List of territorial disputes
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This is a list of extant territorial disputes around the world. A claimant's full control is indicated in bold, one or more claimant's partial control indicated in italics.
[edit] Disputes involving states that recognize each other
[edit] In Africa and neighbouring seas
- Bassas da India, Europa Island and Juan de Nova: France and Madagascar[1]
- Badme: Ethiopia and Eritrea[1]
- Bakassi Penisula: Nigeria and Cameroon
- Banc du Geyser: Madagascar, France and the Comoros
- (former) Bogomerom archipelago (parts): Chad and Nigeria
- Bure: Ethiopia and Eritrea
- Cabinda: Angola and Democratic Republic of the Congo
- Caprivi Strip boundary tripoints/quadripoint: Botswana, Namibia, Zambia and Zimbabwe
- Ceuta[2]Spain and Morocco
- Chagos Archipelago: United Kingdom (as British Indian Ocean Territory), Mauritius and the Seychelles
- Chirac pastures : Morocco and Algeria
- part of Gicumbi District, North Province: Rwanda and Uganda
- Glorioso Islands: France, Madagascar, the Seychelles and the Comoros
- Hala'ib Triangle: Egypt and Sudan
- Isla Perejil: Spain and Morocco
- Ilemi Triangle: Kenya, Ethiopia and Sudan
- part of Kabale District: Uganda and Rwanda
- Kangawane Swazi homelands in parts of Mpumalanga and Kwazulu Natal: South Africa and Swaziland
- Kariba Power Station and Sindabezi Island: Zambia and Zimbabwe
- Kasikili/Sedudu: Botswana and Namibia
- part of the Katemba region: Angola and the Democratic Republic of the Congo
- Koualou village: Burkina Faso and Benin
- Lete Island and neighbouring islands: Benin and Niger (adjudicated by the ICJ in 2005)
- area near Logoba/Moyo District: Sudan and Uganda
- Lunchinda-Pweto province: Zambia and Democratic Republic of the Congo
- Mayotte: France and Comoros[1]
- Mbanie Island, Cocotiers, and Congas: Gabon and Equatorial Guinea[3]
- Melilla[4]Spain and Morocco
- several islands in the River Ntem: Cameroon and Equatorial Guinea
- North West Niger (about 25,000 square km): Niger and Libya
- Ogaden: Ethiopia and Somalia
- several villages near the Okpara River: Benin and Niger
- Peñón de Alhucemas: Spain and Morocco
- the Rufunzo Valley and Sabererwa: Rwanda and Burundi
- South East Algeria: Algeria and Libya
- Socotra: Yemen and Somalia
- triangular area of land south east of Toummo: Niger and Libya
- Tromelin: France and Mauritius
- Tsorona-Zalambessa: Ethiopia and Eritrea
- Yenga (border hamlet): Sierra Leone and Guinea
[edit] In the Americas
- Ankoko Island : Guyana and Venezuela
- Arroyo de la Invernada : Brazil and Uruguay
- Atacama corridor: Chile and Bolivia
- Southern half of Belize: Belize and Guatemala
- Bajo Nuevo Bank (Petrel Islands): Colombia, United States, Jamaica (the only three active claims) and possibly Honduras
- Bird Island (Isla Aves): Venezuela and Dominica
- Brazilian Island : Brazil, Argentina and Uruguay
- Conejo Island: Honduras and El Salvador
- Falkland Islands: United Kingdom and Argentina[1]
- French Guiana west of the Marouini River: France and Suriname
- Green Island (Fortune), Newfoundland: Canada and France (St Pierre and Miquelon) NOTE Sovereignty undetermined
- Guantanamo Bay: United States of America (lease-holder; naval base and detention center) and Cuba[1]
- Guyana east of the Upper Courantyne River: Guyana and Suriname
- Guyana west of the Essequibo River (Guayana Esequiba): Guyana and Venezuela
- Hans Island: Denmark and Canada
- Los Monjes archipelago: Venezuela and Colombia[1]
- area near Mejito De La Cruz: Costa Rica and Nicaragua
- Navassa Island: United States of America (having possession) and Haiti[1]
- Pacific Ocean Sea border: Chile and Peru
- San Andrés and Providencia: Colombia and Nicaragua; Honduras de facto recognizes Colombian claim
- Sapodilla Cays: Belize, Guatemala (formerly claiming all Belize) and Honduras
