Talk:Local derby
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 |
The article on Local derby is supported by the WikiProject on Football, which is an attempt to improve the quality and coverage of football (soccer) related articles on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, you can visit the project page; if you have any questions about the project or the article ratings below, please consult the FAQ. |
|---|---|
| Start | This article has been rated as Start-Class on the quality scale. |
| Mid | This article has been rated as Mid-importance on the importance scale. |
I question whether the USA should be in this. You don't hear "derby" or "local derby" used much here. "Crosstown rivalry" is heard much more often.
On the other hand, in US college sports, there are innumerable "annual grudge matches", chiefly in football - frequently these are between schools located in one state, such as Alabama-Auburn, or Texas-Texas A&M, or in neighboring states, such as Michigan-Ohio State, or Florida-Georgia, or even in non-adjacent states, such as Oklahoma-Nebraska. Ellsworth 17:49, 25 Sep 2004 (UTC)
[edit] Edinburgh Derby "Catholic-Protestant" rivalry theory
This is absolute rubbish. It may have been the case 100 or so years ago but is nothing more than an inter-city rivalry now; Hibs have, in fact, a higher Protestant than Catholic fanbase. I, as well as many other Hibees and Jambos, would consider this an insult, comparing Hibs and Hearts to the bigots from Glasgow, thus I have removed it.—The preceding unsigned comment was added by 82.41.90.87 (talk • contribs).
I agree. There is absolutely no evidence that such a sectarian rivalry exists between Hearts and Hibs. Snowbound 01:08, 18 October 2006 (UTC)
[edit] international derbies
I've added in a tentative start at an international list (country vs country) at the bottom of the article - it needs considerable expansion, and I'm not 100% convinced this is the best place in the article for it. Input welcomed! Grutness|hello? 
01:36, 1 Jan 2005 (UTC)
- Hi. I just have to add that I do think that the international 'derbies' page, really doesn't qualify as a derby as such, but more of a rivalry. I personally think that it qualifies for its own page, before more matches are added to the list. Other people's opinions on this? - Master Of Ninja 23:52, 13 Mar 2005 (UTC)
-
- I disagree. "Local" is relative. In rugby union, Australia-New Zealand is a derby; New Zealand-South Africa is a rivalry. Certainly, countries with a land border have a local element at the margin. Joestynes 05:49, 14 Mar 2005 (UTC)
On another topic, I don't know that Northern Ireland v Republic of Ireland is a major rivalry. They haven't played very often (this site lists 4 pairs of qualifiers and 1 friendly), and few of the matches were memorable or important. Perhaps not every political cleavage corresponds to a sporting rivalry. Certainly Republic fans would get more excited about playing England (not that England fans would get too excited — I guess rivalries ought to be symmetric to merit inclusion). Joestynes 09:22, 13 Apr 2005 (UTC)
I would say England fans would get very excited, just look at the 1992 (not sure of year) when it had to be abandoned. SouthEastLad
[edit] 'Rivalries' that aren't quite 'Derbies'
I've searched quite a bit but I'm yet to find a page that deals with hotly contested sporting rivalries that aren't neccessarily 'local' (e.g. 'El Classico' between Barca and Real Madrid, Liverpool v Manchester United in England). Is there a page I have missed, and if there isn't, do these matches deserve some sort of a mention here? --Alilaw 16:24, 26 Jan 2005 (UTC)
- http://www.footballderbies.com/ - Go here; meaning to add to page for a wee bit, so did it just now. You probably could do a wikipedia article on it, but I'd be hard pressed thinking a name for it. "Football rivalries" maybe? - Master Of Ninja 18:04, 26 Jan 2005 (UTC)
[edit] Oslo Derby
If the derby is west against east,why do both teams have the same stadium?
