From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This page will never be Wikipedia policy. It is, by design, entirely informal.
The Mediation Cabal provides informal mediation for disputes on Wikipedia. We cannot confirm or deny our existence. Actually the "Cabalists" of the Mediation Cabal do wish to help you, but problems are much easier to solve when you can laugh about them.
|
Shortcut:
WP:TINMC
WP:MEDCAB
WP:MEDCABAL |
|
The Mediation Cabal is a bunch of volunteers providing unofficial, informal mediation for disputes on Wikipedia. The Mediation Committee provides official mediation (per Wikipedia:Mediation), and the Arbitration Committee produces official resolutions and sanctions. We at MedCabal are not at all official and are just ordinary Wikipedians.
We do not impose sanctions or make judgments. We facilitate communication and help parties reach an agreement by their own efforts.
There are some situations we cannot help you with. Please read the following carefully.
- You must already be having a discussion. We cannot start a discussion for you. If participants are edit-warring without discussion we cannot help you. Consider asking for page protection. Once you have a discussion going we can help.
- Mediation is purely voluntary. All interested parties must be willing to accept mediation. If any interested party does not accept mediation, we cannot help.
- We cannot judge who is right (unless there is a clear policy violation). If you need outside opinions, you can ask for a third opinion, or appeal to a broader community for input by asking at the Village pump, posting a Wikiquette alert (for behavioral issues), or filing a Request for Comment
- Be familiar with Wikipedia policy. Be sure to read WP:NPOV, WP:RS, and WP:EL.
- All parties must be willing to assume good faith.
If you have any questions you can post on our talk page, join us at the #wikipedia-medcab IRC channel on Freenode, or send us email.
If you wish your case to be handled discreetly or if you cannot edit Wikipedia, you can ask on IRC or send us email.
How to list a MedCab request
I. |
Put the MedCab request tag on talk page of the dispute.
- {{subst:Medcab-request}}
- at the top of the page.
- Do not mark the edit as minor.
- Save the page.
|
II. |
Create the article's case page.
- The resulting box at the top of the article should contain a link to "Preloaded case page".
- Click that link to open the article's case page. A preloaded form and some instructions will appear. Fill out the form. Please be concise.
- Save the page.
|
It may take up to several weeks for a MedCab mediator to take on your case. Please be patient.
Cabalists
Cabalists magically rise to the call of mediation simply by having the case page on their watchlists. There are no official members. We are also happy to accept new mediators. If you want to help mediate, just pick a case from the list of new cases below. You can read some suggestions here. Don't be afraid to ask for help on the talk page.
Coordinators
The Mediation Cabal coordinators are:
If you have any concerns or otherwise need assistance from the coordinators, you can ask at the Coordination Desk.
Case list
This list is included on opentasks. Please update when necessary:
Robert Gray, anarchy battlefield, Almeda University, Antioxidant, Hero, The Freechild Project, More...
Cases needing mediators
|
When people create a new case, it will get automatically added below. If you volunteer to help out a case, please change the template status field to "open."
|
Open cases
|
To put cases on this list, you must change the template status field to "open." Put all comments on the case pages themselves or in the template comment field.
- 2007-01-04 Johann Hari — Mediator(s): TheronJ
- 2007-01-24 Afshar Experiment — Mediator(s): sdirrim
- 2007-01-26 Magnetic Monopole NPOV — Mediator(s): Mathmo
- 2007-02-01 shock wave — Mediator(s): Mathmo
- Comment: Early stages at the moment, looking over evidence
- 2007-02-04 ECW One Night Stand edits — Mediator(s): Flakeloaf
- 2007-02-06 Sinosphere — Mediator(s): JUBALCAIN 23:55, 10 February 2007 (UTC)
- 2007-02-10 Boris Stomakhin — Mediator(s): Diez2
- Comment: Needs more opinions
- 2007-02-10 Castelseprio — Mediator(s): Selket
- Comment: The assistance of another mediator is requested. --Selket Talk 00:41, 16 March 2007 (UTC)
- 2007-02-13 Canadian English Words — Mediator(s): SRICE13
- 2007-02-19 Clinical Psychology — Mediator(s): .V. (talk • contribs)
- 2007-02-24 Costco Employment Practices — Mediator(s): WJBscribe (talk • contribs)
- 2007-02-28 Eugène Ionesco
- Comment: Needs new mediator - last one was blocked indefinitely.
- 2007-03-05 RDRAM — Mediator(s): YechielMan
- Comment: It's a dispute over the inclusion of a highly technical paragraph.
- 2007-03-06 Ethnic Cleansing — Mediator(s): Snowolf
- 2007-03-06 Morgellons — Mediator(s): vassyana (talk • contribs)
- Comment: Participants engaged in discussion. Posing questions to help organize issues and move forward towards compromise.
- 2007-03-06 Steven Alan Hassan — Mediator(s): Vassyana (talk • contribs)
- Comment: Truce accepted. Sandbox drafts completed. Comparing differances between two versions of drafts for review. Asking for a compromise draft to be written.
- 2007-03-08 Chai (symbol) — Mediator(s): RJASE1
- Comment: Have heard back from both parties, ready to begin.
- 2007-03-10 Newroz as celebrated by Kurds — Mediator(s): —— Eagle101 Need help? 04:04, 23 March 2007 (UTC)
- Comment: Opening case, seeing if everyone is happy with mediation.
- 2007-03-11 Ohio State University — Mediator(s): Eagle 101
- Comment: We are underway. (Have gotten 3rd party input)
- 2007-03-13 Electronic Voice Phenomenon — Mediator(s): —— Eagle101 Need help? 21:36, 18 March 2007 (UTC)
- Comment: Opening case, see if parties will accept me.
- 2007-03-14 List of metropolitan areas by population — Mediator(s): —— Eagle101 Need help? 06:09, 17 March 2007 (UTC)
- Comment: Opening case, seeing if both users will accept me as mediator.
- 2007-03-19 PCD (album) — Mediator(s): Mr.Z-mantalk¢Review!
- Comment: Making inital contact
- 2007-03-24 From Genesis to Revelation — Mediator(s): RJASE1
- Comment: The requestor in this case has left Wikipedia. Case should probably be closed as a result.
- 2007-03-25 Global warming — Mediator(s): Kim Bruning
- Comment: Needs help from more mediators... Please don't use the medcab page.
- 2007-03-28 Guru Gita — Mediator(s): --James, La gloria è a dio 23:17, 29 March 2007 (UTC)
- 2007-03-29 Hero — Mediator(s): Snowolf
- 2007-03-30 Jim Bob Duggar — Mediator(s): Ulysses411
- Comment: Both parties are on a break until April 8, 2007 while third party assistance is provided by Project Biography members.
- 2007-03-31 ChrisO — Mediator(s): anthony[cfc]
|
Old cases
|
|
|