- Sea Otter Rocks, Sea Lion Rock and Copper Island (Medny Island): United States of America and Russia. NOTE: Sovereignty undetermined; agreement to cede these areas to Russia has not been ratified by the Duma
- Serranilla Bank : Colombia, United States, Nicaragua and possibly Honduras
- South Georgia and the South Sandwich Islands & Shag Rocks: United Kingdom and Argentina[1]
- Southern Patagonian Ice Field between Mount Fitzroy and Cerro Daudet: Argentina and Chile (parts of the border still officially undefined)
- List of areas disputed by the United States (state mentioned first) and Canada (province or territory mentioned second)
- Machias Seal Island (Maine / New Brunswick)
- North Rock (Maine / New Brunswick)
- Strait of Juan de Fuca (Washington / British Columbia)
- Dixon Entrance (Alaska / British Columbia)
- Portland Canal (Alaska / British Columbia)
- Beaufort Sea (Alaska / Yukon)
- Northwest Passage and other Arctic waters (Claimed by U.S. to be international waters)
[edit] In Asia and the Pacific
- Abu Musa: Iran and the United Arab Emirates
- Aksai Chin: People's Republic of China, India and ROC[1][5]
- Arunachal Pradesh (South Tibet): India, People's Republic of China and ROC[5]
- Banaba Island: Kiribati and Fiji
- Bagys and Turkestan (village): Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan
- Bhutanese enclaves in Tibet, namely Cherkip Gompa, Dho, Dungmar, Gesur, Gezon, Itse Gompa, Khochar, Nyanri, Ringung, Sanmar, Tarchen and Zuthulphuk : People's Republic of China and Bhutan, also the Republic of China, unrecognized by either aforementioned state
- Bougainville : Papua New Guinea and the Solomon Islands
- Chumbi and Dobta: People's Republic of China, India and the Republic of China, unrecognized by either aforementioned state
- various areas: Dak Jerman/Dak Duyt, Dak Dang/Dak Huyt, the La Drang area and the islands of Baie/Koh Ta Kiev, Milieu/Koh Thmey, Eau/Koh Ses, Pic/Koh Tonsay and the Northern Pirates/Koh Po : Cambodia and Vietnam
- David Gareja monastery complex: Azerbaijan and Georgia
- Doi Lang: Myanmar and Thailand
- Dokdo (Takeshima in Japanese): South Korea, North Korea and Japan[6] (Japan does not recognize the statehood of North Korea.)[1]
- al-Duwaima Island: Yemen and Saudi Arabia
- 48 square miles (124 km²) of Jordanian territory: Syria and Jordan
- East Jerusalem : Israel and the Palestinian National Authority
- several areas in the Fergana Valley: Kyrgyzstan, Tajikstan and Uzbekistan
- Golan Heights: Israel and Syria
- Shebaa Farms: Israel, Syria, and Lebanon
- Greater and Lesser Tunbs: Iran and the United Arab Emirates
- Hatay: Turkey and Syria
- Hibernia Reef: Australia and Indonesia
- Indo-Bangladesh enclaves: India and Bangladesh
- Isfara Valley: Kyrgyzstan and Tajikstan
- former Princely State of Junagadh: India and Pakistan
- Karang Unarang: Indonesia and Malaysia
- Kashmir: Pakistan and India[1] NOTE, a small area is also claimed by Afghanistan, see Pakistan/Afghanistan dispute below.
- Kalapani region, also Susta region (part), and Antudanda area: India and Nepal
- KTM railway station in Tanjong Pagar: Malaysia and Singapore
- Lower Kurile Islands: Russia and Japan[1]
- Kula Kangri: Bhutan and the People's Republic of China, also the Republic of China, unrecognized by either state
- Ligitan and Sipidan: Malaysia and Indonesia
- Limbang area: Brunei and Malaysia
- Macclesfield Bank: People's Republic of China, Republic of China and Vietnam[5]
- Matthew and Hunter Islands: Vanuatu and France[1]
- Minerva Reefs: Tonga and Fiji
- Muhurichar river island: India and Bangladesh
- certain islands in the Naf River: Bangladesh and Myanmar
- Nawalparasi region: Nepal and India
- New Moore/ South Talpatty/ Purbasha Island: Bangladesh and India - dispute also deters maritime boundary delimitation in the Bay of Bengal.
