Talk:Lux Aeterna (Requiem for a Dream)
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
I don't think this one track need to be separated from the Requiem for a Dream (soundtrack) article. One reason for the RfaD(s) article was to collect the uses of this track, which had started to clutter up both the Requiem for a Dream film & Clint Mansell pages. But now it is yet another page removed from this, and the link is not obvious.
Unless a valid argument for separating this track from the album page is given, I will re-merge it back. The Yeti 00:03, 24 March 2007 (UTC)
- It's because this is the track that Requiem for a Dream is most famous for - I highly doubt that any track other than Lux Aeterna has been used in such a widespread fashion. Even from the soundtrack page: "Lux Æterna" has since become extremely popular, with both the original and the remix having appeared in a wide variety of commercials and trailers.
In my opinion, that makes it notable enough to merit its own article. Plus, it reduces clutter from the soundtrack article when 90% is about LA. Will 22:59, 24 March 2007 (UTC)
-
- I don't know -- although I have been working on cleaning up this article, I don't really see why it's better here than as a "Lux Aeterna"-specific subsection of the soundtrack article. I find it unlikely that this page -- little more than a stub -- will ever expand into a full-fledge article. ~CS 00:26, 25 March 2007 (UTC)
-
-
- When people try to do internet searches on "that music from The Two Towers / Sunshine / etc trailer", they are most likely to find the answer Requiem for a Dream or Requiem for a Tower; not Lux Aeterna. That is a good reason to merge it back, as the whole point of Wikipedia is to help people find info on a topic.
-
-
-
- And the fact that one of the "other uses" had to be moved from here back to RfaD(s) sort of invalidates the first reply given to the proposal above.
-
-
-
- Besides, the original location [RfaD(s)] was - firstly not that long anyway, and - secondly only been in existence for a couple of weeks. The Yeti 03:20, 25 March 2007 (UTC)
-
