada. Nasuada has a scene with King Orrin, and from her POV, but she never shows any interest in him, or feels attracted to him. Remember, if you get a scene from a character's POV and they don't indicate that they notice anything about the other person's appearance or personality, it's not a very good sign. On the other hand, Nasuada and Murtagh have never had a scene together, and yet we can tell they are attracted to each other from the way they talk about each other. And there is also the foreshadowing. - lancel August 3rd 2006

• • They don't have to like each other. And most likely Murtagh is gonna die in some tragic thing, sadly...but Nasuada should be with King Orrin for political reasons. - The person without an account

• I have no real interest in Nasuada besides the fact that she's slightly better than Arya, but I think she's basically just a plot device to get Murtagh killed. How cliched (and characteristic of Christopher) would it be if Murtagh's love for Nasuada ended up being his doom? Because Murtagh is doomed, I think we've all realized that. It's just so cliche, the forbidden-love-ending-in-tragedy thing. It's just so Christopher Paolini. - pikachu2raichu, August 6th 2006

• Murtagh does deserve better. Heil Murtagh!

• Poor Murtagh... - The person without an account

• Guess what? Over at Inheritance Forums, there's a poll about who's your fave character from Inheritance. Keep in mind ALL readers participated, not just Murtagh fans...and Murtagh got the most votes! I always suspected he was the most popular character, and now I have proof. And Thorn was everyone's second favorite dragon after Saphira, which is quite amazing considering Thorn didn't have any lines and only made one appearance so far. - inkblot2 August 7 2006

I agree! - The person without an account

I agree with you guys about Murtagh, but we should really try to fill in these citations if possible.

(Looks up citations) Well, we're having fun just going on about Murtagh. And now I know what citations means! - The person without an account

Question: In the artical is says "A Elven dagger named Drac'ner" under important possessions. Did they ever mention that in the book? I don't remember it. - The person without an account

I think that Murtagh and Thorn will come over to the good side but I don't think that Thorn and Saphira will mate, just because I don't think that it sounds like something Christopher would do based on what we have read so far. I agree that there will be some romance between Murtagh and Nasuada though. -thornrider19

I think at the end Arya and Eragon (blech!) will hook up, Roran will (already has, actually) hook up with Katrina, and Murtagh will hook up with me. :D Or Nasuada. - murtaghrider (no! lol that's just a joke; I got the idea from thornrider19)

If Murtagh survives, and he hooks up with Nasuada, I will throw my book across the room and not read another word of anything written my CP (and I'll write him a letter that will not be pleasant). You know, Nasuada might not even survive book III *crosses fingers*. CP made a major change in Nasuada's character. A major change could be dying. That's a major change. - The person without an account

You can uncross your fingers. CP said that he made a major change to the ending of Book 3 that "involves Nasuada" and of which he is very excited, which I think is a fair indication that she survives. She's a bit flat, but she got more development (went from pretty girl to rebel leader) than some other characters, like Arya. - murtaghrider

• sigh* And I have a theory about Galbatorix!! I got came up with it when I was reading an artical about a Yu-Gi-Oh! GX character, Sartorious. He has 2 personalities. 1 good, 1 evil. There might still be some good left in Galby! Anyway, back to Murtagh. I have no more interesting theories about him! - The person about an account

• Sheesh, you're all a bunch of cynics. If you hate most of the characters and The Author why are you reading the books? Anyway, I think Murtagh/Nasuada is most likely. Their personalities compliment each other nicely and I think even if they don't fall in love they may become good friends, depending on weather or not Murt survives which is most definately within the realm of possibility. It is possible, I suppose that Nasuada MIGHT become the next rider. It would tie up a few knots and could be the twist involving Nasuada that Chris mentioned. I really see no point in Arya becoming the next rider seeing as she's already powerful and imortal. She does not need to be a rider. And even though a lot of people seem to think that Chris is a horrible character hating sadistic dweeb, I like to think that he is smarter than that. - The Accountless N00b.

• • Accountless N00b - this is not a place for flaming other people. If they want to read Inheritance and then critique it, then that's their business. I don't think this is the place for arguing about their opinions on Inheritance, this is just to discuss Murtagh and his role/position in Inheritance. To get back on topic, I don't think Murtagh will die, but I think Thorn will. And as for Nasuada, I think that might work out. - fangdom, September 3rd 2006

• • • Nasuada has very little chance of becoming the next Rider. She's human. She needs to be trained. They don't have that much time. - The person without an account

• fangdom - I was not flaming. At least not intentionally. If any offense was caused, I am sorry. However I was simply stating my opinion and I believe that is my business as much as the various critiques are the business of those who have posted them. Nor do I see how anyone was arguing, once again people are entitled to their opinions and are entitled to state them no matter what other peoples opinions are. There is a differance between debate and argument. And I admit that I slightly overstepped the limits when I called people cynical, I can only plead that I am an optimist and am getting a little fed up with all pessimistic talk that I see on this subject. Anyway, this is completely off topic so I'll shut up now. - The Acountless N00b