- Northern Bhutan: Bhutan and The People's Republic of China
- parts of North West Frontier Province, Federally Administered Tribal Areas and Balochistan: Pakistan and Afghanistan
- small areas of Oecussi-Ambeno: East Timor and Indonesia
- Qarah and Umm Al Maradim: Kuwait and Saudi Arabia
- Quatern Island: India and Bangladesh
- Palau Batek/Fatu Sinai: Indonesia and East Timor
- Palmas Island: Indonesia and Philippines
- Paracel Islands: People's Republic of China, Republic of China and Vietnam[1][5]
- Pedra Branca/Pulau Batu Puteh: Singapore and Malaysia
- part of Poipet commune: Thailand and Cambodia
- Prachin Buri area: Thailand and Cambodia
- Pyrdiwah: India and Bangladesh
- Sabah (North Borneo): Malaysia and Philippines
- Sakhalin (southern): Russia (Japan has renounced Sakhalin pursuant to the San Francisco Peace Treaty without recognizing the Russian claim.)
- former Saudi-Iraqi neutral zone: Iraq and Saudi Arabia
- Scarborough Shoal: Philippines, People's Republic of China and Republic of China[5]
- Senkaku Islands (Diaoyu Tai): Japan, People's Republic of China and Republic of China[1][5]
- Shaksgam Valley: People's Republic of China and India
- Shatt Al-Arab: Iran and Iraq
- Siachen Glacier: India and Pakistan
- Sir Creek: India and Pakistan
- Socotra Rock: People's Republic of China, Republic of China, South Korea and North Korea
- Spratly Islands: People's Republic of China, Republic of China, Vietnam, Philippines (part), Malaysia (part) and Brunei (part)[1][5]
- Swains Island: United States and Tokelau
- parts of Three Pagodas Pass: Myanmar and Thailand
- Teraina: Kiribati and the United States of America
- Tumen River (disputed sovereignty of certain islands): People's Republic of China, Democratic People's Republic of Korea, Republic of Korea and the Republic of China[1][5][6]
- Vozrozhdeniya Island (now a peninsula): Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan
- Wake Island: United States and Marshall Islands[1]
- a small part of Xinjiang: the People's Republic of China, India and also the Republic of China, unrecognized by either state
- Wrangel Island, Herald Island and the De Long Islands: Russia and the State of Alaska. NOTE While a 1994 judgment by the State Court of Alaska claimed these areas to be illegally occupied Russian territory,[citation needed] the United States has never asserted a territorial claim to the islands[7]
- Yalu River (disputed sovereignty of certain islands): People's Republic of China, Democratic People's Republic of Korea, Republic of Korea and the Republic of China[1][5][6]
- Zarrara oilfield and Khor al-Odaid areas: the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia[1]
[edit] In Europe
- Barents Sea boundary dispute: Russia and Norway
- Bay of Piran, also hamlets of Bozini, Mlini, Škodelin and Škrile and much of the border area: Slovenia and Croatia
- Ems estuary and Dollart Bay (western part): Netherlands and Germany
- Ferdinandea: Italy, United Kingdom, France, Spain and possibly Malta, Algeria, Tunisia, Libya and Morocco
- Gibraltar: United Kingdom (as a UK Overseas Territory) and Spain[1]
- Isthmus between Gibraltar and Spain: United Kingdom and Spain
- Imia/Kardak: Greece and Turkey
- Ivangorod: Russia and Estonia
- Kosa Tuzla Island: Ukraine and Russia
- the areas of Debellde, Viti and the Sharr Triangle: Serbia, the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia and the UN-administered territory of Kosovo. NOTE One of the disputes is between The Special Representative of the UN Secretary-General and the Provisional Institutions of Self-Government of Kosovo, the other two are between FYROM and Kosovo
- Mont Blanc: France and Italy
- an area near Montalmus peak: Andorra and Spain
- Eastern coast of Narva river and Petseri region: Russia and Estonia
- Olivenza: Spain and Portugal