- Because Lyn is generally regarded as the team belonging to the upper-class (the former king of Norway being a prominent supporter and all), meaning they belong to Western Oslo (the richer part of Oslo). Vålerenga is the team belonging to the eastern, more poorer part, of Oslo. Besides they didn't always use to share the stadium. Salmon 12:55, 12 March 2006 (UTC)
[edit] north east (England) "derbies"
Must we have "north east" (England) derbies included in the UK section? I usually take a derby to mean teams within the same city or county. Yes, there are exceptions such as Manchester United V Leeds (because of the War of the Roses Pennine thing) and can operate of a regional scale but you don't hear about "North West derbies or South East derbies. Newcastle and Sunderland are within the same county, therefore it's a Tyne-Wear derby. Middlesbrough have no great connection with Newcastle or Sunderland. Ask a Geordie or Mackem about Middlesbrough, there usually isn't a great feeling of identity or shared history with the area. Not that I mean to be too harsh of Middlesbrough but it's virutally Yorkshire (well...at one time it kind of was). There is a great distance between the Tees and the Tyne. It just annoys me when people use the "North East" as if it is a city in its own right, the same with Scotland.
Also, whilst it is true that Carlisle, being in Cumbria, gets included as being in the North East, I don't know anyone who would call Carlisle V. York, or even Carlisle V. Newcastle a "derby". There's around 120 miles between Carlisle and York! Hardly a local derby. Imagine calling Hearts V. Celtic a derby! I have therefore taken away the NE sections, kept the Tyne-Wear derby. Is someone can come up with a local derby for Middlesbrough (Darlington) then feel free to add it. I'll get off my soapbox now! hedpeguyuk 21:22, 20 April 2006 (UTC)
I've added a "Tees" football derby. Middlesbrough V. Hartlepool and left the Tyne Wear derby. If any Hartlepool supporters/residents aren't happy then feel free to change it. But "North East" as a region is far too broad. York and Carlisle also need derbies added but I'm too tired to do it now! hedpeguyuk 21:33, 20 April 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Manchester united vs Arsenal
would their games be considered derbies? they are rivals and always have heated matches. any idea what the name of this Derby would be?
- An inherent feature of a derby is the physical closeness of the teams. Since Manchester and London are not close to each other, games between their teams, no matter how fierce the rivalry is, cannot be considered a derby. Bob Palin 17:22, 19 June 2006 (UTC)
- ok sounds good. lol
[edit] Supposed tameness of Mets/Yankees Rivalry
Regular season games between the Mets and Yankees have only been played since 1997, but that development made the rivalry incredibly heated. Many fans of both teams (particulary those who were already Yankee fans in 1962 when the Mets were formed) had to pick sides when this series began. Add in the near-Subway (World) Series in 1999 and the 2000 World Series, and now the fans are always wild for these games. It's especially true now with both teams doing so well. Bwysock 18:58, 2 September 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Rivalry?
Liverpool vs Nottingham Forest is not a derby game. I'm not even sure if it's been even much of a rivalry for 20 years. Am I wrong?
- Not a derby - Liverpool v Everton is, but Liverpool v Forest is Nott! Australian Matt 04:40, 19 November 2006 (UTC)
[edit] The Greatest Derby in Britian
The greatest Derby in Britian is... yes the Glasgow Derby Celtic vs Rangers the heat between these two clubs is unique wont find it anywhere in the world. People Worldwide tune in to watch this Rivalry and are alway impressed.
[edit] "Falkirk Derby"
Falkirk v Dunfermline is listed as the "Falkirk Derby". Clearly its isn't, the Falkirk derby should be the East Stirlingshire v Falkirk game (listed as Stirlingshire derby, although neither are now in Stirlingshire!) However, as I was about to change this I realised I had no idea what to classify the Falkirk v Dunfermline game as. Clearly it is a typical "derby" match, mutual dislike etc but why? Any Pars or Bairns fans able to resolve this and give it its proper name? The best I can think of is "Central Scotland Derby" Caledonian Place 01:14, 23 October 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Need to Keep Rivalry and Derby seperate
Too much duplication! Kevlar67 00:26, 25 November 2006 (UTC)
- yes! thank you!
