User talk:Mike Selinker/Wikipedians

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Contents

[edit] Wikipedian categories

I thought I would get a jump on helping right away : ) - jc37 21:04, 6 September 2006 (UTC)

Quote:

Let's see if this helps:

[edit] Skill Level adjective

  1. (are) beginner; or (have an) introductory;
  2. intermediate
  3. advanced
  4. expert
  5. native
  6. humble

use "a" or "an" in the following as appropriate

[edit] Computer Programmers

  • Wikipedian computer programmers
  • Wikipedians who are <skill level> computer programmers
  • Wikipedians who are <programming language> programmers
  • Wikipedians who are <skill level> programmers of <programming language>

[edit] Musical Instrument

  • Wikipedian <skill level> <instrument> players

OR

  • Wikipedian <skill level> <instrument> + ists
(accordianists, pianists, vocalists, etc)
(depending on usage)

[edit] Language

  • Wikipedians who are <skill level> speakers of <language>

OR

  • Wikipedians who have a <skill level> understanding of <language>
(which do you prefer?)


  • Wikipedians who have a <skill level> understanding of the <language> script

OR

  • Wikipedians who have a <skill level> understanding of the <language> alphabet
(depending on usage)

[edit] Use of Not

Each of the preceeding groups could have "not" placed after the verb of being (is/are), or could have "do not" placed before "have".

(These would be the "zero" level languages, etc.)

Examples:

Programmers:

  • Wikipedians who are not computer programmers
(etc)

Instruments:

  • Wikipedians who do not play the <instrument>

OR

  • Wikipedians who are not <instrument> + ists

Language possibilities:

  • Wikipedians who do not have a <skill level> understanding of <language>
  • Wikipedians who do not understand <language>
  • Wikipedians who do not speak <language>


  • Wikipedians who do not have a <skill level> understanding of the <language> script
  • Wikipedians who do not have a <skill level> understanding of the <language> alphabet
  • Wikipedians who do not understand the <language> script
  • Wikipedians who do not understand the <language> alphabet

Note: In thinking about the "use of not" categories, I am beginning to think we should just delete them. If we add "those who do", to "those who do not", we will have a listing of all Wikipedians. - jc37 02:59, 12 September 2006 (UTC)