- Pechorsky District of Pskov Oblast: Russia and Estonia
- Pichvni: Georgia and Russia
- Prevlaka: Montenegro and Croatia
- Pytalovsky District of the Pskov Oblast/Abrene region: Russia and Latvia
- Rockall: United Kingdom, Republic of Ireland, Denmark and Iceland
- Sastavci: Serbia and Bosnia Herzegovina
- Ŝarengradska Ada: Serbia and Bosnia Herzegovina
- Sarych: Ukraine and Russia
- Snake Island: Ukraine and Romania
- Small 3m-by-60m strip next to Vatican City: the Holy See and Italy
- Veliki and Mali Škoj:Croatia and Bosnia and Herzegovina
[edit] Disputes between a state and its subnational entities, or between subnational entities
- Belgaum: Mahashtra and Karnataka in India
- Black Hills: United States government and the Lakota Nation
- Ceara and Piaui in Brazil
- Southern edge of Labrador: Quebec and Newfoundland and Labrador
- Large area of Yucatán Peninsula: Mexican states of Campeche and Quintana Roo
- Hawaii: United States government and Hawaiian sovereignty movement
[edit] Disputes involving parties that each have some territory under control but do not recognize each other
- See also: List of unrecognized countries
- Abkhazia: Republic of Abkhazia and Georgia
- Bhutan: Bhutan and Republic of China[5]
- Northern Cyprus: Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus and Republic of Cyprus
- Mainland China: People's Republic of China and Republic of China[5]
- a small area of Gilgit-Baltistan: Pakistan and Republic of China[5]
- Heixiazi / Bolshoy Ussuriyskiy (ended in 2004):
- Eastern half: Russia and Republic of China[8]
- Western half: People's Republic of China and Republic of China
- Israel proper: Israel and (unofficially) the Palestinian National Authority (The map of "liberated Palestine" on the official website of the PNA, official PA schoolbooks, and official emblem of the PNA, PLO, and other groups all include Israel's entire territory)[9] The Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs website display maps which show that the West Bank and the Gaza Strip are part of its territory. [1]
- Kachin State (north part west of Gaoligong Mountain (zh:高黎贡山), the white area on the lower (south) portion of the accomanying Chinese map west of Yunnan), and the Division of Sagaing: Myanmar and Republic of China[8]
- North Korea: Democratic People's Republic of Korea, Republic of Korea. The ROK's constitution states that "The territory of the Republic of Korea shall consist of the Korean peninsula and its adjacent islands."[10]
- South Korea: Republic of Korea, Democratic People's Republic of Korea
- Lachin corridor: Nagorno-Karabakh Republic and Azerbaijan
- Nagorno-Karabakh: Nagorno-Karabakh Republic and Azerbaijan
- Pamir Mountains (the white area on the left-hand (west) portion of the accomanying Chinese map west of Xinjiang):
- Northern and central parts: Tajikstan and Republic of China[8]
- Southern part: Afghanistan and Republic of China[8]
- Puntland: Puntland and Somalia
- part of Rason administrative division, Democratic People's Republic of Korea: Democratic People's Republic of Korea and the Republic of China
- HM Roughs Tower: the 'Principality' of Sealand and the United Kingdom
- Sanaag and Sool: Somaliland, Puntland and Somalia
- Sikkim: India and the Republic of China
- Sixty-Four Villages East of the Heilongjiang River: Russia and Republic of China[8]
- Somaliland: Somaliland and Somalia
- South Ossetia: Republic of South Ossetia and Georgia
- Northern and eastern Sri Lanka: Sri Lanka and Tamil Eelam
- 'border' checkpoint near Strovilia: The Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus and the United Kingdom (in regard to its' Sovereign Base Areas). NOTE: Technically, of course, this also involves Cyprus; the checkpoint is partially on UN-administered land, and Cyprus claims all of the island.
