Talk:Moses Fleetwood Walker
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
Moses Fleetwood Walker is maintained by WikiProject Baseball, which aims to improve Wikipedia's coverage of baseball and baseball-related topics. If you would like to participate, visit the project page, or contribute to the discussion | ||
| ??? | This article has not yet received a rating on the quality scale. | ||
| ??? | This article has not yet received a rating on the importance scale. | ||
|
Article Grading: |
|||
|
WikiProject Baseball To-do:
Here are some tasks you can do to help with WikiProject Baseball:
|
|||
 |
This article is within the scope of WikiProject Biography. For more information, visit the project page. | ||
| ??? | This article has not yet received a rating on the Project's quality scale. Please rate the article and then leave a short summary here to explain the ratings and/or to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the article. [FAQ] | ||
Contents |
[edit] Edits by 24.196.83.46
- Walker has traditionally been credited as the first African-American major league player. Recent research by the Society for American Baseball Research indicates William Edward White, who played one game for the Providence Grays in 1879, was the son of a white former slave-holder and his mulatto mistress.
SABR did not indicate White 'was the son of a white former slave-holder and his mulatto mistress.'
They indicated he may have been the first African-American major league player, as the previous version indicated.
I am reverting that change. Econrad 1 July 2005 05:22 (UTC)
- From the Providence Journal 2/15/2004 (free registration required):
- "The mystery of White's background and life goes back to a plantation in rural Georgia. He was the son of a white plantation owner, who was also a captain in the Confederate Army, and his mulatto servant."
-
- OK, to be more precise: The anonymous user removed all references to the point that White may have been the first professional black baseball player. Very misleading. Econrad 3 July 2005 13:12 (UTC)
Looking at other changes, the anonymous user also deleted the 'law school' reference from the section that read 'He then attended the University of Michigan law school'
Why?
I am reverting the entire edit.
Econrad 1 July 2005 05:33 (UTC)
[edit] International League as a major league in the 1880s
Another edit by the anonymous user:
- 24.196.83.46 (→Baseball Career - International League was not a major league. It was the top minor league in the country, but it was not a major league. The two 1880s major leagues were the AA and the NL)
Here's the source:
"After playing two seasons in minor league baseball, Walker resurfaced in the majors playing for Newark of the International League in 1887. That season, he and star pitcher George Stovey formed the first black battery in organized baseball."
Source: http://www.blackathlete.net/artman/publish/article_0512.shtml
I'm not saying that's gospel, do you have a source indicating otherwise?
- I found a counter point:
- "When the International League was inaugurated in 1887, Walker and seven other African Americans including Fowler and Grant were part of the circuit. This league was (and is) one notch below the majors (AAA)." Source: http://www.dickiethon.com/omnibus/negro_part1.htm Econrad 3 July 2005 13:38 (UTC)
The blackathlete.net site is incorrect. The International league was often considered the third best league in the country one notch below the two majors. Any baseball encyclopedia will confirm the the American Association and the National League were the two major leagues in 1887.
See for example these two baseball reference sites and their list of major leagues by year:
http://www.baseball-reference.com/leagues/
and
http://baseball-almanac.com/yearmenu.shtml
Properly, these reference sites make no mention of the International League as a major league.
[edit] William Edward White
A little more information on W.E. White. The Providence Journal article mentions W.E. White's race as being listed as "white" in the 1900 and 1910 census. It does not mention the 1880 census. However, doing a search through http://www.familysearch.org in the 1880 U.S. census for William E. White in Rhode Island brings up: William E. White in his 1880 boarding house in Providence also listed as "white." Unfortunately, there seems to be no way to link directly to this census result on familysearch.org (gregor197)
This would be easier to talk about if Mr. White's last name was not the same as the racial category! :)
- I've been wrestling with how much info to include on White, and whether to create a page for him, and include it there. The original section I wrote just said White 'may' have been the first.
- I added a 'Baseball History' section to frame the William Edward White content on Fleet's page; I'm not sure if it should be moved to a new page for White. Econrad 3 July 2005 20:52 (UTC)
-
- A separate W.E. White page would be a good thing, but I still think it's good to leave information about the controversy here, too, since it is pertinent to Walker's history. (gregor197)
-
-
- FYI: you can date and sign your name by typing 4 tildes ('~') in a row. Econrad 3 July 2005 21:47 (UTC)
-
Good addition of the baseball history separator.... I was thinking about separating that section, too!
Abisai here: I was wondering if the entire section titled baseball history was better suited as a separate article, one addressing the White vs. Walker as first discussion separately, or even one just to address White individually. Also, I was considering putting something to distinguish Mr. Walker as the first everday player, since Mr. White played but a single game. I feel inadequately aware of the facts of the matter and would defer to others, but thought this was a point worthy of mentioning in the article.
- Agreed. I'd like a short mention of the issue in this article (as it was originally) with a wikilink to the more detailed info, whether on a William Edward White page, or on a page dedicated to the issue, like 'First African-American Major-Leage Baseball Player', or similar. If anyone has thoughts on the issue (or the title if we go with a separate article), please add your $.02.
- NPOV becomes challenging (for me anyways), as White played one game as a sub, and, as the Toledo Blade explains, "One of the main reasons why Mr. White probably didn't come to light until last year was, until then, no one knew that he was African-American."[1]. My POV says Fleet deserves credit for playing time and for suffering due to racism, but I'm trying to remain NPOV.Econrad 6 July 2005 01:12 (UTC)
[edit] Fleet in College
Walker initially enrolled at Oberlin in 1878, but that school did not field a varsity baseball team for competition with outside opponents until 1881 (See Zang: pages 20-22). Walker had been a frequent competitor in intramural competitions before the formation of the varsity.
Walker then transferred to the University of Michigan for the 1881-82 school year. He played varsity baseball in 1882. (See Zang: pages 22-23 and 29). Technically speaking, colleges did not award varsity letters until the turn of the century, so he didn't actually win any letters, per se.
In 1883, of course, Walker turned professional for the Toledo Blue Stockings, so he only played one year on the varsity at Michigan.
Weldy Walker followed in his brother's footsteps and also transferred to Michigan - where he played varsity baseball in 1883 and 1884. (See Zang: page 32 and "A Fleeting Ambition" http://www.pub.umich.edu/daily/1999/apr/04-20-99/sports/sports9.html]
- US Gov source that says Fleet Walker won two varsity letters: [2]
Econrad 4 July 2005 00:26 (UTC)
The Honorable Douglas Applegate and his staff did the best that they could for this resolution, but there was not as much information readily available about Fleet Walker in 1990 as there is now, and the two varsity letters assertion is incorrect. The time table itself rules this out. He played for Oberlin in the spring of 1881 and Toledo in the spring of 1883. In between he played at Michigan in the spring of 1882.
[edit] Thanks Econrad
I found a small item about this player and found it interesting enough to begin a little stub about it here. It is very interesting for me to read the updates and further deliberation provided, especially by Econrad. Thanks for your work here.
- Thanks for the kind words!Econrad 6 July 2005 01:12 (UTC)