- Taiwan, the Pescadores, Quemoy, Matsu Islands, Pratas Islands: Republic of China and People's Republic of China. The ROC's constitution states that "The modifications of the functions, operations, and organization of the Taiwan Provincial Government may be specified by law."[11] The PRC's constitution states "Taiwan is part of the sacred territory of the People's Republic of China. It is the lofty duty of the entire Chinese people, including our compatriots in Taiwan, to accomplish the great task of reunifying the motherland."[12]
- Transnistria: Pridnestrovian Moldavian Republic and Moldova
- Tannu Uriankhai: Russia, Mongolia and Republic of China[8]
- Western Sahara: Morocco and the Polisario Front's auto-proclaimed Saharawi Arab Democratic Republic. The United Nations considers the sovereignty issue as unresolved pending a final solution. Sovereignty was relinquished by Spain in 1976. Mauritania's claim is dormant.
- West Bank: Israel and the Palestinian National Authority
[edit] Formally frozen dispute
- See also demilitarized zone
The Antarctic Treaty System, formed on 1 December 1959 and entered into force on 23 June 1961, establishes the legal framework for the management of Antarctica and provides administration for the continent, which is carried out through consultative member meetings. It freezes the territorial claims of all signatories (all claimants have acceded) for as long as the treaty is in force. However, it is not a final settlement; parties can choose to withdraw from the System at any time. Furthermore, only a minority of states have signed it, and it is not formally sanctioned by the United Nations. Thus, Antarctica remains the only part of the planet any (non-signatory) state can still lay claim to as terra nullius (on the grounds of it not having been part of any existing state's legal and effective territory).
When the Constitution of the Republic of China was adopted on 25 December 1947, the Republic of China did recognize the statehood of the People's Republic of Mongolia with Soviet pressure. After the UN General Assembly Resolution 505 was passed in 1952, the Republic of China withdrew such a recognition in 1953 and therefore claimed Greater Mongolia. The Republic of China has once again recognized the statehood of Mongolia in 2002, thus freezing the territorial claim, but as the Constitution of the Republic of China still mentions Mongolia in Article 119 that has not been superseded, there are different opinions as to whether such a recognition is constitutional. On 26 November 1993, the Judicial Yuan in its Interpretation 328 called the constitutional territory beyond the reach of judicial review and thus avoided the question as whether Mongolia should be considered the constitutional territory of the Republic of China.
[edit] Note
Over 1.5% of the world's population live in an area disputed by two (or more) countries that are members of the United Nations. This rises to around 25% when the areas and regions where territorial claims are made by two or more parties that do not recognize each other is included, although much of this comes from the Republic of China's claim to mainland China.
[edit] Disputes between a state and a secessionist group with no territorial control
[edit] References
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u Field Listing - Disputes - international, CIA World Factbook
- ^ http://www.iht.com/articles/2006/01/31/news/spain.php
- ^ Compte rendu du déplacement d'une délégation du groupe interparlementaire France-Afrique centrale au Gabon, en Guinée équatoriale et à Sao Tomé-et-Principe, parliamentary report of the French Senate, 2003.
- ^ http://www.iht.com/articles/2006/01/31/news/spain.php
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l The Republic of China (ROC) now based in Taiwan is involved in territorial disputes with many countries near China while not recognized by any of them due to having no diplomatic relations. The ROC recognizes neither the People's Republic of China (PRC) nor its border agreements or treaties with any other countries while Article 4 of the Constitution of the Republic of China states that "The territory of the Republic of China according to its existing national boundaries shall not be altered except by resolution of the National Assembly."
- ^ a b c The Democratic People's Republic of Korea (North Korea) and the Republic of Korea (South Korea) do not recognize each other.
- ^ Status of Wrangel and Other Arctic Islands U.S. Department of State Fact Sheet on Wrangel Island
- ^ a b c d e f Relinquished by the People's Republic of China but still claimed by the Republic of China.
- ^ When the Palestinians say "End of occupation", what do they mean?
- ^ s:Constitution of the Republic of Korea, Article 3
- ^ s:Additional Articles of the Constitution of the Republic of China, Article 9, Section 2
- ^ s:Constitution of the People's Republic of China, Preamble